Skip to content
Sign up free
Criminal Justice

Life Without Parole Is Supposed to Be Final. California Is Testing That.

Life Without Parole Is Supposed to Be Final. California Is Testing That.

California is testing whether life without parole sentences can be revisited, sparking a legal battle over who gets to decide: lawmakers, judges, or an appointed parole board.

By Keila DeFede

4-minute read

In 1999, a Sacramento judge sentenced David Funston to three consecutive life terms for kidnapping and molesting young children. In 2010, Melissa Huckaby pleaded guilty to kidnapping and murdering 8-year-old Sandra Cantu and was sentenced to life without the possibility of parole.

Prosecutors, police, and Sandra's family all believed those cases were closed.

Both are back in the news.

One change came from a law passed by the legislature. The other came from rules written by an appointed state board. Whether that difference matters is now a question for a Sacramento courtroom.

From Prosecutor to Plaintiff

The cases are the subject of two recent episodes of Inside the Crime Files (Funston, Cantu). The show is hosted by Anne Marie Schubert, who spent more than 30 years as a prosecutor and eight as Sacramento County's elected district attorney, where she led the prosecution of the Golden State Killer.

Schubert left the Republican Party in 2018 and ran for attorney general in 2022 with no party preference. She drew about 8% of the vote in the Top Two primary.

In January 2026, she became president and CEO of the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, a Sacramento nonprofit focused on victims' rights. The foundation is now suing the state over one of the policies discussed below.

"The justice system makes promises to those families," Schubert says on the Funston episode. "Some of those promises are spoken out loud in a courtroom. Some are just understood."

Three Life Terms, One Parole Hearing

In 1995, Funston spent months luring young children in Sacramento County into his car with toys and candy. Detectives had no suspect until Nancy Hunnicutt, home for lunch one day, saw a stranger put two of her young neighbors in his car, yelled at him from her window and gave 911 his license plate. He let the girls go, and the plate led police to Funston. Schubert prosecuted him, and a jury convicted him on 16 felony counts.

In September 2025, the Board of Parole Hearings found Funston suitable for release under California's Elderly Parole Program. A 2020 law made people eligible for a parole hearing once they are 50 years old and have served 20 years. Gov. Gavin Newsom sent the decision back for review, and in February 2026 the full board reaffirmed it.

The governor could not overturn it. Under the state constitution, that power applies only to murder cases.

Funston was stopped on the day of his release only because Placer County prosecutors filed new charges tied to a 1996 Roseville case. He remains in custody.

Sacramento County Sheriff Jim Cooper, a guest on the episode, read the board's hearing records. He notes that Funston himself described his attraction to children as "lifelong," and questions how "the unelected parole board" approved his release anyway.

The case pushed lawmakers to act. In September 2026, Newsom signed AB 2727, which raises the elderly parole age to 65 for people convicted of certain serious sex offenses against children and requires a psychological risk screening before parole.

A Plea Deal's Promise

The second episode goes to Tracy, where Sandra Cantu disappeared from her mobile home park on March 27, 2009. Her body was found about 10 days later inside a suitcase belonging to Huckaby, a neighbor whose daughter often played with Sandra.

San Joaquin County District Attorney Ron Freitas ran the homicide unit at the time. He says prosecutors offered a plea to life without parole partly so the family would never face appeals or parole hearings. The promise, he says, was that Huckaby "would never step foot as a free person outside of a prison."

On Oct. 1, 2026, new Board of Parole Hearings regulations took effect. They create a process to review people who have served at least 25 consecutive years, including many serving life without parole. The board can then refer some of them to a court for resentencing or to the governor for a commutation.

More than 2,400 people could be eligible, according to the foundation.

"It's a slap in the face," says Sandra's aunt, Angie Chavez. "Life without the possibility of parole. What does that mean? It means life without the possibility of parole. Period."

Freitas argues the board is doing something lawmakers have refused to do in public. Bills like this "always fail" when legislators have to put their names on them, he says. "This is the type of thing that lives in the dark."

The Case for a Second Look

The board says the debate overstates what its rules do. The regulations "do not authorize the release of any inmate," it said in response to the lawsuit. They set up a process for preparing public safety risk assessments. Any decision to shorten a sentence stays with a judge or the governor.

Supporters of elderly parole point to outcomes. Keith Wattley, founder of the prisoner advocacy group UnCommon Law, told CalMatters he knows of no case of "a single person who had a sex offense, was released with elderly parole, and committed a new sex offense after the release."

Jennifer Shaffer, a former executive officer of the board, told the same outlet that the law leaves the board little choice: "the board must release someone if they no longer pose a current, unreasonable risk to the public." She added that the board employs about 70 forensic psychologists to make that assessment.

The ACLU of California opposed AB 2727, arguing that release rates are already low and prisons remain overcrowded.

Who Decides?

The Funston and Cantu cases raise the same question from different directions.

Elderly parole is a law. Voters can hold the legislators who passed it accountable, and the Legislature has already changed it once in response to Funston.

The life-without-parole review is a set of regulations. It was adopted by a board whose members are appointed by the governor and confirmed by the state Senate, not by a vote of the Legislature or the public.

Schubert's foundation, joined by the Peace Officers Research Association of California and victims' families including Chavez, sued in July. They argue the board went beyond its authority and changed sentencing law on its own. The state corrections department has said the rules simply create "a more transparent process" for referrals and that final decisions remain with the governor or the courts. The case is pending in Sacramento Superior Court.

Schubert has said her group will pursue a ballot measure if the courts and the Legislature don't act.

For Chavez, the reason to keep fighting is simple.

"I have to do this," she says. "I would feel horrible if anybody had their killer out because of me not doing something about it."

Disclosure: Inside the Crime Files is supported by the Independent Voter Project, which also funds IVN, and is produced by Olas Media.

Adhere to the IVN etiquette

By posting a comment, you agree to adhere to our etiquette rules: No partisan attacks, no personal attacks, substantiate your sources, no self-promotion.

Get IVN’s Free Weekly Newsletter:Get IVN’s Free Newsletter

Get IVN’s Free Weekly Newsletter:Get IVN’s Free Newsletter

Nonpartisan Issues. Diverse Perspectives.

Check your inbox and click the link to confirm.

Republish this article

Republishing guidelines

Republish IVN articles for free. Independent Voter News articles may be republished online or in print under a Creative Commons BY-NC-ND 4.0 license, on these terms:

  1. Credit the author and IVN. Keep the byline ("By Author Name, Independent Voter News") and the attribution note at the end, which links to the original.
  2. Point search engines to the original. Set the canonical URL of your copy to the original IVN article (the HTML we give you includes the tag).
  3. Keep the meaning. You may update time and place references and apply your house style. You may trim for length, as long as the cuts don't change the meaning or misrepresent the author. Keep the headline. Mark any additions as your own (for example "Additional reporting by ...").
  4. Translations are welcome. Translate faithfully, add "Translated from English by [your outlet]", and tell us at editor@ivn.us.
  5. Keep the links, including the link to the original article.
  6. Keep the tracking image. The HTML includes a 1-pixel image that counts readers on your page. It collects no personal information.
  7. Photos and illustrations. Images credited to IVN may be used with this article only. Images credited to others (AP, Getty, Unsplash, Wikimedia and so on) stay under their owners' terms. Secure the rights or switch "Include images" off.
  8. Don't sell it. You can't sell our articles or sell ads specifically against them. Your normal site advertising is fine.
  9. No implied endorsement. Don't suggest that IVN or the author endorses you, your candidates or your causes, or that donations to you support IVN.
  10. Keep labels. Opinion or analysis pieces keep that label.
  11. No bulk or automated republishing, and don't submit our articles to aggregators (Apple News, Google News, MSN) as your own.
  12. Corrections and removals. Update your copy when we correct it, and remove it promptly if we ask. We'll contact you at the email you give us.
  13. Questions or print republication: editor@ivn.us.

IVN staff: fill in who you're inviting above, then create the invite.

Preparing the article

Life Without Parole Is Supposed to Be Final. California Is Testing That.

Choose a format
  • HTML
  • Email HTML
  • Markdown
  • Formatted (.docx)
  • Plain text
  • WordPress blocks
  • PDF
Choose a platform

Photos credited to others need their owners' permission.

To for

Republishing somewhere else? Questions? editor@ivn.us