logo

Transparency Advocates Concerned With San Diego City Attorney Mara Elliott's Public Records Bill

image
Author: Jeff Powers
Created: 07 March, 2019
Updated: 21 November, 2022
2 min read

San Diego, Calif.-  San Diego City Attorney Mara Elliott has created government transparency concerns with her drafting of Senate Bill 615.

Elliott says her bill is a win-win for transparency and the taxpayers:

"Ensuring the public’s access to information is critical, yet in recent years, the City of San Diego, and public agencies statewide, have struggled to keep up with a widening avalanche of Public Records Act requests," Elliott noted.

SB 615 would require public agencies and record-seekers to engage in a “meet and confer” session — basically, a conversation aimed at resolving disputes in good faith before misunderstandings can escalate and a lawsuit follows.

Elliott contends the “meet and confer” process will prevent those unnecessary lawsuits and expensive judgments.

A Hinderance For The Public

"This action adds an unnecessary layer of bureaucracy to an already challenging process for the public." - Former San Diego City Councilwoman Donna Frye

Former San Diego City Councilwoman Donna Frye says the "meet and confer" provision will only make the process more burdensome for the public.

"To say that this bill is to help the public is just not believable. This needs to be stopped as it has nothing to do with streamlining the process for the public," Frye continued, "The easiest way to make sure the public has those documents is to post them online. Pretty simple. Make is easy, not more difficult."

Frye, a longtime champion of government transparency, also raised questions regarding the legal jurisdiction of the City Attorney's office.

IVP Existence Banner

"Why is the San Diego City Attorney driving statewide legislation," Frye quipped, "and why hasn't the city council, the true legislative body of the City of San Diego, not weighed in on something so fundamental? Or are they going to have the City Attorney now handle the legislative branch of government."

Frye is not alone in her criticism.

Flood of Criticism

News organizations and public watchdog advocates like attorney and San Diego Mayoral candidate Cory Briggs, has been very critical of the SB-615 language drafted by Elliott and her office.

On his twitter feed, Briggs noted his concerns:

"Let's review all the things that @CityAttorneySD and @MaraWElliott didn't tell @SenBenHueso before they duped him into carrying their dirty water in gutting the California Public Records Act. Ben isn't dumb, but he's got rolled by Mara."

Briggs also raised the point that in these cases, public sector lawyers like City Attorney Mara Elliott, are immune from malpractice judgments:

Hueso Hedging? 

State Senator Ben Hueso, who was poised to bring SB-615 to the floor in Sacramento, now tells IVN he will not move forward with ANY legislation that compromises government transparency.

IVP Existence Banner

Importantly, the final language of SB-615, will be drafted by Legislative Counsel in consultation with Senator Hueso’s staff.

In a statement to IVN, Hueso expressed his goals for SB-615. “My objective is to protect taxpayers while increasing transparency in government," promising, “I will not move forward with any legislation that compromises the obligation of government to be transparent in any way.”

Latest articles

vote
It's Time to Let All Voters Vote in South Dakota's Taxpayer-Funded Primaries
Unfortunately, the upcoming 2024 South Dakota primary election promises more of the same for our state....
15 March, 2024
-
5 min read
TikTok
TikTok Has No Place in the Two-Party Duopoly
The US House of Representatives voted 352-65 Wednesday in favor of a bill (HR 7521) that would ban TikTok, a social media app used by approximately 170 million Americans, if Chinese tech company ByteDance refuses to divest from it....
13 March, 2024
-
7 min read
make every vote count
Report: 6-in-10 New Voters Register Unaffiliated in States that Suppress Independent Voters
Mounting research continues to show the real truth behind independent voter suppression in several states across the US....
12 March, 2024
-
3 min read
voter at polls
17% More Votes Count Under Ranked Choice Voting, Study Finds
A new study analyzing all single-winner ranked choice voting (RCV) elections since 2004 reveals a significant increase in meaningful votes and representation in elections under RCV....
12 March, 2024
-
2 min read
vote sticker
Ohio Bill Would Force Party Affiliation on Voters -- Whether They Want It or Not
Photo Credit:  Ohio has open partisan primaries that do not require party affiliation as a condition...
10 March, 2024
-
3 min read
texas
Two Key TX House Races Head to Expensive and Unnecessary Runoff Elections
Two US House primaries in Texas are headed for runoffs in May. Voters who are already exhausted with the political process will be asked to go to the polls in elections that historically draw in half of the March primary's turnout -- which was abysmally low in 2024....
07 March, 2024
-
4 min read