Study: Breaking National Trends, CA's Top-Two Primary Increased Competition and Decreased Polarization

Published: 26 Sep, 2023
1 min read

California is one of only a few states that has broken the trend of increased polarization, according to a report released earlier this year. And the most significant thing that separates California's elections from other states is the use of a nonpartisan top-two primary.

Open Primaries hosted a virtual discussion with Dr. Richard Barton, author of the Unite America Institute study titled, "“California’s Top-Two Primary: The Effects on Electoral Politics and Governance.” The report was published on the 13th anniversary of Top-Two's passage by California voters under Proposition 14 in June 2010.

Barton discussed a range of topics with regards to his study, which found that not only has California depolarized to a degree, but it is also one of only a few states that broke the trend of escalating polarization. It also saw increased electoral competition under a nonpartisan primary system.

It is not the only research that has come to this conclusion about Top-Two in California. Over the last decade, study after study after study have looked at voter participation, impact, electoral competition, and confidence in state government -- and they all come to the same conclusion:

Top-two has changed California elections to give voters greater accountability, better representation, and more competition -- particularly in the primaries where all voters and candidates, regardless of party affiliation, participate on the same ballot.

READ MORE: Unite America: California's Top-Two Primary Changed the Game for Better Elections

The passage of California's Proposition 14, authored by the Independent Voter Project, showed the nation what was possible, and Barton's study adds to the success story that has unfolded over the last decade and shows the potential of where Top Two can go not only in California, but in other states across the country.

Check out the full conversation with Dr. Barton above.

You Might Also Like

Paul Rieckhoff Tells Stephen Colbert: Voters Shouldn't Have to Pick a Party to Matter
Paul Rieckhoff Tells Stephen Colbert: Voters Shouldn't Have to Pick a Party to Matter
Paul Rieckhoff wears many hats. He is a veteran of the Iraq War, founded Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America, national security analyst, author, producer, podcaster, and founder of Independent Veterans of America....
11 Mar, 2026
-
2 min read
Did New Petition Rules Kill Oklahoma’s Open Primaries Initiative?
Did New Petition Rules Kill Oklahoma’s Open Primaries Initiative?
Last week, the Oklahoma campaign to put a nonpartisan all-voter and all-candidate nonpartisan primary initiative on the ballot was informed that it did not collect enough signatures to be certified. This means state voters won’t get a say on the matter in 2026....
10 Mar, 2026
-
5 min read
How James Talarico Won Over Independents Amid Texas Primary Chaos
How James Talarico Won Over Independents Amid Texas Primary Chaos
James Talarico wins Texas’ Democratic Senate primary as campaigns point to unusually high independent participation in the state’s open primary system. Then Dallas County’s last-minute switch back to precinct-only voting sparks confusion, long lines, and a legal fight over ballots cast after 7 p.m....
05 Mar, 2026
-
3 min read
Don’t Kill Top Two. Upgrade It: A Smarter Way to Elect California’s Governor
Don’t Kill Top Two. Upgrade It: A Smarter Way to Elect California’s Governor
The answer to today’s crowded field is not retreat. It is modernization. Instead of empowering party gatekeepers, we can empower voters with more choice, less vote splitting, and majority-supported outcomes....
03 Mar, 2026
-
4 min read
No Referee in the Midterms? Trump’s FEC Nominations Come After 10 Months of Zero Federal Oversight
No Referee in the Midterms? Trump’s FEC Nominations Come After 10 Months of Zero Federal Oversight
As February wrapped up, it was reported that President Donald Trump had nominated two Republicans for the Federal Elections Commission after 10 months of the agency being unable to perform its basic functions....
02 Mar, 2026
-
9 min read
America at 250: Independent Voters Declare Independence from the Two-Party System
America at 250: Independent Voters Declare Independence from the Two-Party System
On February 27, 2026, the better elections group Open Primaries released a sweeping public statement titled Declaration of Independents, framing the exclusion of independent voters from critical taxpayer-funded elections as the unfinished business of 1776....
27 Feb, 2026
-
3 min read