Skip to content
Sign up free
Commentary

American Capitalism Is Bad Economics: Democratic Enterprise Would Rejuvenate Society

American Capitalism Is Bad Economics: Democratic Enterprise Would Rejuvenate Society
Image Credit: Aditya Vyas on Unsplash

William Halal, a senior business professor, entrepreneur, and future forecaster, argues that our country’s fixation on money is woefully bad at serving social needs, economic productivity, and global competitiveness.

By William E. Halal

4-minute read

Our reliance on the “invisible hand” of capitalism to form “perfect markets” that “efficiently serve social interests” is a beautiful theory, but it’s out of touch with economic reality. Yes, American capitalism leads the world at innovation. As a senior business professor, however, I’ve learned that our fixation on money is woefully bad at serving social needs, economic productivity, and global competitiveness. 

For example, after decades of concern over gross inequality, average CEO pay recently rose to almost $19 million per year. Meanwhile, worker pay was largely unchanged. The U.S. has the greatest share of low-wage jobs in the modern world, with the bottom 20 percent living in poverty. During the COVID pandemic, while most Americans were struggling with unemployment, billionaires gained $1 trillion. The gains went largely to Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk and exceeded the GDPs of 139 countries. 

It gets worse. American employees have lost roughly half of their normal share of economic output since the Reagan “revolution” glorified unfettered business. Many even claimed, “greed is good.” A RAND study found that American workers would be receiving $100,000 per year instead of $50,000 today if normal pay rates had held during the past few decades. All told, business moved $50 trillion from the middle class to the top 1 percent of society — the “Great Wealth Transfer.”  

This profit-centered system is not only wanting in human and social terms, it’s bad economics. Income inequality decreased U.S. GDP by 5 percent over the past two decades. Global competitiveness ratings show that the UK, EU, Canada, and other leading nations often beat the U.S. in economic performance. They also provide their citizens with universal health care, free college, financial security, and other benefits Americans can only wish for. These nations also rank at the top of the UN happiness ratings. 

All this changed dramatically in 2019 when the Business Roundtable announced the end of shareholder primacy and now advocates serving customers, employees, suppliers and communities, as well as shareholders. Soon, 90 percent of corporations practiced Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) principles to incorporate social interests. 

This affront to capitalism led some to condemn it as “woke.” Leading the charge was the richest man in the world, Elon Musk, who said, “ESG is a corrupted lie. It needs to end,” while the columnist George Will wrote: “ESG is the stealthy…semi-confiscation of wealth.” 

Lost in this controversy was the stark realization that CEOs are not doing this out of altruism but out of necessity. Fox News reported that nearly all Fortune 500 companies have maintained their commitments despite campaigns against them. 

Here’s how Larry Fink, CEO of BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager, explained it: “Stakeholder capitalism is not about politics.… It is not ‘woke.’ It is…mutually beneficial relationships [with] the employees, customers, suppliers, and communities your company relies on to prosper.” 

Indeed, a committed fringe of corporations (Johnson & Johnson, Nucor Steel, IKEA, Mondragon, etc.) have thrived for decades by working with their stakeholders. But the concept is largely ignored because it clashes with the prevailing profit-focused culture. The challenge now is to bring this superior form of business into the mainstream. 

My studies show that stakeholders are similar to shareholders. They all invest resources, incur costs, and gain benefits. Any enterprise is basically a socio-economic system composed of key stakeholders that perform crucial functions. The obvious need is to integrate all these interests into a more productive whole. Done well, collaboration could more effectively benefit all interests, including making more money for shareholders. It can be a competitive advantage. 

True, a human-centered business could degenerate into unsustainable philanthropy. The key to success is to form stakeholder partnerships that solve strategic problems and create added value. In the end, any viable enterprise must be productive to survive in a competitive marketplace. Social responsibility and ethics are commendable, but it takes active collaboration to resolve tough challenges and create economic and social benefits.  

The concept could also be called a form of “economic democracy,” a “corporate community,” or a “collaborative business.” The emerging system is no longer based primarily on capital, but on the participation of all stakeholders. That’s why I use the term “democratic enterprise.” 

Historic change like this is difficult but there are compelling advantages. A democratic enterprise softens the harshness of markets. Bringing stakeholders into partnerships reduces their potential for disruption and risk. It could also become a self-regulating system to avoid hobbling business with excessive regulation. 

Democratic enterprise could prove to be a boon for America’s role in the world. The major stakeholders form a five-pointed star — a powerful symbol from the nation’s flag.  

Embracing democratic enterprise would resolve the obscene gap between the working class and billionaire oligarchs, transforming managers from greedy pariahs into servant leaders. It could even allow the U.S. to lead the world into a new era that celebrates collaboration.  What can we do as individuals? We should understand this needed change and expect organizations to cooperate with us as employees, consumers, citizens, business partners, and investors. Together, we could create a second American Revolution to a more powerful economic consciousness. 


William E. Halal, PhD, is professor emeritus at George Washington University, Washington, DC, and founder of the TechCast Project. Previously, he served as a major in the US Air Force, an aerospace engineer on the Apollo Program, and a business manager in Silicon Valley. Halal also worked for Grumman Aerospace Company on the lunar module of the Apollo program and served on the team responsible for designing the rocket engine that landed the first men on the moon. He has published eight books and hundreds of articles, consults for corporations and governments, and is a frequent speaker, once substituting for Peter Drucker. His new book, One World? The Digital Revolution and the Rise of Global Consciousness (Amplify Publishing, Aug. 4, 2026), already Amazon’s #1 Best Seller on Globalization, forecasts an emerging Global Consciousness. Learn more at billhalal.com; and view this video with futurist Gerd Leonhard.

Tags: Commentary

Adhere to the IVN etiquette

By posting a comment, you agree to adhere to our etiquette rules: No partisan attacks, no personal attacks, substantiate your sources, no self-promotion.

Get IVN’s Free Weekly Newsletter:Get IVN’s Free Newsletter

Get IVN’s Free Weekly Newsletter:Get IVN’s Free Newsletter

Nonpartisan Issues. Diverse Perspectives.

Check your inbox and click the link to confirm.

Republish this article

Republishing guidelines

Republish IVN articles for free. Independent Voter News articles may be republished online or in print under a Creative Commons BY-NC-ND 4.0 license, on these terms:

  1. Credit the author and IVN. Keep the byline ("By Author Name, Independent Voter News") and the attribution note at the end, which links to the original.
  2. Point search engines to the original. Set the canonical URL of your copy to the original IVN article (the HTML we give you includes the tag).
  3. Keep the meaning. You may update time and place references and apply your house style. You may trim for length, as long as the cuts don't change the meaning or misrepresent the author. Keep the headline. Mark any additions as your own (for example "Additional reporting by ...").
  4. Translations are welcome. Translate faithfully, add "Translated from English by [your outlet]", and tell us at editor@ivn.us.
  5. Keep the links, including the link to the original article.
  6. Keep the tracking image. The HTML includes a 1-pixel image that counts readers on your page. It collects no personal information.
  7. Photos and illustrations. Images credited to IVN may be used with this article only. Images credited to others (AP, Getty, Unsplash, Wikimedia and so on) stay under their owners' terms. Secure the rights or switch "Include images" off.
  8. Don't sell it. You can't sell our articles or sell ads specifically against them. Your normal site advertising is fine.
  9. No implied endorsement. Don't suggest that IVN or the author endorses you, your candidates or your causes, or that donations to you support IVN.
  10. Keep labels. Opinion or analysis pieces keep that label.
  11. No bulk or automated republishing, and don't submit our articles to aggregators (Apple News, Google News, MSN) as your own.
  12. Corrections and removals. Update your copy when we correct it, and remove it promptly if we ask. We'll contact you at the email you give us.
  13. Questions or print republication: editor@ivn.us.

IVN staff: fill in who you're inviting above, then create the invite.

Preparing the article

American Capitalism Is Bad Economics: Democratic Enterprise Would Rejuvenate Society

Choose a format
  • HTML
  • Email HTML
  • Markdown
  • Formatted (.docx)
  • Plain text
  • WordPress blocks
  • PDF
Choose a platform

Photos credited to others need their owners' permission.

To for

Republishing somewhere else? Questions? editor@ivn.us