News broke Tuesday that a panel of federal judges struck down North Carolina’s congressional map, ruling that it constituted an illegal gerrymander. But unlike gerrymandering rulings in the past, the decision had nothing to do with racial or class discrimination, but partisan discrimination.
It is the first time a federal court has struck down congressional maps on the grounds of partisan gerrymandering. The court ordered the General Assembly to redraw the map.
“On its most fundamental level, partisan gerrymandering violates ‘the core principle of republican government . . . that the voters should choose their representatives, not the other way around,’” states the majority opinion.
The decision is expected to be appealed to the US Supreme Court, which is already considering a partisan gerrymandering case out of Wisconsin, Gill v. Whitford.
In October, the high court heard oral argument in the Wisconsin case, which deals with state legislative districts, and is expected to hand down a ruling later this year.
The news out of North Carolina reinvigorated calls for redistricting reform in North Carolina, with many people calling for an independent redistricting commission to draw electoral maps.
Ideally, an independent redistricting commission takes power out of the hands of partisans in the legislature to pick their voters, which further allows them to suppress the voice of voters in the political minority.
Currently, 14 states use a bipartisan or independent redistricting commission or group of some kind to draw state legislative and/or congressional districts. Six of these states use nonpartisan commissions.
The voters in every state need districts determined by independent commissions with opportunity for public comment
— Hope Chase (@Hope_Hartley) January 10, 2018
Thank you Senator! Our fight for #FairMaps is about ensuring voters have real representation & a voice in government. It’s time to end gerrymandering and move to independent redistricting across the country – including in your home state of Minnesota!https://t.co/3fAmrbDrAk
— Common Cause (@CommonCause) January 10, 2018
— Searcy for NC Senate 17 (@ElectSamSearcy) January 10, 2018
Huge news! NC Congressional map 1st ever struck down for unconstitutional partisan #Gerrymandering #Voters should pick their politicians & not other way around! I support campaign finance reform & independent redistricting. Donate to #PreserveOurDemocracy https://t.co/66C6XJz5OW pic.twitter.com/kLS0WsV0Uk
— Dr. Kyle Horton (@drkyle4congress) January 10, 2018
Time for an independent nonpartisan electoral commission. Though you may have to look outside the US for independents.
— Janet Shannon (@JannnetShannnon) January 10, 2018
What’s it gonna take for NC to redraw the lines constitutionally? Or better yet put in an independent commission to draw the lines? https://t.co/2zij84K3Qg
— Christina Henderson (@HendWex) January 10, 2018
All Congressional district lines should be drawn by an independent, non-partisan commission which ensures fair representation for the constituents. It makes no sense that people in power get to decide who votes for them.https://t.co/E3ZqKM8KlZ
— Ben Allain (@BenAllain) January 10, 2018
You Might Also Be Interested In...
Voters, Not Politicians: The Fight over Gerrymandering Heats Up