logo

Congressman Expresses Difficulty in Challenging Citizens United in Hyper-Partisan Environment

image
Created: 22 January, 2016
Updated: 16 October, 2022
3 min read

On Thursday, the sixth anniversary of the controversial Citizens United decision, U.S. Rep. Scott Peters (D-Calif.) held a press conference at North Clairemont Community Park in San Diego with CalPIRG to express support for campaign finance reform.

Peters called for an amendment to overturn the 2010 Supreme Court ruling in Citizens United v. FEC, the decision that struck down legal limits on the amount of money corporations, labor unions, and certain special interest groups can spend on elections.

The case led to the creation of Super PACs and “dark money” groups that do not need to disclose the sources of their donations.

“Six years of anonymous Super PACs controlling elections is long enough, and we need to send a message to Congress to adopt a constitutional amendment to overturn Citizens United,” Peters said. “It's time to bring the focus back to policy, to the issues, to the job we were expected to do.”

When asked by an IVN correspondent if such an amendment would extend to campaign donations from political parties, he said it certainly should be a part of the discussion as well.

However, the path to ratifying any constitutional amendment that would overturn the Citizens United ruling remains unclear. The last time an amendment was added to the Constitution was in 1992, and though that doesn't seem that long ago, what we know today as the Twenty-Seventh Amendment was originally introduced in 1789.

There are only a few ways a proposed amendment to the U.S. Constitution can go from proposal to ratification. First, the proposed amendment must be approved and sent to the states by:

  • The U.S. Congress with a two-thirds vote in both the House and the Senate; or
  • A national convention, called by Congress for this specific purpose or two-thirds (34) of the state legislatures.

Then, to become a part of the Constitution, an amendment must be ratified by:

  • Three-fourths (38) of the state legislatures; or
  • State ratifying conventions in three-fourths of the states.

In the history of the United States, a national convention has never been called by either Congress or two-thirds of the states (though there have been a couple of close calls). Amendments have always come from Congress and then ratified by the state legislatures, which in the current political environment seems highly improbable.

IVP Existence Banner

When asked about the chances of such an amendment passing a Congress held up by continuous gridlock, Peters acknowledged the frustration with the status quo on both sides of the aisle. He hopes that speaking up about Citizens United will spur voters to raise the issue to the 2016 presidential candidates and turn it into a national discussion. Then, the proposed amendment could at least come to a vote on the floor.

Peters also touched on other ways to address campaign finance reform. One provision in his plan would mandate that Super PACs disclose their financial backers, a measure that the Obama administration is currently considering to enact through executive order. He also pointed to his support for the Government by the People Act, a bill that would encourage small campaign donations by creating a matching fund.

“If we're going to get a change,” Peters said, “it's going to be because people are saying, 'we see that money in politics affects us because we're not attending to the things we should be.'"

Image: U.S. Rep. Scott Peters (D-Calif.) / Source: Shawn M. Griffiths, IVN News

Latest articles

vote
It's Time to Let All Voters Vote in South Dakota's Taxpayer-Funded Primaries
Unfortunately, the upcoming 2024 South Dakota primary election promises more of the same for our state....
15 March, 2024
-
5 min read
TikTok
TikTok Has No Place in the Two-Party Duopoly
The US House of Representatives voted 352-65 Wednesday in favor of a bill (HR 7521) that would ban TikTok, a social media app used by approximately 170 million Americans, if Chinese tech company ByteDance refuses to divest from it....
13 March, 2024
-
7 min read
make every vote count
Report: 6-in-10 New Voters Register Unaffiliated in States that Suppress Independent Voters
Mounting research continues to show the real truth behind independent voter suppression in several states across the US....
12 March, 2024
-
3 min read
voter at polls
17% More Votes Count Under Ranked Choice Voting, Study Finds
A new study analyzing all single-winner ranked choice voting (RCV) elections since 2004 reveals a significant increase in meaningful votes and representation in elections under RCV....
12 March, 2024
-
2 min read
vote sticker
Ohio Bill Would Force Party Affiliation on Voters -- Whether They Want It or Not
Photo Credit:  Ohio has open partisan primaries that do not require party affiliation as a condition...
10 March, 2024
-
3 min read
texas
Two Key TX House Races Head to Expensive and Unnecessary Runoff Elections
Two US House primaries in Texas are headed for runoffs in May. Voters who are already exhausted with the political process will be asked to go to the polls in elections that historically draw in half of the March primary's turnout -- which was abysmally low in 2024....
07 March, 2024
-
4 min read