Latest Poll Points to Potential Trouble for 'Top Two' Measure in South Dakota

vote
Photo by Alex Shuper on Unsplash+. Unsplash+ license obtained by author.
Published: 22 Oct, 2024
Updated: 18 Jun, 2025
2 min read

Photo Credit: Alex Shuper / Unsplash

 

Amendment H, which would implement a nonpartisan top two primary system in South Dakota, may be in serious trouble. That is, if a recent South Dakota News Watch poll is accurate.

The poll, co-sponsored by the Chiesman Center for Democracy at USD, found that 55.8% of respondents said they plan to vote "No" on Amendment H, while 39.8% said "Yes."

This left only 4.4% undecided. 

News Watch Poll

"The challenge with our Top Two open primary proposal is to make people aware of exactly how it works," said Joe Kirby of South Dakota Open Primaries.

"Once they understand that, they tend to say things like 'of course, why wouldn't we want that?'"

The primary election system proposed by Amendment H ends party primaries that are paid for by taxpayers but are closed to citizens outside the Republican and Democratic Parties.

It replaces this partisan primary system with a nonpartisan model in which all voters and candidates, regardless of party, have access to a single primary ballot.

IVP Donate

Every candidate that qualifies to run in an election appears on the ballot, and every registered voter has an opportunity to vote for whomever they want in each race.

The top vote-getters move on to the general election to decide the winner between who voters determined to be the two most viable candidates.

Alaska, California, and Washington use similar primary systems. In Alaska, the top four vote-getters advance to the general election. 

“The main argument for this amendment is fairness,” said Kirby. “All voters should have an equal voice in electing their representatives and leaders.”

Polling in June had Amendment H in a promising position. Then, 55% of respondents said they supported open primaries -- up from November 2023 when it was at 49%.

Now, the numbers have flipped.

The June and October polls were conducted by South Dakota News Watch and the Chiesman Center for Democracy and surveyed 500 registered voters. 

The latest poll has a +/- 4.5% margin of error. 

Let Us Vote : Sign Now!

Related articles

Political cartoon of a person representing partisanship, unions, the Democratic Party, and Special Interests taking a bite out of New York.
Mamdani, Lander, and Other Partisan Extremists Just Took a Bite Out of NYC’s Democracy
The partisans, unions, and party bosses have won again. Independents, veterans, working people, young people and democracy have lost again. ...
18 Jul, 2025
-
2 min read
Picture of PA capitol building with a no vote sign in front of it.
Taxed But Silenced: Pennsylvania Independents Sue for Right to Vote
Four independent voters, including well-known journalist Michael Smerconish and political reform advocate David Thornburgh, are suing the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, arguing that its closed primary system violates their constitutional rights under the state’s Free and Equal Elections Clause....
15 Jul, 2025
-
3 min read
vote here sign with people standing in line to vote.
Why Are Democrats in DC Failing to Implement an Initiative Passed by 73% of Voters?
Back in November, DC voters overwhelmingly approved Initiative 83, a measure that called for semi-open primaries and ranked choice voting (RCV) in all city elections. The problem – the DC City Council has yet to fully fund it....
15 Jul, 2025
-
4 min read

Latest articles

Trump Trush Social Post on Colbert
Will Politics Kill Late Night TV?
Stephen Colbert’s Late Show is ending after nearly a decade at the top of the ratings. CBS insists t...
18 Jul, 2025
-
3 min read
Ronald Reagan
Just Say No: The Political Hit Job That Killed Cannabis
As cannabis use became more common in the late 1970s, the backlash grew even stronger. A political and religious conservative resurgence was underway after years of liberal ascendancy. That wave would soon bring former California Governor Ronald Reagan to the White House....
18 Jul, 2025
-
8 min read
Political cartoon of a person representing partisanship, unions, the Democratic Party, and Special Interests taking a bite out of New York.
Mamdani, Lander, and Other Partisan Extremists Just Took a Bite Out of NYC’s Democracy
The partisans, unions, and party bosses have won again. Independents, veterans, working people, young people and democracy have lost again. ...
18 Jul, 2025
-
2 min read