Amendment H: Are South Dakota Voters Ready to Upend a Partisan Monopoly?

I voted sticker
Photo by Mockup Free on Unsplash
Shawn GriffithsShawn Griffiths
Published: 26 Sep, 2024
3 min read

South Dakota voters have a choice in the 2024 election:

They can keep an election system that is solely controlled by a single political party, or they can reform primary elections that allow voters to equally choose any candidate they prefer, regardless of party, under Amendment H. 

Amendment H replaces the current closed taxpayer-funded partisan primary system in South Dakota, with a nonpartisan Top Two primary that allows all voters and candidates to participate on a single primary ballot.

Joe Kirby of South Dakota Open Primaries, the group spearheading the proposal, explains:

"Here is how it works: all candidates for an office are listed on a single ballot. All voters get that ballot. The top two vote getters move on to the general election. Most importantly, all voters get to vote." 

He added that this would include "153,000 independent South Dakota voters who currently have little voice in selecting the people who lead our state." The top two vote-getters in each primary race then move on to the general election.

It cannot be disputed that South Dakota is a one-party state. Both US Senate seats are held by Republicans, as is the state's single congressional seat. The GOP also holds super-majorities in both state legislative chambers.

"Under our closed primary system, the Republican primary is the only election that often matters in the state," said Kirby.

"And unfortunately, a small group of activists has been disrupting the party. That could prove problematic for both the party and the state if we stick with closed primaries."

IVP Donate

The case made by primary reform advocates is that, historically, primary elections draw in a low turnout. In safe districts and states, the voters who do turnout effectively decide election outcomes. 

Research from the nonpartisan group Unite America found that partisan primary systems have resulted in just 8% of voters deciding 83% of elections

This creates an incentive with elected officials to govern not based on what the electorate at-large wants, but what primary voters demand. It's a system that can and has easily been infiltrated by extremist movements.

A nonpartisan primary system, like the Top Two system in California or the Top Four system in Alaska, opens the process up to all voters and candidates, thus reducing the control a single group or movement has on election outcomes.

Voters in South Dakota can expect some elections to feature two Republicans in the general election. As seen in California, this gives independents and voters outside the majority party an influential voice in who wins.

Thus, there is less incentive to campaign to the extremes.

"Our challenge with our Top Two open primary proposal is to make people aware of exactly how it works. Once they understand that, they tend to say things like 'of course, why wouldn't we want that?" said Kirby.

 Not much polling has been conducted on Amendment H. However, a June poll from South Dakota News Watch and the Chiesman Center for Democracy found that 54.6% of respondents supported the proposal. 

Let Us Vote : Sign Now!

"So far, I like our chances in November," said Kirby. 

South Dakota Open Primaries submitted 47,000 signatures to put Amendment H on the ballot. Kirby explained that the biggest opposition to Amendment H is from party bosses on both sides of the aisle. 

"Surprisingly, the Democratic leadership is as vocal in its opposition as are the Republicans, even though the party is no longer competitive in the state," he added. 

Amendment H will be on the November 5 ballot in South Dakota. Absentee voting started on September 20.  The measure is one of six state ballot measures in the US calling for an open nonpartisan primary system.

You Might Also Like

Will the Texas Republican Party be Successful Where the Hawaiian Democratic Party Failed?
Will the Texas Republican Party be Successful Where the Hawaiian Democratic Party Failed?
The Republican Party of Texas (RPT) is suing Secretary of State Jane Nelson in an effort to close the state’s primary elections to party members only – a move that the Democratic Party of Hawaii (DPH) tried back in 2013 in its state and failed. ...
05 Sep, 2025
-
3 min read
Gerrymandering, Primaries, and Election History: How It Really Works
Gerrymandering, Primaries, and Election History: How It Really Works
The nation’s attention is currently on the ongoing redistricting fight between Republicans and Democrats. The conversation is being framed: “Donald Trump is doing this.” “Gavin Newsom is doing that.” However, what voters are missing is the context of how we got here....
08 Aug, 2025
-
1 min read
Cartoon hand placing a ballot into a box that says primary on it with a GOP elephant and Democrat donkey in the background.
Hate Gerrymandering? Let’s Start Voting in Primaries
Responding to pressure from President Trump, Texas Governor Greg Abbott and the Republican-controlled legislature are moving forward with a plan to redraw their district lines in advance of the 2026 midterms. Democrats are contemplating how to fight back and blunt any gains the GOP makes in Texas by conducting their own gerrymanders in New York, Illinois, and California.  ...
07 Aug, 2025
-
4 min read
Colorado mail ballot
“Gold-Standard” or “Rigged”? How Secure Colorado’s Mail-In Elections Really Are
The White House touted a big announcement Tuesday, only for it to be reported early that President Donald Trump plans to re-locate U.S. Space Command headquarters from Colorado to Alabama – which is not as big of deal as the reason for the decision....
03 Sep, 2025
-
6 min read
two hands shaking.
California Doubles Down on Rehabilitation
On a hot August morning, state and local leaders gathered in Fresno to cut the ribbon on California’s newest community reentry facility. The site, run in partnership with TURN Behavioral Health Services, is designed to help people finishing prison sentences adjust to life on the outside. For Jorge Moreno of the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR), it’s about giving people a chance to breathe. “(It’s) like a phase down from the institutions,” he said. “(They) can decompress from the pressures and politics of prison and start acclimating back into the community.”...
03 Sep, 2025
-
5 min read
Independent Indiana Challenges the Two-Party Stranglehold on State Politics
Independent Indiana Challenges the Two-Party Stranglehold on State Politics
A new nonpartisan group launched this week in Indiana with a single goal in mind: Take on Indiana’s entrenched two-party system by encouraging more candidates to give voters a third option free of a party label -- and calling Hoosiers to support these candidates. ...
04 Sep, 2025
-
4 min read