Disconnected Democracy: The Cost of Exclusion in an Age of Political Identity

People sitting at a table.
Photo by Dylan Gillis on Unsplash.
Published: 02 Jun, 2025
3 min read

Editor's Note: This article originally published on The Independent Center's website and was republished on IVN by request and with permission of the organization.

 

At the heart of human experience lies the need to belong — a deep-seated psychological requirement that shapes everything from our relationships to our political identities. Feelings of exclusion impact us just as acutely as physical pain and how our sense of connection — or lack thereof — can profoundly influence behavior, decision-making, and social cohesion. More than just a feeling, belonging is a force: the sense that we are part of a valued group where we matter and can contribute meaningfully. As politics becomes more fragmented and the political parties cater more to their respective bases, understanding and intentionally cultivating belonging becomes crucial not just for individual well-being, but for the health of democracy and public discourse.

Zooming In

Our environment has a major impact on us, but this doesn’t mean we can’t take action to change it. This is called situation crafting. We have agency to adjust the context around us to foster connection, resilience, and personal growth. These strategic adjustments, or “wise interventions,” are rooted in psychological insight and are designed to reinforce individuals’ sense of belonging and self-worth.

This is why the independent voter needs a home. To unlock the maximum human potential and revitalize our democracy, it’s crucial that we understand and act on this fundamental psychological need.

Key Facts

  • Belonging and pain: Research shows that social exclusion activates the same brain regions as physical pain, underlining the profound psychological distress of disconnection.
  • Biological roots: Evolution favored individuals who bonded with others, leading to a brain wired to seek out in-groups and view outsiders with caution — a dynamic that today contributes to political and social tribalism.
  • The power of perception: When people feel that their belonging is under threat, they become more defensive, fearful, and less open to differing viewpoints.
  • Echo chambers: A 2021 study found that most Americans rarely encounter opposing political views in daily life, reinforcing ideological silos even within neighborhoods.
  • Cognitive pitfalls: Biases such as the Fundamental Attribution Error and Confirmation Bias lead us to judge others harshly and cling to our own views — not because of malice, but because our minds are wired for coherence and certainty.
  • Groupthink and conformity: Extreme conformity often arises from a desire to belong. In politically polarized societies, this pressure can silence dissent and deepen divides.

Independent Lens

From an independent perspective, this offers a vital framework for navigating our increasingly fractured civic landscape. It makes clear that political polarization isn’t just about ideology — it’s about identity, fear, and unmet psychological needs. Traditional efforts to change minds through campaigns or facts often fail because they don’t address the underlying emotional terrain.

Instead, bridging divides starts with humilityempathy, and genuine dialogue. If we want to foster cross-group understanding, we must create environments where people feel safe, seen, and respected — even when they disagree. This doesn’t mean abandoning convictions but recognizing the humanity in others and resisting the reflex to dehumanize or stereotype.

In this instance, social psychology offers us a roadmap for anyone who wants to build a more inclusive, less divided world — starting with the unlocking the power of the individual.

You Might Also Like

“Cartoon illustration of Americans facing the U.S. Capitol as light pierces through red and blue partisan cracks, representing independent voters and hope for political reform.”
New Poll: Voters Want New Leadership – and They’re Turning to Independents
A new poll from the Independent Center highlights a clear message from the public: Americans are fed up with the current political leadership, and they’re ready for change....
12 Nov, 2025
-
2 min read
person with a voted sticker.
CNN Poll Shows Independent Voters Are More Diverse Than You Think
A new CNN poll conducted by SSRS between August 21 and September 1 surveyed 2,077 adults, including 1,006 who identify as independents. The results challenge the idea that independents are a single bloc of undecided swing voters. Instead, they fall into five distinct groups with very different views of politics....
26 Sep, 2025
-
2 min read
Charlie Kirk
PODCAST: Charlie Kirk’s Tragedy is a Reason to Self-Reflect
The shocking assassination of Charlie Kirk has shaken the country and highlighted just how fractured our democracy has become. On this episode of the Independent Voter Podcast, Chad Peace and Cara McCormick reflect on the moment, drawing comparisons to the unity the nation felt after 9/11 and asking whether independent-minded reforms could help bring Americans back together....
18 Sep, 2025
-
1 min read
Trump sitting in the oval office with a piece of paper with a cannabis leaf on his desk.
Is Trump About to Outflank Democrats on Cannabis? Progressives Sound the Alarm
As President Donald Trump signals renewed interest in reclassifying cannabis from a Schedule I drug to Schedule III, a policy goal long championed by liberals and libertarians, the reaction among some partisan progressive advocates is not celebration, but concern....
08 Dec, 2025
-
5 min read
Malibu, California.
From the Palisades to Simi Valley, Independent Voters Poised to Decide the Fight to Replace Jacqui Irwin
The coastline that defines California’s mythology begins here. From Malibu’s winding cliffs to the leafy streets of Brentwood and Bel Air, through Topanga Canyon and into the valleys of Calabasas, Agoura Hills, and Thousand Oaks, the 42nd Assembly District holds some of the most photographed, most coveted, and most challenged terrain in the state. ...
10 Dec, 2025
-
6 min read
Ranked choice voting
Ranked Choice for Every Voter? New Bill Would Transform Every Congressional Election by 2030
As voters brace for what is expected to be a chaotic and divisive midterm election cycle, U.S. Representatives Jamie Raskin (Md.), Don Beyer (Va.), and U.S. Senator Peter Welch (Vt.) have re-introduced legislation that would require ranked choice voting (RCV) for all congressional primaries and general elections beginning in 2030....
10 Dec, 2025
-
3 min read