Same Election: Voter ID Wins Big; GOP Loses Big

Hand sticking ballot in ballot box.
Photo by Getty Images on Unsplash. Unsplash+ License obtained by editor.
Cara Brown McCormickCara Brown McCormick
Published: 03 Apr, 2025
3 min read

Many have seen the story out of Wisconsin: Susan Crawford defied record-breaking spending by Super PACs to win the April 1 state Supreme Court election. “Crawford beat Musk,” is the headline after the world’s richest man poured millions into the race to defeat her, while liberal billionaires also opened up their own pocketbooks for Crawford.

With both sides of the media focusing on the partisan funding arms race, the constitutional amendment that formally cemented Wisconsin’s voter ID requirements into state constitutional law could prove to be an even more important story.

The Voter ID measure passed with 62% of the vote, while 38% opposed it, according to unofficial results. Decision Desk HQ projected the outcome just 20 minutes after polls closed. In other words, when voters cast their ballots, they didn’t just defy big money, but party narratives as well.

The referendum asked voters:

"Photographic identification for voting. Shall section 1m of article III of the constitution be created to require that voters present valid photographic identification verifying their identity in order to vote in any election, subject to exceptions which may be established by law?" 

The referendum does not create new ID requirements. Wisconsin’s voter ID law has been in effect since 2011. Acceptable forms of identification include a Wisconsin driver’s license or state ID, U.S. passport, military ID, and certain student IDs.

The GOP has long owned the issue of voter ID, arguing that it is important for the security and integrity of elections. Republican lawmakers said they advanced the amendment as a way to safeguard existing law from potential legal challenges. 

Republican State Sen. Van Wanggaard said "this will help maintain integrity in the electoral process, no matter who controls the Legislature."

Democrats, on the other hand, criticized the decision to place the question on the April ballot, alleging that it was designed to boost conservative turnout in the high-profile race for a seat on the Wisconsin Supreme Court.

IVP Donate

But regardless of what the parties’ machinations might have been, voters made their own decisions on election day. Democrat Susan Crawford won the state Supreme Court seat with 55% of the vote.

And, voter ID won by an even greater majority.

While the Republican Party and the Democratic Party have tried to control the narrative on this issue, most voters have long supported a requirement to show photo ID when casting a ballot regardless of party support or opposition.

A 2021 Marquette University Law School poll found that 77% of registered Wisconsin voters supported the state’s voter ID law. This included 96% of Republicans, 52% of Democrats, and 81% of independents. 

When explicitly asked about enshrining the law in the constitution, 73% expressed support — 97% of Republicans, 44% of Democrats, and 74% of independents 

This strong cross-partisan support suggests that while Republicans may have hoped the amendment would energize their base and improve their odds in the Supreme Court race, the issue did not polarize voters in a predictable partisan fashion. 

Instead, it attracted backing from a wide swath of the electorate, including many independents and Democrats.

Concerns about election security and integrity cut across party lines and include a majority of independent voters, and the success of the amendment—alongside the election of a liberal Supreme Court justice—underscores a clearly independent-minded electorate.

Let Us Vote : Sign Now!

And for those who think Voter ID is just a tactic for Republicans to boost voter turnout -- they might be right. But Republicans are wrong to think that is necessarily a boost for Republican candidates

You Might Also Like

person with a voted sticker.
CNN Poll Shows Independent Voters Are More Diverse Than You Think
A new CNN poll conducted by SSRS between August 21 and September 1 surveyed 2,077 adults, including 1,006 who identify as independents. The results challenge the idea that independents are a single bloc of undecided swing voters. Instead, they fall into five distinct groups with very different views of politics....
26 Sep, 2025
-
2 min read
Charlie Kirk
PODCAST: Charlie Kirk’s Tragedy is a Reason to Self-Reflect
The shocking assassination of Charlie Kirk has shaken the country and highlighted just how fractured our democracy has become. On this episode of the Independent Voter Podcast, Chad Peace and Cara McCormick reflect on the moment, drawing comparisons to the unity the nation felt after 9/11 and asking whether independent-minded reforms could help bring Americans back together....
18 Sep, 2025
-
1 min read
Colorado i voted
Colorado Voter Registration Data Shows Independents Now the Majority
Colorado has reached a new milestone in voter registration: unaffiliated voters now make up more than half of the electorate....
17 Sep, 2025
-
1 min read
Proposition 50 voter guide
California Prop 50: Partisan Power Play or Necessary Counterpunch?
November 4 marks a special election for what has become the most controversial ballot measure in California in recent memory: Proposition 50, which would circumvent congressional districts drawn by the state’s independent redistricting commission for a legislative-drawn map....
01 Oct, 2025
-
9 min read
court gavel.
Virtual Discussion: The Fight for Equal Independent Voting Rights Makes it to SCOTUS
Every major voting rights movement in U.S. history – whether successful or not – has intertwined with landmark litigation. This was the case for women’s suffrage. It was the case for civil rights. And it is the case in the ongoing effort to protect the right of all voters to have equal participation in taxpayer-funded elections – something millions of independent voters are denied across the U.S....
29 Sep, 2025
-
2 min read
Supreme Court building
SCOTUS Considers Challenge to Closed Primaries -- Here's Why It Is Such a Big Deal
In a dramatic step forward for litigation challenging closed primaries, the U.S. Supreme Court has indicated they are going to conference to discuss whether to grant a writ of certiorari to Polelle v. Florida Secretary of State; a case challenging Florida's closed primaries that Open Primaries has supported since its inception....
26 Sep, 2025
-
2 min read