Poll: La. Lawmakers Dismantle Nonpartisan Elections Supported by Two-Thirds of Voters

voting
Photo by Getty Images on Unsplash. Unsplash+ License obtained by author.
Created: 23 Jan, 2024
3 min read

Photo Credit: Getty Images / Unsplash

 

It is not uncommon to meet someone who feels like their voice isn't heard by the people elected to represent them. In fact, it is a sentiment shared by most voters.

However, in Louisiana, voters witnessed their legislature not only ignore their opinions on something as important as voter rights -- but lawmakers also spit in their faces.

A new poll from JMC Analytics, a Louisiana-based data analysis group, found that 65% of voters support the nonpartisan "jungle primary" system used in all Louisiana state, legislative, and non-federal presidential elections.

In a "jungle primary," all voters and candidates participate on a single ballot when other states would conduct their general elections. If a candidate gets over 50% of the vote, they win outright.

If no candidate gets a majority, a runoff election is held a month later.

The "jungle primary" defies the traditional rules of a primary election -- particularly partisan primaries. First, the system does not pick nominees; it elects candidates, regardless of party.

Second, it doesn't discriminate against voters based on party ID or lack thereof. Third, there is no guarantee of a follow-up election if a candidate garners over 50% of the vote.

More Choice for San Diego

Voters are satisfied with this system because it treats them equally at the ballot box. It doesn't divide voters into separate classes nor give certain groups of voters an advantage or privilege that is denied other groups of voters. 

However, the primary system Louisiana Gov. Jeff Landry called on state legislators to move to in a special legislative session is designed to do everything voters don't want elections to do.

Landry wanted closed partisan primaries for all elections in the state, which would make elections about nominating party candidates, rather than electing candidates -- moving away from a taxpayer-funded process that serves a public purpose to one that serves a private purpose.

Only party members can participate under closed primary rules, which would shut out over 800,000 state voters and condition their right to equal and meaningful participation in elections on joining a private political corporation. 

By restricting voter access and taking away a right to equal treatment under the law, moving to a closed primary would by its very definition disenfranchise a third of the state's electorate.

Ultimately, party leaders have more control over electoral outcomes in low-turnout closed partisan primaries -- making elections less about the interests of voters, and more about the self-serving interests of the parties themselves.

The Louisiana Legislature did not give Landry everything he wanted. However, they voted to switch to closed partisan primaries for congressional and US Senate races, State Supreme Court and School Board elections, and elections for the state's Public Service Commission.

Not only does this disenfranchise a substantial segment of the voting population in important elections, but it will also result in confusion among independent voters because now they will have equal rights in some elections, but not others.

More Choice for San Diego

Lawmakers may come to regret their decision to put politics before voters. The JMC Analytics poll found that a majority of survey takers (54%) said they would be less likely to vote for a candidate who supports changing the primary system.

Related articles

American flag on pole.
The Illusion of Competition in American Elections
American elections are becoming less competitive, and the consequences are eroding democracy. As The...
28 Feb, 2025
-
2 min read
a row of vote here ballot stations
New Mexico House Committee to Take Up Independent Voters' Rights to Vote in Primaries
SANTA FE, N.M. - A bill that could open primary elections to more than 330,000 New Mexico voters reg...
26 Feb, 2025
-
2 min read
Several ballot boxes with different colored ballots sticking out.
Open Primaries Bill Passes New Mexico Senate, Moves to House
SANTA FE, N.M. - With a short legislative window to work with, the updates on a bill to open New Mex...
21 Feb, 2025
-
1 min read

Latest articles

Symbols for both parties on elevated positions.
A Tale of Two Parties: Democrats Are from Mars, Republicans Are from Venus
As I think about Tuesday’s State of the Union address by President Donald Trump and the response of Senator Elissa Slotkin from Michigan—a former CIA analyst and a rising star in the Democratic Party—I am reminded of the book “Men Are from Mars, Women Are from Venus” by John Gray published in 1992....
06 Mar, 2025
-
5 min read
Symbols of both parties on a scale.
Research Shows Congress Is Getting Younger, But No Less Divided
Pew Research Center published 7 facts this week about the changing face of Congress in the 119th session. On top of an increase in diversity, the research center found Congress is also slightly younger....
05 Mar, 2025
-
3 min read
American flag in front of a government building with columns.
How An Unresponsive Government Is Affecting Public Support for Foreign Aid
The heated confrontation in the White House Friday between Ukraine President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and US President Donald Trump and his vice president, JD Vance, continues to spur debate across the nation as voters are split on the US's support of Ukraine in its war with Russia....
04 Mar, 2025
-
4 min read