NYC Won't Show Independent Voters Much Love This Valentine's Day

New York sign in the city.
Photo by Nik Shuliahin on Unsplash
Published: 11 Feb, 2025
Updated: 18 Jun, 2025
3 min read

In New York City, it goes without saying that the most consequential election in nearly every race is in the Democratic primary. However, if registered independent voters don't join a party soon, they will be completely denied a say.

The deadline to change their voter registration is Friday, February 14 -- and while it may be Valentine's Day, many voters won't be feeling the love. The choice forced on them is join a party or don't vote.

New York City uses closed partisan primary elections, meaning only registered party members can participate. This includes the 2025 mayoral election, which is getting heightened attention with Mayor Eric Adams in the national spotlight.

The odds of a Democrat winning in November are great. After all, Democrats outnumber Republicans 6-to-1 in the Big Apple. In other words, the next mayor -- along with other elected positions -- will be decided in June.

By the time registered independent voters are allowed a say in November, it will be too late.

"New York is one of only a dozen states and NYC one of only 15% of cities that operate a closed primary system," writes Jeremy Gruber, Senior Vice President of the election reform group Open Primaries

"Our primary elections are conducted exactly like the general election, in the same public buildings, on the same machines, with the same poll workers and administered by the city with our tax dollars. The only difference is that independents are barred from participating. Not a single elected official in NYC has publicly denounced it."

Gruber explains that the closed primaries go beyond just disenfranchisement in New York because it is also used by the parties, candidates, and allied organizations to target independent voters for "conversion."

"When Be Counted tells independents to join the Democratic Party, it’s because they want to use independents to help them reach an outcome that the Democratic primary isn’t providing," he writes.

IVP Donate

"When The City runs a feature on why independents should join a party, and doesn’t interview a single independent on why that’s a problem, they’re telling independents we don’t matter."

And those were just a couple of examples. Some candidates even try to be cute with it. Gothamist reports:

"In a cheeky nod to the Valentine’s Day deadline, mayoral candidate Assemblymember Zohran Mamdani made a video for social media, complete with a love song and a heart-shaped chocolate box containing a voter registration form, asking: 'Will you be my Democrat?'"

It doesn't matter if voters want to be a Democrat or a party member of any kind. Andrew Yang, who has run for president and mayor in NYC, says he knows a lot of people who join a party just so they can have a meaningful vote.

Independent voters -- who register as "blank" in New York -- are the second largest voting bloc in the nation's largest city. They make up 1.1 million registered voters, according to data from the state.

Voters have until Friday to change their voter registration if they want to vote in the primaries. The fastest way to re-register is to submit an application online. However, an online application has to be received a day early on February 13. 

Related articles

Crowd cheering
2025 Has Already Been a Monumental Win for Independent Voters
We’re halfway into 2025 and the year has already delivered several wins for independent voters and their right to equal participation in elections following a campaign cycle in which statewide ballot measure losses threatened to slow down the movement....
18 Jun, 2025
-
13 min read
Busy New York city at night.
As Demand for Reform in NYC Grows, Open Primaries Gains Media Attention
As the New York City Charter Revision Commission considers a wide breadth of reforms to city policy, one reform in particular is catching the attention of both voters and the media: Ending the city’s use of closed partisan primaries....
12 Jun, 2025
-
3 min read
An electric sign of the American flag.
ABC's Sara Haines Calls Out 'Narrow View' that Independent Voters Can't Exist in Trump Era
American journalist and co-host of ABC’s The View, Sara Haines, refutes the notion that people can't be independent-minded in their election choices in an era in which the Republican Party is controlled by Trump – a perspective voiced by her colleague, Sunny Houstin that Haines describes as “narrow.”...
06 Jun, 2025
-
3 min read

Latest articles

Crowd in Time Square.
NYC Exit Survey: 96% of Voters Understood Their Ranked Choice Ballots
An exit poll conducted by SurveyUSA on behalf of the nonprofit better elections group FairVote finds that ranked choice voting (RCV) continues to be supported by a vast majority of voters who find it simple, fair, and easy to use. The findings come in the wake of the city’s third use of RCV in its June 2025 primary elections....
01 Jul, 2025
-
6 min read
A man filling out his election ballot.
Oregon Activist Sues over Closed Primaries: 'I Shouldn't Have to Join a Party to Have a Voice'
A new lawsuit filed in Oregon challenges the constitutionality of the state’s closed primary system, which denies the state’s largest registered voting bloc – independent voters – access to taxpayer-funded primary elections. The suit alleges Oregon is denying the voters equal voting rights...
01 Jul, 2025
-
3 min read
Supreme Court building.
Supreme Court Sides with Federal Corrections Officers in Lawsuit Over Prison Incident
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled June 30 that federal prison officers and officials cannot be sued by an inmate who accused them of excessive force during a 2021 incident, delivering a victory for federal corrections personnel concerned about rising legal exposure for doing their jobs....
01 Jul, 2025
-
3 min read