As Markets Slide, Polling Shows Independent Voters Are Growing Wary of Economic Direction

Image of trade numbers and graph.
Photo by Anne Nygård on Unsplash
Created: 07 Apr, 2025
2 min read

The Nasdaq Composite has officially entered bear market territory—defined by a drop of 20% or more from its recent high—while the S&P 500 is nearing the same threshold today. Last week U.S. stock markets shed $6.6 trillion in value over a two-day span, triggered by President Trump’s larger-than-expected tariff announcement and China’s vow to match the tariffs on all American-made goods.

While financial analysts monitor the implications for the broader economy, independent voters across the country are also paying close attention. For many, market volatility and rising prices are reigniting concerns about the direction of economic policy and political leadership.

Economic Expectations vs. Current Sentiment

Independent voters played a pivotal role in the 2024 election, with former President Donald Trump significantly narrowing the gap among this key demographic compared to previous cycles. In some cases, independents split almost evenly between Trump and Kamala Harris, reflecting a clear shift from 2020. Many of these voters were drawn by promises to lower costs and restore economic stability.

However, recent polling and sentiment data suggest a growing disconnect. A CBS News/YouGov poll conducted March 27-28, 2025, shows that most independents do not support the current administration’s focus on tariffs.

Tariffs as a Political Swing Issue

Sixty-one percent oppose the recently proposed tariffs and think the president is focusing too much on them. Seventy-seven percent of independents say the tariffs will increase prices in the short term. These views suggest tariffs may function as a political swing issue, particularly for independent voters. Many of these voters say they are seeing the opposite of what they anticipated: more economic uncertainty, not less.

CBS Poll data

CBS Poll data 2

While President Trump is currently more popular overall than he was at this point in his first term, his ratings on economic stewardship among independents are slipping. Financial Times data journalist John Burn-Murdoch recently noted after looking at the YouGov polling that “the larger group of other voters who backed Trump last November is rapidly souring on his economic policies and overall record.”

That shift may not reflect a wholesale rejection of the administration, but rather a recalibration of expectations. Independent voters—who tend to prioritize outcomes over ideology—are reevaluating whether current policies align with their concerns about cost of living, wages, and financial security.

Markets and Momentum

The Nasdaq’s entry into bear market territory adds another layer of uncertainty. While bear markets don’t always lead to recessions, they often influence voter sentiment and contribute to a climate of economic caution. Market trends, combined with the rising cost of essentials like housing and groceries, reinforce a sense of unease for many voters who already feel financially stretched.

IVP Donate

Looking Ahead

As the 2026 midterms approach, the evolving views of independent voters could prove decisive. They remain a highly engaged and influential bloc, particularly in competitive districts. If economic conditions continue to overshadow other political priorities, their shifting sentiment may reshape both parties’ strategies moving forward.

Related articles

Person holding up a cannabis plant.
On Top of New Tariffs and Proposed Vape Ban, Calif. Cannabis Retailers Also Face an Excise Tax Hike
SACRAMENTO, CALIF. - As California’s legal cannabis industry heads into the second half of 2025, sto...
16 Apr, 2025
-
3 min read
Cargo ship and harbor with a picture of the globe in the water.
Trump's Trade War: When Bad Economics Makes Good Politics
Last week, Americans ...
14 Apr, 2025
-
1 min read
cannabis plant
Tariffs and Vape Ban Could Push California’s Cannabis Market Further Underground
California’s legal cannabis industry, long weighed down by high taxes and regulation, is facing new ...
11 Apr, 2025
-
3 min read

Latest articles

Building with columns.
In 3 States, Partisans Pick the Secretary of State Without Voter or Executive Input
In 47 US states, the secretary of state is a recognized statewide office, and in most of those states, voters get to decide who holds it. But in three 3 states — Maine, Tennessee, and New Hampshire — the legislature holds that power exclusively....
29 Apr, 2025
-
7 min read
A man wearing an I Voted sticker on a collared shirt.
Charlottesville's First Use of Ranked Choice Voting is Unique -- Here's Why
Primary elections are scheduled in Charlottesville, Virginia, on June 17. However, there is something different about this election: It is the first time the city will use ranked choice voting (RCV). ...
29 Apr, 2025
-
4 min read
ballots in ballot box.
Congressmen Co-Lead Effort to Prohibit Ranked Choice Voting in Federal Elections
US Rep. Nick Begich (R-Alaska), who was elected under Alaska’s ranked choice voting (RCV) system, and US Rep. Abraham Hamadeh (R-Arizona) are co-leading an effort to prohibit the use of RCV in federal elections. ...
29 Apr, 2025
-
2 min read