Idaho Lawmakers Are Going After the Ballot Initiative Process

Idaho Capitol Building
Photo by from Keri Lund on Flickr and used under creative commons license.
Published: 09 Jan, 2025
Updated: 18 Jun, 2025
2 min read

Idaho lawmakers are still fuming that citizen-led groups tried to change the way the state elects its lawmakers. The 2024 initiative failed, but now a bill in the legislature would make it harder for any ballot proposition to pass.

Rep. Bruce Skaug introduced the bill in the House State Affairs Committee on Wednesday. If approved and signed into law, it will raise the vote threshold needed to pass citizen initiatives to 60%.

It has 11 co-sponsors.

Skaug told committee members that the purpose of the bill was to curtail the influence of out-of-state money in the initiative process. "This is one way to level the playing field a little bit by raising it to 60%," he said.

In November, Idaho voters weighed in on Proposition 1, which proposed a complete overhaul to state elections, including implementing a nonpartisan top four primary with ranked choice voting (RCV) in the general election.

Under a nonpartisan primary system, all voters and candidates participate on a single ballot.

Proposition 1 was spearheaded by a coalition called Idahoans for Open Primaries and the group Reclaim Idaho. More than $5 million was raised in support of it, including contributions from out-of-state groups.

Luke Mayville, a lead organizer for Prop. 1, called Skaug's bill “a shameless attempt to silence Idaho voters.” 

The irony of the bill is that it doesn't do anything about what Skaug says is the issue. In fact, if anything, it invites more money into the process because groups will need to spend more to reach voters.

IVP Donate

But moving the goal post on voters to effect change in their state has increasingly found its way into more legislative bodies in recent years. In fact, in 2022, research found over 60 laws were proposed in 11 states in a 5-year period.

These states were not controlled by a single party and included Arkansas, Arizona, Florida, Maine, Missouri, North Dakota, Nevada, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Dakota, and Washington.

Skaug's bill also imposes a tougher barrier on a citizen initiative process that the Idaho Supreme Court ruled in 2021 was a fundamental right to state voters and an effort to curtail it would be a violation of voters' rights.

A 60% threshold would be a standard that doesn't exist in any other election in the state, which is made more interesting by the fact that many state lawmakers rejected a new voting method (RCV) that requires majority winners.

In its 2021 ruling, the state supreme court noted that state lawmakers cannot use an "unsubstantiated fear of the ‘tyranny of the majority,’ by replacing it with an actual ‘tyranny of the minority."

Related articles

Michael Smerconish
Michael Smerconish Leads Lawsuit Against Both Political Parties
CNN host Michael Smerconish is a Pennsylvania voter who is denied access to taxpayer-funded primaries because he is a registered non-party affiliate (independent). He is also one of the plaintiffs in a new lawsuit challenging his state’s use of closed primaries. ...
22 Jul, 2025
-
1 min read
Vote sign with New York City skyline in the background.
Don’t Blame Mamdani for Closed Primaries in New York City
The NYC Charter Revision Commission (CRC) will hold its final meeting on July 21 to decide what reforms to city policy will appear on the November ballot. However, one proposal will not be on the commission’s docket – open primaries....
21 Jul, 2025
-
10 min read
Political cartoon of a person representing partisanship, unions, the Democratic Party, and Special Interests taking a bite out of New York.
Mamdani, Lander, and Other Partisan Extremists Just Took a Bite Out of NYC’s Democracy
The partisans, unions, and party bosses have won again. Independents, veterans, working people, young people and democracy have lost again. ...
18 Jul, 2025
-
2 min read

Latest articles

Tulsi Gabbard Reading Documents at a Podium in Front of the Capitol and an American Flag
The Trump Russia Story Was False, but What About Tulsi’s Tale?
WASHINGTON, D.C. — Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard is accusing the Obama administrat...
23 Jul, 2025
-
7 min read
HIRW: The Unfair Fight Between Regulated Cannabis and Unregulated “Gas‑Station” Hemp
How It Really Works: The Unfair Fight Between Legal Cannabis and Unregulated 'Gas‑Station' Hemp
When President Richard Nixon told the nation on June 17, 1971, that drug abuse was “public enemy number one,” he formally launched the War on Drugs and cemented cannabis in Schedule I of the Controlled Substances Act. ...
22 Jul, 2025
-
10 min read
Michael Smerconish
Michael Smerconish Leads Lawsuit Against Both Political Parties
CNN host Michael Smerconish is a Pennsylvania voter who is denied access to taxpayer-funded primaries because he is a registered non-party affiliate (independent). He is also one of the plaintiffs in a new lawsuit challenging his state’s use of closed primaries. ...
22 Jul, 2025
-
1 min read