Arizona's Make Elections Fair Act: It's Not About Ranked Choice Voting

voting
Photo by Getty Images on Unsplash. Unsplash+ License obtained by author.
Published: 05 Aug, 2024
Updated: 18 Jun, 2025
3 min read

The Arizona Free Enterprise Club filed a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of a ballot initiative that would require state lawmakers to adopt a primary system that allows all voters and candidates, regardless of party, to participate on a single ballot.

The organization asserts that the initiative, sponsored by Make Elections Fair AZ, amends the constitution in several distinct ways and thus violates the state’s single-subject and separate amendment rule – but it also gets plenty of things wrong about the initiative.

The purpose of the Make Elections Fair Arizona Act, the initiative being challenged, is to level the playing field in elections for all candidates and voters in a manner that is free of the controlling influence of partisan politics. This is stated under its “Purpose and Intent.”

“To accomplish these goals, this Constitutional Amendment creates a primary system in which people may vote for the candidate of their choice, regardless of the political party of the voter or the candidate," the initiative states.

ALSO READ: Arizona Initiative: Parties Can Either Accept Open Primaries or Pay for Them

It is first and foremost a primary reform initiative. However, the Arizona Free Enterprise Club claims in its lawsuit that the initiative “contains distinctly different topics and amends multiple sections of the Arizona constitution,” and thus violates the state’s Separate Amendment Rule.

The lawsuit points to certain changes that could be made to the general election, like the adoption of ranked choice voting (RCV) – but the addition of RCV is purely hypothetical.

The initiative stipulates that the election model used is up to the legislature.

The most important requirement is that lawmakers have to use a nonpartisan primary system. The initiative allows for flexibility when it comes to the general election

IVP Donate

State lawmakers could choose to go with a Top Two system, like in California, for elections that elect only one candidate. In this case, the winner of the general election is guaranteed to have a majority of the vote because there are only two candidates.

Or, they could go with a Top Four system like in Alaska. In the event 3 or more candidates advance to the general election then the initiative requires a ranking method for voters to use to determine a majority winner. 

This is an if. It all comes down to the legislature and if the legislature fails to provide a nonpartisan election system, it would be the responsibility of the state’s chief elections administrator, the secretary of state, to decide what election model is best to use.

If state lawmakers object to a ranking method, they can enact a Top Two system – but the model adopted should be one built on equal treatment of voters and candidates (who would have the same signature requirements).

That’s the point. And it starts with primary elections.

The Make Elections Fair Act would amend the language in various parts of a single Article in the Arizona Constitution, Article VII, and if adopted would apply to state elections that occur after July 1, 2026. 

The lawsuit filed by the Arizona Free Enterprise Club comes after the Arizona Legislative Council adopted language for the initiative for voter pamphlets that intentionally focuses on ranked choice voting, which again is not guaranteed or required.

"This initiative is arguably the most important reform in our lifetime," said Sarah Smallhouse, chair of Make Elections Fair, in an interview for Public News Service. "It's time to do right by Arizona. It's time to start fixing things. It's time to make elections fair."

Let Us Vote : Sign Now!

Make Elections Fair AZ suggested changes to the language to ensure that it was not confusing to voters. The legislative council, however, rejected them – leading to Make Elections Fair to file its own lawsuit against state lawmakers. 

Arizona Attorney General Kris Maye believes the partisan legislative council is improperly trying to influence the vote on the Make Elections Fair Act and other initiatives. A Maricopa County superior court will consider and rule on the language challenge

Related articles

Stop light with the capitol building in the background.
DC Dems to Independent Voters: You Don’t Matter
The DC City Council had one final opportunity to fund a provision approved by 73% of city voters in November that would open primary elections to 83,000+ independent voters – and the Democratic-controlled body elected instead not to honor the will of voters....
29 Jul, 2025
-
2 min read
Michael Smerconish
Michael Smerconish Leads Lawsuit Against Both Political Parties
CNN host Michael Smerconish is a Pennsylvania voter who is denied access to taxpayer-funded primaries because he is a registered non-party affiliate (independent). He is also one of the plaintiffs in a new lawsuit challenging his state’s use of closed primaries. ...
22 Jul, 2025
-
1 min read
Vote sign with New York City skyline in the background.
Don’t Blame Mamdani for Closed Primaries in New York City
The NYC Charter Revision Commission (CRC) will hold its final meeting on July 21 to decide what reforms to city policy will appear on the November ballot. However, one proposal will not be on the commission’s docket – open primaries....
21 Jul, 2025
-
10 min read

Latest articles

Stop light with the capitol building in the background.
DC Dems to Independent Voters: You Don’t Matter
The DC City Council had one final opportunity to fund a provision approved by 73% of city voters in November that would open primary elections to 83,000+ independent voters – and the Democratic-controlled body elected instead not to honor the will of voters....
29 Jul, 2025
-
2 min read
CCPOA honor guard.
California’s Soft Sentencing Freed a Violent Offender -- Then He Walked Into a State Office and Killed a Parole Agent
On July 17, a California state parole agent became the first CDCR officer killed in the line of duty since 2018 when he was shot inside a state parole office by a man who had been released just months earlier after serving only four years for randomly stabbing a stranger in the neck....
29 Jul, 2025
-
7 min read
Joe Manchin
Manchin to DC: Independents Are Here, and We’re Not Going Away
The rise of an independent majority has long been dismissed by the press as a myth, which is why few people heard about an event in the nation’s capital on July 23 that gathered prominent and rising independent voices....
29 Jul, 2025
-
4 min read