Americans Support Checks on Presidential Power Despite Low Trust in Government, Survey Finds

Close up of US Supreme Court building.
Photo by Getty Images on Unsplash. Unsplash+ License obtained by author.
Published: 22 Apr, 2025
Updated: 18 Jun, 2025
3 min read

PHILADELPHIA, PENN. — Despite broad public distrust of the federal government, most Americans still believe in the foundational principles on which the US political system was built —especially the importance of checks and balances.

This is according to a new national survey by the Annenberg Public Policy Center (APPC) of the University of Pennsylvania.

The findings reveal that large majorities of US adults support the role of Congress and the courts in limiting presidential authority, even amid broader dissatisfaction and skepticism toward the federal government’s three branches.

“Americans do not think the president should have the ability to act unconstrained by the courts and Congress,” said Matt Levendusky, director of APPC’s Institutions of Democracy division and a Penn political science professor.

“Democrats, Republicans, and independents alike believe that the courts and Congress should be able to check the president’s actions.”

Levendusky and Shawn Patterson Jr. wrote about the issue for NBC News. 

Americans Value Constitutional Oversight

One of the most notable findings of the APPC survey is the extent to which the public supports constitutional oversight, even under extraordinary circumstances such as terrorism.

When asked whether a president should comply with a Supreme Court ruling — even if he believes it hinders national security — 69% of respondents said the president should follow the court’s decision.

This represents a 25-point increase from 2007, when only 44% felt that way. Similarly, 76% of respondents agreed that the president is supposed to follow Supreme Court rulings.

IVP Donate

“People want the president to listen to the Supreme Court and they think that our system of government requires the president to do so,” said Kathleen Hall Jamieson, director of the Annenberg Public Policy Center.

Few Americans think the president should be allowed to ignore court decisions. In fact, only 27% of Republicans, 20% of independents, and 5% of Democrats think the president has this right.

And it is not just the courts. Sixty percent of respondents didn't believe the president should have the right to enact policies without congressional approval. Only 13% of independents surveyed said the president should have this right.

This public commitment to constitutional checks on the executive branch comes at a time when Americans harbor low levels of trust in the federal government itself.

According to the APPC survey, only 41% of Americans trust the US Supreme Court to act in the best interests of people like them. Trust is even lower for the presidency (40%), elected officials (36%), and Congress (32%).

Business leaders ranked the lowest at 30%.

At the heart of this distrust may be a general perception that these critical institutions in American government and society are not operating the way they should or the way they were formed to operate.

A clear majority — 60% — believe the country is seriously off track, while only 40% think it is generally going in the right direction.  Still, Americans believe in the principles underpinning the US Constitution.

Let Us Vote : Sign Now!

“Even though people say they don’t have much trust in particular government institutions—Congress, the President, the courts—they do express support for our system of government,” said Jamieson.

“They support the idea of checks and balances, if not the individual branches themselves.”

A Complex View of Government

The findings highlight a complex relationship that the American public has with their government. Even as many voters believe US institutions are failing them, they still believe in the principles they are supposed to represent.

And they still want to believe in the democratic process.

In times of political division and national anxiety, Americans appear to be drawing a line between the individuals who hold power and the principles that define how power is wielded.

The survey data, collected in February and March 2025, underscores the need for elected leaders and institutions to earn back public trust—even as the public continues to uphold the constitutional framework that empowers them.

In this article

Related articles

Two wedding rings on a dictionary opened to the definition of marriage.
Record Partisan Divide Overshadows Broad Public Support for Same-Sex Marriage
It has been 10 years since the Supreme Court's decision in Obergefell v. Hodges opened the door for same-sex couples across the US to marry, regardless of what states banned it and what states had already legalized it....
30 May, 2025
-
3 min read
United states map with red and blue stacks over each state.
Gallup: Americans More Likely to Rank Government Leadership as No. 1 Problem
The latest polling data from Gallup shows that the number one problem facing the US for most voters now is not the economy, it is not cost of living or inflation -- it is poor leadership in the government....
15 Apr, 2025
-
2 min read
US Capitol Building
CNN Poll: Only 19% of Independents View Democrats Favorably and Don't Think Much Better of Republicans
According to a new poll from CNN, conducted by SSRS, most of the public doesn't hold either major party in high regard, especially independent voters -- with whom neither party exceeds 20% favorability....
18 Mar, 2025
-
3 min read

Latest articles

homelessness in California
Clearing Homeless Encampments Is a Band-Aid, Not A Solution
Last July, Governor Gavin Newsom issued an executive order “to address (homeless) encampments” and allocated funding to local governments to clear encampments and connect “those living in them to housing and supportive services.” ...
20 Jun, 2025
-
3 min read
Thomas Massie
Thomas Massie and AOC: The Political Alliance No One Saw Coming in 2025
All eyes are on President Donald Trump to see if the US will further insert itself into the escalating military conflict between Israel and Iran. As the two nations continue to attack each other, the debate over US involvement is creating a rift between defense hawks and non-interventionists in the Republican Party....
20 Jun, 2025
-
5 min read
Bottle with a cannabis plant on it.
Is Texas About to Be More Chill on Hemp Than California?
California has just proposed a sweeping new rule to permanently ban intoxicating hemp products — and Texas may soon follow, as Governor Greg Abbott (R) faces a June 22 deadline to sign or veto a similar bill....
19 Jun, 2025
-
4 min read