CA State Superintendent Race: A Look At Tuck And Thurmond

image
Author: Jeff Powers
Created: 02 Oct, 2018
Updated: 21 Nov, 2022
3 min read

https://soundcloud.com/independent-voter-podcast/a-conversation-with-state-superintendent-candidate-marshall-tuck

San Diego, CA.- While it certainly doesn't have the political fervor associated with partisan politics, make no mistake, the race for Superintendent of California is hotly contested.

Candidates Marshall Tuck and Tony Thurmond have been trading barbs over the direction of the states school system, responsible for educating more than 6 million students.

Marshall Tuck has spent most of two decades as a school administrator and is backed by California's charter school community. For five years he was the president of the Green Dot Public Schools, a network of charter high schools in low-income neighborhoods of Los Angeles. He then became CEO of the nonprofit Partnership for Los Angeles Schools, whose goal was to turn around some of Los Angeles Unified’s schools with the highest dropout rates.

Tony Thurmond, is backed by the state's teachers' union. A second-term assemblyman and social worker by training, Thurmond founded or ran several nonprofit organizations that worked with low-income foster children. Thurmond served one term on the city council in Richmond and on the West Contra Costa Unified school board before being elected to the Assembly district serving Richmond, Berkeley and parts of Oakland.

The race has become abnormally expensive and politically combative. Tuck, who ran and lost for state chief in 2014, has raised in excess of $3 million. Thurmond has raised close to $2 million.

In the June Primary, Tuck beat Thurmond by just 2 percentage points.

A Big Agenda

Whomever voters choose, the new Superintendent will have a full plate.

  • The National Assessment of Education states California's poor students perform worse than their peers in every single state except for Alaska.
  • The state has suffered from teacher shortages, leaving hundreds of classrooms overseen by either unqualified or substitute teachers.
  • Local districts administrations budgets have grown exponentially as billion dollar bond measures continue to be approved by voters.

Tuck and Thurmond have each stated publicly they will use their power as a bully pulpit to push their own agendas.

More Choice for San Diego

They both promised to replace the state's 25-year-old charter law and find a new way to pay down its $100 billion pension debt.

Down Ballot Race

Name recognition in down-ballot races is particularly key, and in this race, each candidate has a considerable amount of name recognition. That typically translates into a close race which is what we saw in the June Primary with Tuck beating Thurmond by just 2 percentage points.

For 20 years Thurmond has served as a social worker, school board member, and city council member. He has turned that public service into a number of key endorsements including the union representing California's prison officers has have emerged as a player. The group announced a $500,000 expenditure for television ads to help elect Thurmond.

Tuck has served as the president of Green Dot Public Schools, a national network of charter schools, and was the founding CEO of the nonprofit Partnership for Los Angeles Schools. A group that operates 18 elementary, middle, and high schools serving 15,000 students. Tuck has found support in a number of Charter school champions including Bill Evers, a critic of Common Core and Betsy Devos supporter.

Tuck said he learned the necessary ingredients for improving schools by running his own set of charter schools in Los Angeles.

The Conversation

I reached out to both campaigns for an interview. Marshall Tuck responded and here is our conversation:

Latest articles

voters at the ballot box.
4 Principles of Change Open Primary Advocates Must Embrace
This was a big year for the open primaries movement. Seven state-level campaigns and one municipal. Millions of voters declaring their support for open primaries. New leaders emerging across the country. Primary elections for the first time at the center of the national reform debate....
23 Dec, 2024
-
5 min read
House Speaker Mike Johnson
GOP vs GOP: Party Fragmentation in the New Congress
Shawn and Dan dive into the fragmentation within both parties, Elon Musk's entrance as a Republican power broker, and a recent poll showing a surprisingly high level of support for Donald Trump among people who voted for Jill Stein....
23 Dec, 2024
-
1 min read
Young person voting.
2024 Recap: Lessons Learned from the Successes and Failures of Statewide Primary Reform
In 2024, a historic number of statewide initiatives appeared on the ballot to open primary elections to all voters and candidates. Most of the initiatives failed, but reformers were successful in Washington DC. ...
19 Dec, 2024
-
2 min read