Petition Denied: SoccerCity, SDSU West Heading For November Ballot

image
Author: Jeff Powers
Created: 07 Aug, 2018
Updated: 21 Nov, 2022
1 min read

San Diego, CA. - The City Attorney's emergency petition to keep SoccerCity and SDSU West off the November ballot has been denied by the Fourth District Court Of Appeal.

Justices Patricia Benke, Richard Huffman, and Joan Irion  declined to rule on the issues raised by the City Attorney's office.

The Justices wrote, "given the substantial public interest involved, we decline to eliminate the right of the public to express its views on the competing initiatives. There is an important public interest 'in protecting the fundamental right of the people to propose statutory or constitutional changes through the initiative process.'"

The City Attorney raised concerns that the costs to put the initiatives on the ballot would be significant to taxpayers. The Court disagreed, "The City's assertion that it will have to spend taxpayer money to place the SDSU West Initiative on the ballot is not substantial enough to prevent the Initiative from going before the electorate. The petition is DENIED."

City Attorney Responds

IVN San Diego reached out to the City Attorney's office for reaction to the decision.

Communications Director Hilary Nemchik sent the following statement, “We did everything we could to lift the cloud of legal uncertainty over these measures so San Diego voters could participate with confidence in a decision that will impact us for generations.”

California Cities Backed Effort

Last week City Attorney Mara Elliott sent out a release reading the League of California Cities backed the push to prevent SoccerCity and SDSU West from appearing on the November ballot.

The League said the San Diego measures were "invalid" under state law in the opinion of its Legal Advisory Committee. The committee, composed of 24 city attorneys from around the state, monitors litigation and identifies the cases of statewide significance.

https://twitter.com/CityAttorneySD/status/1024697370859065345

IVP Donate

Latest articles

New Yorkers in a cafe.
Will New Yorkers Vote on Open Primaries This November?
The New York City Charter Revision Committee, convened by Mayor Eric Adams, released a preliminary report last week in which it states it is considering two potential reforms to city primary elections that exclude a fifth of the city's electorate. ...
09 May, 2025
-
3 min read
Dont tread on me flag.
Libertarian Party Chair Warns Party in Danger of 'Full Collapse'
Elections in the US make it all, but impossible for third party and independent candidates to compete in most elections. Still, for several decades there have been established third parties at the national level, including the Libertarian, Green, and Reform Parties....
07 May, 2025
-
2 min read
People shopping
Are Independent Voters Prepared to Ride Out Tariff Uncertainty?
For millions of independent voters, short-term pain isn’t just uncomfortable—it’s unsustainable....
07 May, 2025
-
2 min read