Efficiency Gap: The Greatest Weapon to Fight Partisan Gerrymandering

image
Created: 26 Jun, 2017
Updated: 17 Oct, 2022
2 min read

The fight against gerrymandering nationwide is taking a new turn. Courts are no longer just looking at discrimination based on race, sex, or class, but political discrimination and partisan motives to consolidate power and weaken the voice of voters outside the party in power.

First it was Wisconsin. Then it was Pennsylvania. Now, more states are open to legal challenges against partisan gerrymandering thanks to the "efficiency gap," the statistical method used in Whitford v. Gill to determine that Wisconsin Assembly lines were so extremely partisan that it constituted a gerrymander and violated the rights of voters outside the Republican Party.

In the simplest of terms, the "efficiency gap" compares the statewide average share of each party's vote in the districts with the statewide percentage of seats it wins. A consistently large gap between the numbers will indicate a gerrymander has occurred.

New AP analysis using the "efficiency gap" reveals just how extensive the problem of partisan gerrymandering is.

In Indiana, for instance, even though state House Republicans averaged 57.6 percent of the vote, they won 70 out of the state's 100 seats.

In Colorado, a tight battleground state, Democrats took 57 percent of state House seats despite getting just over 50 percent of the statewide vote in November.

Donald Trump took 34 percent of the vote in Maryland, yet only one of its congressional districts is represented by a Republican. This is because Democrats intentionally implemented a 7-1 plan after the 2010 census to ensure they got all, but one seat.

More Choice for San Diego

Pennsylvania is considered one of the biggest offenders of partisan gerrymandering, along with Maryland. A new lawsuit shows that even though Democrats made up the majority of the statewide vote in 2012, Republicans took 72 percent of the congressional districts thanks to their 2011 strategy of "cracking" and "packing."

One district is so bizarrely drawn in Pennsylvania that not only does it look like Goofy kicking Donald Duck, but it is held together in one area only by a seafood shack. Plaintiffs also uses the "efficiency gap" to make their case.

READ MORE: Coalition Sues Pennsylvania over Partisan Gerrymandering

For the first time federal courts are taking on and ruling against state electoral maps, not on the basis of race or other types of socioeconomic discrimination, but on the political motives of the party in power, and it is in large part because of the "efficiency gap."

Photo Credit: Christos Georghiou / shutterstock.com

Latest articles

Man voting.
Maine Lawmakers Vote to Protect RCV Counting Process, Which Generates Results in 'One Minute'
On Monday, Maine's Veterans and Legal Affairs Committee voted 3-7 against restoring batch elimination to the ranked choice voting (RCV) system through LD 656 (HP 424), the title of which claims it will save taxpayers money, but the secretary of state says is unnecessary. ...
11 Mar, 2025
-
1 min read
Vote here signs outside a building.
To Avoid Confusion, Should RCV Just Be Called Instant Runoff Elections?
In discussions with an elderly voter in Colorado about Proposition 131, the unsuccessful 2024 ballot measure to create a nonpartisan primary with ranked choice voting (RCV), in the general election, we learned something important. This individual had voted against Proposition 131, casting his mail ballot on the day he received it. A week later, he received a campaign ad mailer that Colorado’s governor and Denver’s mayor had endorsed Proposition 131, which may have influenced his decision....
11 Mar, 2025
-
5 min read
Sky view of the US capitol building.
Democracy Expert Larry Diamond Warns of Growing Culture of SuperPAC Intimidation in Congress
In his new regular column, Diamond on Democracy, democracy scholar Larry Diamond, acknowledges that “[h]aving won the presidency fair and square, Donald Trump has earned the right to propose, and in many cases to implement, radical new policy directions.” ...
11 Mar, 2025
-
3 min read