SCOTUS Rejects Major Party Challenges to Open Primaries

image
Published: 15 May, 2017
Updated: 17 Oct, 2022
1 min read

The AP reported Monday that the Supreme Court has rejected two cases challenging open primaries in Montana and Hawaii. The justices did not comment on their decision to leave the Ninth Circuit's rulings in place.

The majority parties in both states -- Democratic Party of Hawaii and Republican committees in Montana -- filed a legal challenge against the open primary laws in their respective states, which allow voters to choose a party ballot on primary election day without consideration of their party affiliation.

In both cases, lower courts ruled that the plaintiffs did not provide sufficient evidence that their constitutional rights were severely burdened by open primaries; specifically, their First Amendment right to association.

For now, the high court is staying out of the legal challenges to primary elections. In 2015, the Supreme Court rejected a challenge to closed primaries in New Jersey brought by a coalition of nonpartisan organizations and individual plaintiffs, led by the Independent Voter Project.

Read More About the New Jersey Lawsuit Here.

Photo Credit: Steven Frame / shutterstock.com

Latest articles

Wall St. sign.
Americans Want Congress to Stop Playing the Market — So Why Won’t Lawmakers Listen?
Americans have spoken, again and again — and the message is crystal clear: members of Congress should not be allowed to trade stocks while in office. Yet, despite bipartisan legislative proposals and national scrutiny, Congress continues to stall....
05 Aug, 2025
-
3 min read
stacks of cash.
From Relief to Rage: $100M FireAid Concert Engulfed in Political Scandal
LOS ANGELES, CA – It seems we can’t even have a $100 million benefit concert without inviting partis...
05 Aug, 2025
-
10 min read
One hand holding a blue California and another holding a red Texas in front of the US Capitol Building.
The Redistricting War Is Here — One CA Republican Says It’s Time to Call It Off
Texas Republicans have threatened to redraw their maps to protect their party’s majority in Congress. California Democrats have, in turn, threatened to respond with their own mid-decade redistricting to “fight fire with fire.”...
05 Aug, 2025
-
4 min read