SCOTUS Sets Conference Date for Hawaii, Montana Open Primary Cases

image
Published: 26 Apr, 2017
Updated: 17 Oct, 2022
1 min read

The Supreme Court of the United States will consider whether or not to take up two open primary cases in Montana and Hawaii at its May 11 conference. The cases were brought by the majority party in both states in an effort to get rid of the open primary process.

Lower federal courts in both cases ruled that neither the Democratic Party of Hawaii nor the Republican Party of Montana were able to produce sufficient evidence that the open partisan primary process burdened their constitutional rights of association -- the main complaint from both parties.

READ MORE: SCOTUS Hints Partisan Open Primaries May Be Unconstitutional

“The Democratic Party’s facial challenge fails because the Party has not developed evidence showing that Hawaii’s open primary system severely burdens its associational rights," wrote Judge A. Wallace Tashima for the Ninth Circuit in the Hawaii case.

Tashima added:

“The Democratic Party’s preference for limiting primary participants to registered Party members, coupled with the fact that more people vote in Democratic primaries than are formally registered with the Party, is not sufficient to show that Hawaii’s open primary system severely burdens the Party’s associational rights.”

ALSO READ: Montana GOP: You Have to Join a Party to Vote

Similar conclusions were found in the Montana case as well. But now the case is before the Supreme Court, and if the justices decide to take up one or both cases, any precedent set could have broad consequences on elections across the United States.

Photo Credit: Andrey_Pop / shutterstock.com

Latest articles

California Capitol Building and Flag with Two Lawmakers Shaking Hands & Passports in Front of It
California Is Doing What Congress Can't on Immigration
SACRAMENTO, CA — In an era when immigration remains one of the most divisive issues in American poli...
24 Jul, 2025
-
5 min read
Tulsi Gabbard Reading Documents at a Podium in Front of the Capitol and an American Flag
The Trump Russia Story Was False, but What About Tulsi’s Tale?
WASHINGTON, D.C. — Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard is accusing the Obama administrat...
23 Jul, 2025
-
7 min read
HIRW: The Unfair Fight Between Regulated Cannabis and Unregulated “Gas‑Station” Hemp
How It Really Works: The Unfair Fight Between Legal Cannabis and Unregulated 'Gas‑Station' Hemp
When President Richard Nixon told the nation on June 17, 1971, that drug abuse was “public enemy number one,” he formally launched the War on Drugs and cemented cannabis in Schedule I of the Controlled Substances Act. ...
22 Jul, 2025
-
10 min read