How Does One Judge Block the President?

image
Published: 26 Apr, 2017
Updated: 21 Nov, 2022
2 min read

Several of Trump’s executive orders have now been blocked by federal district court judges.

First the travel ban, then on Tuesday President Trump’s sanctuary city executive order was blocked by U.S. District Judge William Orrick. The judge issued a temporary ruling in a lawsuit against the executive order targeting so-called sanctuary cities.

The decision will remain in place for now, but both cases could make their way to the Supreme Court.

Is it normal for a single, federal judge, such as Orrick, to be able to block the president with their decision? Here's what you need to know to understand how one individual has the authority to block the president.

1. Article III of the Constitution grants this power directly

Article III of the Constitution states that federal courts may only decide executive order cases where “Controversies to which the United States shall be a Party.”

The plaintiff, be it individual, group, or state, must be able to claim a real injury when attacking an executive order. Additionally, plaintiffs must be careful about where they file their case. A lawsuit will often originate in a court where it is likely the judge will rule in their favor.

However, cases can also be appealed all the way to the Supreme Court, which has the final decision.

2. District judges are appointed by presidents for life, and ideology plays a crucial role

Each district judge is appointed for a life term, making it impossible for any single president to nominate all of these judges in their term(s). Thus, district court judges are appointed by both Republican and Democratic presidents.

Judge Orrick is one of 714 U.S. district court judges who are nominated by the president and then approved by the Senate. Orrick was appointed by President Barack Obama, who he reportedly donated to and fundraised for during the 2008 campaign.

IVP Donate

Since the Republican Senate refused to confirm many of Obama’s nominations, President Donald Trump will have the chance to appoint over 100 judges to district and appeals courts.

3. While district judges do have the ability to stop executive orders, it is unusual

While the courts do have the power to declare an executive order illegal or unconstitutional, they do not regularly overturn presidential actions. According to author William G. Howell in his book on the subject of executive actions, in his attempt to list every challenged executive order between 1945-1998, he found that the courts ruled in favor of the president in 83% of cases.

Still, it takes only one judge in one district court to block an executive order made by the President of the United States.

Latest articles

An electric sign of the American flag.
ABC's Sara Haines Calls Out 'Narrow View' that Independent Voters Can't Exist in Trump Era
American journalist and co-host of ABC’s The View, Sara Haines, refutes the notion that people can't be independent-minded in their election choices in an era in which the Republican Party is controlled by Trump – a perspective voiced by her colleague, Sunny Houstin that Haines describes as “narrow.”...
06 Jun, 2025
-
3 min read
US map divided in blue and red with a white ballot box on top.
Could Maine Be the First State to Exit the National Popular Vote Compact?
On May 20, the Maine House of Representatives voted 76–71 to withdraw the state from the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC), reversing course just over a year after Maine became the 17th jurisdiction to join the agreement....
04 Jun, 2025
-
3 min read
New York City
Nine Democrats Face Off in NYC Mayoral Debate as Ranked Choice Voting, Cuomo Probe, and Independent Bid from Adams Reshape the Race
A crowded field of nine Democratic candidates will take the stage tonight, June 4, in the first official debate of the 2025 New York City mayoral primary. Held at NBC’s 30 Rock studios and co-sponsored by the city’s Campaign Finance Board, NBC 4 New York, Telemundo 47, and POLITICO New York, the debate comes at a pivotal moment in a race already shaped by political upheaval, criminal investigations, and the unique dynamics of ranked choice voting....
04 Jun, 2025
-
6 min read