How Does One Judge Block the President?

image
Created: 26 Apr, 2017
Updated: 21 Nov, 2022
2 min read

Several of Trump’s executive orders have now been blocked by federal district court judges.

First the travel ban, then on Tuesday President Trump’s sanctuary city executive order was blocked by U.S. District Judge William Orrick. The judge issued a temporary ruling in a lawsuit against the executive order targeting so-called sanctuary cities.

The decision will remain in place for now, but both cases could make their way to the Supreme Court.

Is it normal for a single, federal judge, such as Orrick, to be able to block the president with their decision? Here's what you need to know to understand how one individual has the authority to block the president.

1. Article III of the Constitution grants this power directly

Article III of the Constitution states that federal courts may only decide executive order cases where “Controversies to which the United States shall be a Party.”

The plaintiff, be it individual, group, or state, must be able to claim a real injury when attacking an executive order. Additionally, plaintiffs must be careful about where they file their case. A lawsuit will often originate in a court where it is likely the judge will rule in their favor.

However, cases can also be appealed all the way to the Supreme Court, which has the final decision.

2. District judges are appointed by presidents for life, and ideology plays a crucial role

Each district judge is appointed for a life term, making it impossible for any single president to nominate all of these judges in their term(s). Thus, district court judges are appointed by both Republican and Democratic presidents.

Judge Orrick is one of 714 U.S. district court judges who are nominated by the president and then approved by the Senate. Orrick was appointed by President Barack Obama, who he reportedly donated to and fundraised for during the 2008 campaign.

IVP Donate

Since the Republican Senate refused to confirm many of Obama’s nominations, President Donald Trump will have the chance to appoint over 100 judges to district and appeals courts.

3. While district judges do have the ability to stop executive orders, it is unusual

While the courts do have the power to declare an executive order illegal or unconstitutional, they do not regularly overturn presidential actions. According to author William G. Howell in his book on the subject of executive actions, in his attempt to list every challenged executive order between 1945-1998, he found that the courts ruled in favor of the president in 83% of cases.

Still, it takes only one judge in one district court to block an executive order made by the President of the United States.

Latest articles

Custom image that says Immigration reform with two migrants on the left and border security with a border agent on the right. The words Why Not Both are in the middle.
Democrat Senator Gallego Releases Plan for Immigration Reform that Party Loyalists Won’t Like
Senator Ruben Gallego (D-Ariz.) has introduced a plan for systemic immigration reform and a front-and-center border security plan to reach what he says should be a bipartisan goal of “getting illegal border crossing to as near zero as possible.” ...
16 May, 2025
-
6 min read
A young woman voting.
Pennsylvania Rep Chris Rabb: There Should Be No Second-Class Voters In Our State
A bill that would open Pennsylvania primary elections to over 1.4 million registered independent voters, HB 280, cleared its first major hurdle to becoming law this week when it cleared the House State Government Committee....
15 May, 2025
-
3 min read
Boston
Boston City Council Backs Ranked Choice Voting Home Rule Petition in 8–4 Vote
On May 14, the Boston City Council voted 8–4 in favor of a Home Rule Petition allowing voters to rank candidates in order of preference, a shift that could change how Bostonians elect their leaders....
14 May, 2025
-
3 min read