Justice Scalia: Like All of Us, There Was Both Good and Bad

image
Stephen YearwoodStephen Yearwood
Published: 15 Feb, 2016
1 min read

Justice Anton Scalia died, and there is always sadness in death. People loved him and cared about him and will miss him.

Justice Scalia was also an important member of the Supreme Court. Intellectually, he was a devout ‘originalist.’ In that, he was at best wrongheaded.

Originalism is the doctrine that we must apply the Constitution to the issues of today based on what the words in it, and arguments for and against it, meant to the people who debated and wrote that monumental document.

That is perhaps the most absurd notion ever to be taken seriously in the history of notions: it is impossible to know what those words meant to those people. We can be certain, however, that the words in it and related to it had different meanings for different people, just as words today have different meanings for different people.

Even if it might be a good idea to base the judgments of today on the meanings of words to people back then, there would obviously be more than one interpretation of what those meanings were. Justice Scalia obviously intended that we should all abide by his interpretation of the meanings those words had for those people way back then.

I detested the style of Justice Scalia. In it, he reminded me of Rush Limbaugh. It is one thing to act that way on the radio, but to me it is grotesque to employ such rhetorical antics in the chambers of our Supreme Court. Even so, I admire him and Justice Ginsberg for their exemplary behavior in their personal relationship. In that the two of them reminded all of us that, despite our differences in style, ideology, cultural preferences, etc., we can still act like human beings with regard to one another.

Photo Credit: Mark Avery/Orange County Register/ZUMA Press

You Might Also Like

Will the Texas Republican Party be Successful Where the Hawaiian Democratic Party Failed?
Will the Texas Republican Party be Successful Where the Hawaiian Democratic Party Failed?
The Republican Party of Texas (RPT) is suing Secretary of State Jane Nelson in an effort to close the state’s primary elections to party members only – a move that the Democratic Party of Hawaii (DPH) tried back in 2013 in its state and failed. ...
05 Sep, 2025
-
3 min read
Supreme Court building.
Retired Attorney Takes Voting Rights Case All the Way to the Supreme Court -- By Himself
The next big voting rights case the Supreme Court of the United States could consider wasn’t filed by the ACLU, the League of Women Voters, Common Cause, or another household name when it comes to voter rights. ...
09 Sep, 2025
-
5 min read
congress flag
Poll: 82% of Americans Want Redistricting Done by Independent Commission, Not Politicians
There may be no greater indication that voters are not being listened to in the escalating redistricting war between the Republican and Democratic Parties than a new poll from NBC News that shows 8-in-10 Americans want the parties to stop....
10 Sep, 2025
-
3 min read