logo

Don't Be Deceived By The Federal Reserve; It Is Not An 'Independent' Agency

image
Created: 17 April, 2015
Updated: 15 October, 2022
2 min read

WASHINGTON, D.C. -- Audit the Fed, a cause championed by former U.S. Representative Ron Paul (R-Texas), was picked up by Paul's son, U.S. Senator Rand Paul (R-Ky.), early on in his political career.

For some voters, including more libertarian-minded voters, auditing the central bank is as important of an issue as raising the minimum wage is for progressives. Now that Sen. Paul has entered the 2016 presidential election, the issue may get a little more attention.

The goal behind auditing the Fed is to increase transparency in the U.S. central bank. According to Rand Paul’s campaign website, in the "Audit the Fed" section under "Issues":

“The Federal Reserve was created by Congress and is supposed to be overseen by Congress. The Fed is now in every nook and cranny of banking with unprecedented regulatory powers and no Congressional oversight. I believe the Fed should be audited and the regulatory power should be placed back under the control of Congress.”

The Federal Reserve, created by Congress in 1913, is the "independent" central bank of the United States. This means it is supposed to operate outside the political scrutiny of the executive and legislative branches, and is charged with providing "the nation with a safer, more flexible, and more stable monetary and financial system."

Fed Chair Janet Yellen and other officials within the central bank have argued that a full audit (the Fed already must comply with a partial audit) and greater oversight over the Federal Reserve from Congress would compromise the independence of the agency, and would subject the Fed's monetary policy to the politics of the Legislative Branch.

 

 

However, when so many other issues are politicized, such as Obama reopening relations with Cuba or the Iran nuclear deal, can the Fed get by without political scrutiny in its job of preserving the economy?

According to the U.S. government, there are roughly

70 different “independent” government agencies that were created by Congress. If politicizing the Fed’s monetary policy is not enough, what about controversial Environmental Protection Agency policies?

More Choice for San Diego

The EPA and Social Security Administration are two other prominent agencies that were created by Congress to oversee policies that go beyond the “scope of ordinary legislation.”

Any government agency that claims to be independent is not truly independent because it owes its very existence to Congress. The president also nominates the C-level administrators for these groups and the Senate goes through the motions of approval.

By politicizing these issues, it would allow politicians, regardless of party affiliation, a greater say in every miniscule policy -- such as monetary policy.

Perhaps the economist James Galbraith said it best: "That independence is of course independence from the executive branch."

It is Congress' responsibility to hold the central bank accountable for its decisions and the impact they have on the economy. There can only be unilateral action until Congress calls a hearing, an investigation, or even an audit. Independence from the Legislative Branch, in this case, is a myth.

Photo Credit: Orhan Cam / shutterstock.com

Latest articles

Supreme Court of the United States
Recess Appointments: How Do They Work and Will Trump Be Able to Make Them?
One of the biggest legal questions going into the second term of President-Elect Donald Trump is, will he try to push through cabinet appointments he wants during a congressional recess? And... can he?...
25 November, 2024
-
3 min read
A wide shot of an Alaska city.
In a True Nail-Biter, Alaska Voters Reject Repeal of Top 4 Primary and Ranked Choice Voting
Two weeks after Election Day, Alaska voters finally know the fate of their election system. The choice before them was keep the nonpartisan Top 4 primary system with ranked choice voting in the general election or go back to partisan control over elections....
21 November, 2024
-
5 min read
Coin with Trump's face on it.
How Will the New Government Affect Independent Voters' Finances?
My rates! What happened to my rates? Partisan and independent voters ranked the economy the most important issue in the 2024 election....
20 November, 2024
-
9 min read