Can the GOP Create Consensus from Gridlock?

image
Created: 03 Nov, 2014
Updated: 15 Oct, 2022
2 min read

When the House switched to Republican control in the 2010 midterms, it was treated as a referendum on President Barack Obama’s health care law. Two years later, the GOP set its sights on the White House. However, Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney was not able to beat Obama. Now, the Senate is the prize in next week’s elections.

The GOP is now promising consensus the same way Obama, as a presidential candidate, promised unity. The current Senate minority leader, Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) would have the most to gain from Republicans taking over the majority and that responsibility falls on him.

Critics would say that this was part of his master plan to obstruct Obama’s executive orders and legislative efforts, but the senior senator from Kentucky understands the power behind a disgruntled electorate and the importance of consensus.

Especially, if that consensus crosses partisan lines:

“An executive order can’t . The fiat of a nine-person court can’t do it. A raucous and precarious partisan majority in the House can’t do it. The only institution that can make stable and enduring laws is the one we have in which all 50 states are represented equally, and where every single senator has a say in the laws that we pass.”

The Senate majority leader can’t simply pass all the bills he wants no matter what party he belongs to. It would benefit the Republicans to be more open with their opponents once they are in charge so as not to re-create the obstructionist methods that became a trait of both parties.

There are some areas where McConnell should not cave in with the more conservative wing of the House. Take health care reform for example.

The Democratic majority in the Senate has been the primary bulwark preventing any House-approved repeal-Obamacare legislation. Now, even if the Senate does turn red, the ACA still has other safeguards protecting it.

There is no way Obama will sign a law repealing his prized legislative victory. It would be futile for McConnell to focus on that while the public is clamoring for Congress to fix so many other areas like the economy and jobs, foreign policy, and energy policy.

There are plenty of stories in the news about what the Republicans will do when they pick up 6 seats. Their goal should not be to continue running Congress the way their colleagues ran the House since 2010. There will be no need for that.

Sen. McConnell will be judged on his words if he is serious about creating a non-raucous and more certain Senate. If working with Democrats to pass bills is the way to go, so be it. The trick will be to select the bills that can survive a filibuster, assuming McConnell is serious about changing that rule as well.

IVP Donate

No photo credit attributed.

Latest articles

Andrew Cuomo
DOJ Opens Cuomo Investigation as Ranked Choice Mayoral Primary Nears
The New York Times scooped on May 20 that the U.S. Department of Justice has opened a criminal investigation into Andrew Cuomo, the former New York governor and current front-runner in the city’s Democratic mayoral primary. The inquiry focuses on Cuomo’s testimony to Congress about his administration’s handling of nursing home admissions during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic....
21 May, 2025
-
3 min read
Two women having a conversation.
The Rule of Five: How to Avoid Talking about Politics
At college, one of my double majors was Political Science. At the time, I remember thinking that I’d always be able to hold my own in a conversation if I had a basic understanding of politics. I still feel that way, but I no longer want to talk about politics (unless it’s about office politics)....
21 May, 2025
-
4 min read
An angel raising a key to prison bars.
More Than a Uniform: Remembering Annie Covarrubias and the Crisis Facing Correctional Officers
Last week, California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) officials announced the sudden passing of Annie Covarrubias, a correctional officer at the Correctional Training Facility (CTF) in Soledad. She was 35 years old. In the words of her colleagues, Annie was a “dependable, professional, and kind” officer, known for her dedication to both her peers and the incarcerated individuals she worked with every day....
20 May, 2025
-
2 min read