NSA Violated Constitution by Breaching Tens of Thousands of American Emails

image
Brian IniguezBrian Iniguez
Published: 22 Aug, 2013
2 min read
National trust in the NSA could further deplete in the wake of a 2011 

court ruling released Wednesday. Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISA) chief justice Judge John D. Bates declared the methods undertaken by the agency unconstitutional and overreaching in authority.

The NSA is purported to have gathered and stored thousands of communications belonging to American citizens, a stark difference to what the secret court had been led to believe in both scope and nature. Bates had not been aware the extent to which the agency had intervened in civil life.

The document outlining the court's decision also reveals the NSA's records of breaching its own surveillance protocol annually, with tens of thousands of Americans' emails being "gathered" along with foreign intel.

Some argue that these are merely statistically inevitable mistakes and not an abuse of authority. Others call for a discontinuation of the agency altogether, crying Big Brother. The NSA is claiming they're doing this for national security. So, how well have they performed?

Director General Keith Alexander gave a very telling speech at the Black Hat computer-security conference:

"I promise you the truth -- what we know, what we're doing, and what I cannot tell you because we don't want to jeopardize our future defense."

Alexander also revealed two important numbers, validating his agency's existence. Fifty-four terrorist attacks, according to Alexander, have been prevented worldwide. Thirteen of them were based in the U.S.

The specifics of the thwarted attacks were left unsaid.

Despite its unpopularity, the NSA claims to track only about .00004 percent of all web traffic, an extremely small amount considering the scale of everyday networking. How does an agency that only looks at one part per million of the Internet accidentally store citizens' information?

Alexander provides:

IVP Donate

"A US person might be courtesy copied on an e-mail to or from a legitimate foreign target, or a person in the US might be in contact with a known terrorist target."

Considering the questionable cases surrounding Internet arrests, these mistakes could end up costing someone their livelihood.

Americans finding out that a court ruled the NSA's methods unconstitutional two years later will further sour the relationship between the people and their government.

Photo Credit: Credit: amaze646 / Shutterstock.com

You Might Also Like

Ethan Penner
Could This Well-Funded Independent Upend the CA Governor’s Race?
Ethan Penner, a Calabasas businessman, author, and educator with a storied career in real estate finance, has officially announced his intention to run for California governor in 2026 as an independent. On his campaign website, Penner says he is running to “disrupt the failing two-party system.” ...
12 Sep, 2025
-
5 min read
Supreme Court of the United States
Forward Party Joins Petition to SCOTUS Against State of Florida
Right now, the divide between the Republican and Democratic Parties appears beyond repair. The political rhetoric is toxic, the nation’s leadership puts party gain before lasting solutions, and few voters actually feel heard by the people elected to represent them. At a time when it seems things will only get worse from here, the Independent Voter Project filed an amicus brief with the U.S. Supreme Court along with Open Primaries and the Forward Party in support of a lawsuit that targets one of the biggest culprits behind all of this....
16 Sep, 2025
-
3 min read
congress flag
Poll: 82% of Americans Want Redistricting Done by Independent Commission, Not Politicians
There may be no greater indication that voters are not being listened to in the escalating redistricting war between the Republican and Democratic Parties than a new poll from NBC News that shows 8-in-10 Americans want the parties to stop....
10 Sep, 2025
-
3 min read