California and Quebec Unite in a Growing Carbon Market

image
Published: 28 May, 2013
3 min read
Refinery in Valero, California // credit: californiareport.org

Refinery in Valero, California // credit: californiareport.org

 Many find it a surprise to learn that amid rising concern about the environment, President Richard Nixon in 1970 proposed the creation of an Environmental Protection Agency, a National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, and signed amendments to the 1967 Clean Air Act calling for reductions in automobile emissions and the national testing of air quality.

Such people may find it equally extraordinary that California established its Air Resources Board under Governor Ronald Reagan.  Aside from their party affiliations, both Nixon and Reagan shared another likeness that may account for their similar alignments on environmental issues – both were Californians and, at one time, representatives of the state.

Although neither of these former presidents would ever be seen as “environmentalists” in any sense of the term, both hailed from a state that has lead the nation, and occasionally the world, in terms of environmental policy making.

More recently, in 2006, California’s Republican Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger signed Assembly Bill 32, the Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006, creating emissions standards and an emissions trading scheme for the state.

Though the signing was fraught with disdain from those with differing political views, what was more interesting was the fear that such a law would put California at a comparative disadvantage and cause emissions to increase in jurisdictions with less strict climate as a result of energy intensive sectors fleeing California – a situation known as “carbon leakage.”

In the years since AB 32 was signed, the California Air Resources Board and a number of state politicians have been working to expand the California model and provide for a larger marketplace where this problem is mitigated.

On Friday, May 17, the California Air Resources Board linked its carbon “cap and trade” program with one in the Canadian province of Quebec. The merger begins January 1, 2014.  As a result, Quebec's permits that let polluters emit carbon dioxide can be purchased and used by California oil refineries, food processors, cement plants and other facilities.  Similarly, California-issued pollution permits will be valid in Quebec.

The linkage agreement also provides an opportunity to closely monitor and fine tune these first two programs, setting the stage for similar arrangements with other jurisdictions that are committed to reducing greenhouse gases.  “Expanding the program to Quebec creates a laboratory for broadening the trading system to other U.S. states, Canadian provinces and nations,” said Dave Clegern, an Air Resources Board spokesman.

IVP Donate

It should be noted that not all are pleased with the administrative board’s decision.  California Chamber of Commerce has argued for a number of years that AB 32 essentially constitutes a tax, a measure that requires a supermajority, which the bill did not receive.  Others, including a number of environmental groups, argue that the state program is moving too slowly.

The administration of California Governor Jerry Brown argues that the strength of this partnership is not limited to the two jurisdictions alone. Its real strength, they argue, is that the partnership creates a path for future partners to follow. Currently, other U.S. states and Canadian provinces are watching carefully and beginning to talk about joining this movement. In addition, there are now discussions with Australia, the cap-and-trade program in the Northeast U.S., and the European Union.  For now, we are left to wait amid this twenty-first century experiment in federalism.

You Might Also Like

Trump sitting in the oval office with a piece of paper with a cannabis leaf on his desk.
Is Trump About to Outflank Democrats on Cannabis? Progressives Sound the Alarm
As President Donald Trump signals renewed interest in reclassifying cannabis from a Schedule I drug to Schedule III, a policy goal long championed by liberals and libertarians, the reaction among some partisan progressive advocates is not celebration, but concern....
08 Dec, 2025
-
5 min read
Malibu, California.
From the Palisades to Simi Valley, Independent Voters Poised to Decide the Fight to Replace Jacqui Irwin
The coastline that defines California’s mythology begins here. From Malibu’s winding cliffs to the leafy streets of Brentwood and Bel Air, through Topanga Canyon and into the valleys of Calabasas, Agoura Hills, and Thousand Oaks, the 42nd Assembly District holds some of the most photographed, most coveted, and most challenged terrain in the state. ...
10 Dec, 2025
-
6 min read
Ranked choice voting
Ranked Choice for Every Voter? New Bill Would Transform Every Congressional Election by 2030
As voters brace for what is expected to be a chaotic and divisive midterm election cycle, U.S. Representatives Jamie Raskin (Md.), Don Beyer (Va.), and U.S. Senator Peter Welch (Vt.) have re-introduced legislation that would require ranked choice voting (RCV) for all congressional primaries and general elections beginning in 2030....
10 Dec, 2025
-
3 min read