SOPA: Weighing Arguments for Online Piracy

image
Author: Matt Metzner
Published: 22 Jan, 2012
Updated: 13 Oct, 2022
3 min read

This week several major websites and services opted to go dark in response to an upcoming vote on the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA) and Protect Intellectual Property Act (PIPA). The bill would allow intellectual property rights holders to petition the Department of Justice to shut down a site until potentially infringing material is removed. Beyond the arguments about freedom of information, speech, and press there are other economic and social factors that we are not hearing as much about.

The major supporters of SOPA and PIPA are largely from the entertainment industry and we are seeing a Hollywood vs. Silicon Valley battle play out on our computers and in Congress. Online piracy is not that bad for America or for the entertainment industry. Many Americans who willingly pirate entertainment media do so because they are not willing to pay the market price.

What is missing from the debate has been the reasons for its existence and associated societal benefits. When a major studio produces a film and sells it on iTunes for $12.99 it is surely cheaper than going to a store and purchasing the film for $20. But, when consumers can download the film for free, many will choose that option. This is not because they are thieves, but because they are making an economic decision where the value of the good to them is significantly lower than the market price.

Continuing to offer $5 worth of enjoyment to consumers for $12.99 is not going to work anymore. With other options available to consumers, they will find avenues to either gather the entertainment they desire at or below the cost they are willing to pay for it, or seek entertainment in other ways.

Intellectual property owners are treating these exchanges as lost sales, and in many ways they are, but they are ignoring the opportunity to turn them into sales. Instead of attempting to shut down websites with potentially infringing material, the entertainment industry should be focused on offering innovative means of consumption to the general public. When a downloader obtains a copy of a film or album they are still going to recommend it to their social networks if it is a good piece. This leads to other sales, exchanges, and social equity that are not being factored into the equation.

Let’s not forget that when online piracy started spreading as a public practice the industry responded with sites like Hulu, iTunes, and Netflix. These are all avenues that thousands of consumers use on a daily basis and provide models for future breakthroughs. Ultimately studios and labels may have to turn their creative content into a means for attracting users and capitalizing in several ways instead of solely on the sale of the film or album itself.

The entertainment industry has been struggling to find ways to protect their intellectual property for years and SOPA is just another stab at it. For the problem to go away, the industry must recognize the real value of their products and offer them at that price or find alternative methods to capitalize on them aside from shutting down online portals.

Online piracy could turn out to be the catalyst that propels the entertainment industry into the future as it incentivizes IP owners to move beyond their traditional models. Until that happens, the web community has spoken, keep your hands off our information.

 

IVP Donate

 

Latest articles

CA capitol building dome with flags.
Why is CA Senator Mike McGuire Trying to Kill the Legal Cannabis Industry?
California’s legal cannabis industry is under mounting pressure, and in early June, state lawmakers and the governor appeared poised to help. A bill to freeze the state’s cannabis excise tax at 15% sailed through the State Assembly with a unanimous 74-0 vote. The governor’s office backed the plan. And legal cannabis businesses, still struggling to compete with unregulated sellers and mounting operating costs, saw a glimmer of hope....
03 Jul, 2025
-
7 min read
I voted buttons
After First RCV Election, Charlottesville Voters Back the Reform: 'They Get It, They Like It, They Want to Do It Again'
A new survey out of Charlottesville, Virginia, shows overwhelming support for ranked choice voting (RCV) following the city’s first use of the system in its June Democratic primary for City Council. Conducted one week after the election, the results found that nearly 90% of respondents support continued use of RCV....
03 Jul, 2025
-
3 min read
Crowd in Time Square.
NYC Exit Survey: 96% of Voters Understood Their Ranked Choice Ballots
An exit poll conducted by SurveyUSA on behalf of the nonprofit better elections group FairVote finds that ranked choice voting (RCV) continues to be supported by a vast majority of voters who find it simple, fair, and easy to use. The findings come in the wake of the city’s third use of RCV in its June 2025 primary elections....
01 Jul, 2025
-
6 min read