What Would Reagan Do?

image
Wes MessamoreWes Messamore
Published: 20 Jul, 2010
3 min read

On Monday, Governor Schwarzenegger signed a bill to plan celebrations for what would have been Ronald Reagan's 100th birthday next year, and another bill declaring February 6th as Ronald Reagan day. Nationwide, conservatives have been pining for their "next Reagan" to lead America out of its economic woes and toward a vision of limited government and individual liberty.

It might be worth considering the answer- on a state level- to a question that is oft-repeated by conservatives for more national issues of public policy: What would Reagan do?

Ronald Reagan was after all, the Governor of California before he became "The Great Communicator" of conservative ideas on a national level, as President of the United States. He came in as a Sacramento-outsider during an unpopular war and with a substantial fiscal mess to clean up (though not quite the abject budget crisis California faces today). Are there any lessons to be gleaned from Reagan's tenure in Sacramento?

Let's have a look.

Reagan won on a "Tea Party"-style platform as a political outsider and ordinary citizen who had had enough with politics as usual, and planned to make Sacramento more efficient and accountable. After a landslide victory against incumbent governor Edmund G. Brown, Reagan froze government hiring and ordered an across-the-board reduction in state spending by ten percent, a solution echoed by the budget-cutting strategy of today's Republicans in California.

Before a year had passed, however, Governor Reagan was faced with the harsh fiscal realities of Sacramento, and after restoring funding to several of the state programs, which couldn't survive the spending cuts, Reagan did something more in line with what today's Democrats propose: he pressed for a major tax increase.

Democrats in the Legislature crafted a very progressive tax hike (which is to say, one that falls more heavily to higher-income taxpayers). It was the highest tax increase in the history of California or any other U.S. state at the time. Reagan signed it, blaming his predecessor for making the tax increase necessary through two terms of irresponsible government.

California ran a budget surplus in the following years, but instead of taking the opportunity to shore up the state's finances and put it on the road to lasting fiscal soundness, Reagan then grew government programs to an alarming level. In total, Reagan's budgets were twice that of his predecessor's, and he ramped up spending on state programs and projects that his conservative supporters vowed to cut.

IVP Donate

Here we are decades later with a budget that continues to grow and a Legislature at its wit's end to keep up with it. Examining Reagan's time in Sacramento, we can learn some important lessons about California's fiscal problems.

Number one, arbitrary and unimaginitive spending cuts can cause a lot of harm without fixing the root inefficiencies of government. Number two, it is possible to get out of a fiscal hole and run budget surpluses, though tax hikes might be necessary in the short-term to accomplish that. Number three, it is also possible (and very easy, even for an avowed conservative) to climb right back into that fiscal hole by allowing state programs and pork to grow.

Now that we know what Reagan would do, let's advance the discussion by talking about what California's next governor should do to fix California's budget deficit.

You Might Also Like

SQ836 supporters
Oklahoma GOP Fails To Block Open Primaries Initiative from Going Before Voters
The Oklahoma Supreme Court on Tuesday unanimously rejected a challenge to a proposed ballot initiative that would open taxpayer-funded primary elections to all candidates and voters, regardless of party affiliation – paving the way for the signature petition process to begin....
17 Sep, 2025
-
4 min read
Supreme Court of the United States
Forward Party Joins Petition to SCOTUS Against State of Florida
Right now, the divide between the Republican and Democratic Parties appears beyond repair. The political rhetoric is toxic, the nation’s leadership puts party gain before lasting solutions, and few voters actually feel heard by the people elected to represent them. At a time when it seems things will only get worse from here, the Independent Voter Project filed an amicus brief with the U.S. Supreme Court along with Open Primaries and the Forward Party in support of a lawsuit that targets one of the biggest culprits behind all of this....
16 Sep, 2025
-
3 min read
congress flag
Poll: 82% of Americans Want Redistricting Done by Independent Commission, Not Politicians
There may be no greater indication that voters are not being listened to in the escalating redistricting war between the Republican and Democratic Parties than a new poll from NBC News that shows 8-in-10 Americans want the parties to stop....
10 Sep, 2025
-
3 min read