Obama vs. Paul Ryan Budget Plan: Interactive Graph
By W. E. Messamore on 08/13/2012 in Barack Obama, budget, comparison, fiscal policy, graph, interactive graph, obama budget, paul ryan, paul ryan budget, Ryan budget with 6 CommentsRead Time: 2 - 4 minutes
The following interactive graph for comparing the Paul Ryan and Barack Obama budget proposals is pretty nifty. Here’s how to read it:
Select from the dropdown box for a list of items you can chart. You can also hover over any of the orange or blue boxes for a popup display comparing the budgetary difference between the Obama and Ryan proposals for that year, for that item.
Boxes in blue are years in which Paul Ryan has budgeted more for an item than President Obama. Boxes in Orange are the reverse.
Straight Up Comparison
Numbers for President Obama come from Whitehouse Budget Summary Tables page 174 (PDF page 6).
Numbers for Paul Ryan come from Path to Prosperity Table S-3 on PDF page 64.
The category items are identical except Ryan has an extra item for Global War on Terror. To equalize, we added Global War on Terror to Security.
Without making any judgment to the contrary, let’s assume Ryan and Obama can both “deliver”. Here are a few charts depicting the results.
What strikes me is how closely so many of these line graphs trend together. Then note on Medicare, that far from pushing grandma off a cliff, the graph looks like Ryan is pushing her uphill. His plan spends even more than Obama’s! Just another example of reality and rhetoric not matching up. This is why it’s important to look at cold, hard facts like numbers on “boring” graphs instead of just reading bumper stickers and listening to talking heads argue.
Have at it:
Interactive graph by: Tableau Software
Hat tip: Zero Hedge for the good find





Leave Your Comment →
6 Comments
Kim Brechtel
08.14.2012
What s the OTHER? There is the big difference?
R Phillips
08.14.2012
I believe you are comparing Ryan to CBO Baseline, not Obama Budget? At least for Other, did not check figures…. Table S-4 is Obama, not S-3
R Phillips
08.14.2012
After digging deeper, it appears you are using an adjusted version for Obama budget. Why is that? Is there an adjusted version for Ryan’s Plan? Want my ducks lined up, when I defend the Ryan Plan to Obama’s here in San Francisco.
W. E. Messamore
08.17.2012
@W__E__Messamore
The numbers for President Obama came from the Whitehouse Budget Summary Tables and the numbers for Paul Ryan come from his Path to Prosperity, so the graph here is simply taking both candidates at their word. I think that’s pretty fair.
solution to snoring
05.05.2013
My brother suggested I may like this web site. He was once entirely
right. This put up actually made my day. You can not consider simply how much time I had spent for this information!
Thanks!
credit counseling va
05.05.2013
Good way of describing, and pleasant post to get facts about my presentation
subject, which i am going to convey in college.