Obama’s Immigration Policy Spurs GOP Criticism
By Jane Susskind | 06/15/2012 | Immigration | 15 Comments
The change in Obama's immigration policy is cheered by young immigrations upset about the increase in deportations under the Obama Administration. Photo Credit: AP, June 14, 2012
In a statement made today, Secretary of Homeland Security Janet Napolitano told reporters that the White House will halt deportation of young immigrants with no criminal background who came to the U.S. as children, and give them work permits.
“Today, I am announcing that effective immediately, young people brought to U.S. by no fault of their own and meet several criteria no longer are removed from country or entered into removal proceedings.”
Some are likening the drastic policy change to the Dream Act, which has been deadlocked in Congress for years. Greg Sargent from the Washington Post argues the policy is more like GOP Senator and potential VP nominee Marco Rubio’s alternative to the Dream Act, questioning whether the GOP would still support it with Obama’s name stamped on it. Given the highly politicized nature of immigration policy, Sargent continues:
Republicans will likely try to take credit for it by arguing that Rubio’s work on the DREAM alternative made this happen. But it was already unclear whether Republicans — Romney included — would have the room to back such an alternative, given the GOP base’s passions on the issue. So what many Republicans will likely do now is object to the new initiative on the basis of process, arguing that Obama’s end run around Congress represents tyranny and the like.
In an election that may come down to the Latino vote, GOP leaders are attacking Obama’s immigration policy, calling it an abuse of power. Rep. Allen West tweets,
On the President’s decision to grant certain rights to illegals…This is yet another example of executive overreach! tinyurl.com/c9sz3x8
— Allen West (@AllenWest) June 15, 2012
In defense of the policy, Napolitano clarifies, ”It is not immunity, it is not amnesty,” she said. “It is an exercise of discretion so that these young people are not in the removal system.”
This law will go into effect immediately, and is set to affect an estimated 800,000 young immigrants. While some Republicans question the president’s intentions in an election year, Obama has made passing the Dream Act a top priority throughout his campaign. The real concern may be the effect this will have on the GOP efforts to win over the Latino vote, an issue that Romney has already struggled with.
This election year move may have GOP leaders up in arms, but young immigrants around the country cheer Obama’s new policy. The Los Angeles Times documents reactions in LA.
“At the beginning I sort of didn’t believe it, but then almost immediately I was overwhelmed by a sense of joy. It gives me hope, it motivates me to continue fighting for my family, for my community.” - Mora, an undocumented student at UCLA
President Obama is set to make an official statement on his policy later this afternoon.





Leave Your Comment →
15 Comments
Lucas Eaves
06.15.2012
@lucaseaves
You should not allow children to go through deportation processes ! This is great news.
Pete Barbour
06.15.2012
Who needs Congress? One man should not be able to create law. Executive Orders give one person too much power.
Dave MacDonald
06.15.2012
I believe it is a cop-out and pandering for votes in November. There is no excuse for giving illegals a free ride. Yes, comprehensive immigration reform is badly needed. From overhaul on how and when the state department handles it, stronger penalties for employers, a guest worker program, but no amnesty for illegals already here. Welfare, tax credits, free education or any other welfare should be reserved for American citizens only. Contribution to the American economy must be a part of any immigration application. Even of the proposal is passed there should be no hooks allowing for more relatives, friends, etc to qualify for immigration or citizenship. In the meantime, deportations should continue.
Justin Buell
06.15.2012
I’m not a big fan of deportation, but I’m not sure about this policy.
Laurie Buckley
06.15.2012
I like it…we can do better, but this is a good idea..
Bill Jurkovich
06.15.2012
It’s not about votes. These illegals can’t vote. Epic FAIL!
Bambi Pawlowicz
06.15.2012
I don’t think this a good idea … We have Americans who we aren’t helping including but not limited to, our service men and women who have come home to no job and homes being foreclosed on!! Let’s work on us first
Diane Newman
06.15.2012
Duh!
John G White
06.15.2012
Yea they say yes but there sitting there on there hands doing NOTHING AS USUAL………..THERE NOTHING BUT A BUNCH OF SORRY ASS SOCIALISTS THEMSELVES OR THE MOST GUTLESS AMERICANS IN EXISTENCE.
Ciro J. Giue
06.15.2012
They can’t vote yet… My problem with this is that sometimes parents go to great dangerous lengths to get them and their kids here. Crossing the Caribbean on a rinky dink raft… Hiking across a dangerous desert… Swimming across a dangerous river… This sends a message that these dangerous lengths to get hear just might be worth the risk. I think this put peoples lives at risk!!!
Laura Cochran
06.15.2012
yes i think it is
Ted Rigsby
06.15.2012
i agree with ciro. its not who is here but how they get here that has caused more harm then anything. the fact that a crimnal should be deported is still kept in the picture. those kids who are truely trying may not be a bad thing to stay but its a hard subject and i dont know what the answer is.
Ted Rigsby
06.15.2012
i do see it as a way to buy votes. i would like him to do what is best for the country not the last min stuff to try and make himself look good.
Bernadine Martin
06.16.2012
They have been here all their lives so what is going to change by not deporting them? Perhaps we should take down the Statue of Liberty…
Bob Jackson
06.20.2012
So, What’s New? The 35% Opposed to President Obama’s Executive Order were represented by “The Stealth Republican Leadership – Strategy Meeting” (during Obama’s 2009 Inauguration) Meeting Agenda: The U. S. Congress Blocking Any & Everything President Obama Proposes, during his time in office. When that’s your Agenda, how long do you think it’ll take before there’s “Outright Public Disrespect” for the Office of the President? …….