Farm Labor Shortage Looms
By Chris Hinyub | 05/04/2012 | Economy, Immigration, Issues | 45 Comments
When the nation’s farmers started experiencing labor shortages last year they didn’t know what to expect for the future; for many, the situation was without precedent. Early indicators for the 2012 season don’t bode well for the nation’s specialty crop growers who rely mainly on human labor instead of power-driven machines to bring their produce to market. No one is hitting the panic button just yet, but the situation is a bit scary.
According to Seattle NPR affiliate KPLU, growers in Washington State are now plowing under large portions of their asparagus acreage because they can’t find enough hands to harvest the labor-intensive crop in a timely manner. The situation in Georgia is so bad that state officials have asked its prison population to pick a vast crop of onions.
The ensuing farm labor shortage begs an important question: in a nation with so many jobless claims, why are there so many unfilled jobs?
“These are jobs that frankly, Americans don’t want to do,” offered Georgia Senator Saxby Chambliss at a Senate Agriculture Committee hearing last week.
Touche.
With the flow of migrant workers from Mexico into the U.S. slowing to a trickle (if not reversing) and a seemingly self-aggrandized work force – too far removed from its agrarian roots to even notice that there is a problem afoot – 2012 might break the boom trend that the agriculture sector has been experiencing for the past few years.






Leave Your Comment →
45 Comments
maxrunner83
05.04.2012
I think that’s a great to have felons do some work and harvest the crops. You would have to pay them the going wage, then maybe they could use that money to pay for running of the prison.
Ana Zuniga-Maus
05.06.2012
We should not been having this problem, when we have laws that aloud farmers to request visas to bring a labor force the legal way, there for their cries are for illegal workers, because 1-they grow use to have illegal work force all the time with out problem. 2- They like the flexibility that illegal workers give them, because they are usually afraid to complain about abuse. In general the illegals workers are easy for them and cheaper, but the option is there to get labor for their farms the legal way.
Amelia
05.08.2012
thats because you are only allowed 19 and thats not enough
Leo Gonzalez
05.06.2012
well, because most of them receive a check while sitting at home
Daniel Smith
05.06.2012
cuz u cant live on 4$ a hour to pick tomatoes in the sun all day
Chris Hinyub
05.06.2012
@Chris_Hinyub
Daniel, there are minimum wage laws. Cutting asparagus spears in Washington State would earn you over $9/hr.
williamfraser
05.09.2012
@williamfraser
Yes, there are minimum wage laws, but agriculture has an entirely different (lower) set of them.
williamfraser
05.09.2012
@williamfraser
So, the response of farmers has been to raise wages to the point that people are willing to work, right?
Chris Hinyub
05.10.2012
@Chris_Hinyub
Farmers only circumvent the laws with illegal migrants because those migrants have no legal recourse for complaint. A legal work force, on the other hand, can demand a going wage.
Theresa Brewerton
05.06.2012
Good make them earn their keep!!!
Leo Gonzalez
05.06.2012
and the others go to school
Sie Alan Williams
05.06.2012
Good, this is a start!!! Prisoners cost an arm and leg so make them earn their keep. Now if we can make it mandatory for people on welfare do the same…
Jimmy D Lawson
05.06.2012
because slave labor was voted out back in the 1800`s?
Derek Varsalona
05.06.2012
People want work that not only pays a living wage but also has purpose and meaning in their lives. Maybe this answers your question?
Leo Gonzalez
05.06.2012
well, yall want cheap tomatoes
Jimmy D Lawson
05.06.2012
so now we have prisoners picking corporate onions
Cheryl Åsvang
05.06.2012
highly doubt people could pay their mortgage payments by picking onions :/
Justin Staller
05.06.2012
BECAUSE AMERICANS ARE LAZY AND HYPOCRITICAL.
Amelia
05.08.2012
that is the truth
Dan Zeller
05.06.2012
Sie Allan Williams, right on, welfare receipients can work for their money now, a must. Jimmy D, yeah doooood… Criminals working for criminals, well that’s not entirely fair!!!
Jeff Smith
05.06.2012
the same Ag companies that poison the land/water?
Chris Miller
05.06.2012
ALEC helps enact for profit prison legislation. ALEC helps enact stricter immigration laws. Corporate farmers lose cheap labor. Prisoners pick crops. Hmmmmm…
Christiane Stover
05.06.2012
All of the above and how is that crack down on illegal aliens working out for you all? I’ll bet those fields were also full of pesticides and herbicides. I wouldn’t want to be in those fields either. I’ll stick with my organic gardens and pick my own. I’ll even share if there is a surplus.
George Manty
05.06.2012
because the government pays more in unemployment than minimum wage, and most farmers can only afford to pay minimum wage or lower than minimum wage to illegal immigrants.
Duncan Webb
05.06.2012
Don`t ask the prisoners to pick crops – MAKE them! Convicts are a HUGE untapped source of labor, and they need to start giving back to society! Pay them a decent wage and put their asses to work, no need for illegal aliens.
hannah
05.07.2012
The only problem with that is that sometimes prison populations are padded specifically to use for free labor, and it isn’t fair when someone in jail for a petty crime or a crime they did not commit comes down with a cancer death sentence from farming pesticides or other dangerous working conditions. Many people are wrongly incarcerated due to lack of defense funds. Public defenders are rarely giving it their all.
D William Childress Jr.
05.06.2012
because American’s are so pitiful they can’t put in an honor days work for an honest days pay – they rather sit on their fat asses at home, stare at their computer phones, rip off tax-payers money from the Obamination, and let illegal aliens flood the country to fill the need. You could take care of our debt problem, unemployment problem, economic problem, and the illegal alien problem ALL by simply eliminating welfare!!!
Dan Zeller
05.06.2012
I would love to agree with you Jr. but the crime rate would skyrocket if we eliminated welfare. Most of the career welfare collectors would go nuts and more than likely commit crimes out of spite beside trying to feed their family. AMAZING!!!
Carrie LeAnne Mager
05.06.2012
Well Georgia, thats what happens when you listen to the Tea Party and don’t do any research of your own. Now you have cut off your nose to spite your face by passing draconian immigration laws (following Arizona) and there is no one to pick the farmers crops! Because ” The illegals are taking American jobs” is , and has always been a pile of B.S. Now your talking about MAKING prison inmates pick/harvest the crops…Where are all the Americans who wanted those jobs??? I predict Georgia will reverse this immigration law out of necessity.. LESSON? Dont just jump on the bandwagon.. Do your OWN research and find out what the resulting situation will be .
Carrie LeAnne Mager
05.06.2012
By the way, Americans won’t take those jobs because it is typically BELOW minimum wage with no overtime and no benefits…again, doing research not just assuming is key
Paul Freeman
05.06.2012
I remember my Grandparents picking berries rather than welfare and if I needed money during the summer thats what I had to do. unemployment offices should be the first one contacted by the farmers for the shortage of labor
Ed Griffin
05.06.2012
Offer better pay ? No . Go from slave labor to prison labor . ” What we have here is a failure to communicate “
Kevin Hannaford
05.06.2012
you can thank “Julia” for this.. it’s the entitlement mentality that’s leading people with no job at all to not take these job..
Dan Zeller
05.06.2012
Carrie… You smarty pants!!! It’s not just farm labor. I am a SoCal, now Arizona resident and Illegals like to play contractor and under-bid Licensed Contractors and then produce inferior work which leads to people getting hurt and living in unsafe conditions. You need to look at the full scope of U.S. Currency that is lost in numerous ways due to illegal immagration. IT’S IN THE HUNDREDS OF BILLIONS ANUALLY but that’s ok, the liberals need the votes!!!
Amelia
05.08.2012
what ever you racist that is not true your just being racist white people take 4 times and long and do as sucky as illegals do
Amelia
05.08.2012
please read what you type before posting because this makes you sound like an idiot!
John Tracey
05.06.2012
Dan, that’s because people like cheap stuff, even of inferior quality. Have you noticed the way Levi’s don’t last as long as they used to? That’s because the American factories are closed because Wallmart threatened to kill Levi’s as a brand if Levy’s didn’t get a cheaper, inferior product in the stores. Not only did we lose American jobs, we spend more on pants now than before, because you need to replace the old ones every year instead of every decade.
Hooray capitalism! Hooray outsourced labor!
(At least immigrant labor pays sales tax. What has Indonesia done for you lately?)
David Black
05.06.2012
Good maybe the farmers will hire the occupy crowds
Antoinette Miller
05.06.2012
I picked pears and apples in Mt. Hood, Oregon… way back. It was hard work, it was long hours and not a whole lot of money. But I didn’t have kids, a husband or even a pet to take care of. It was just me and it was enough for just me. People with a family, a mortgage and loads of bills to pay cannot make it by picking tomatoes, onions or any other crop! The Mexican workers I worked with in the orchard were migrant farm workers. Taxes were taken out of their earnings so I fail to see why so many here are bitching about them doing work most people WON’T do.
Melanie Ledgerwood
05.07.2012
I’m very thankful that you shared this. It should cause us all to be a bit more humble. There is dignity in all work.
hannah
05.07.2012
Pay a living wage and people will do the job. It’s not the job, it’s the money. No one is available to use as slave labor because of the trafficking crackdown. That’s a good thing.
Amelia
05.08.2012
hello dumb ass this will make food higher thousands of Americans are already struggling to get food on the table!!! you are a very stupid person!!!!
jacobdriessel
05.07.2012
@jacobdriessel
Why get a job that pays minimum wage which requires so much work, when you can sit at home and play Farmville while collecting unemployment?
Amelia
05.08.2012
because it is not kool that’s why. well i do because my Illegal boyfriend make $80 thousand a year so I don’t need to work. And if he gets deported we have a house and plenty of cows in his country so whatever happens we set. but hopefully before he gets deported we will be in Honduras waiting for the consulate to approve his wavier so he can come back here legally and make twice as much as he does illegally!
Agelokarla@ hotmail.com
05.14.2012
When this government stop to give money,to those People who just sit
The ass home and collect money as a free living you fellow farmers will finding workers.but as we can see past decades is over wen you have to work your ass to make a living and be successful,
From a another illigal imigrant who work every day,
If I can why you can’t .
In america Sun bright for every one,no mater your religion or color you just have to want,,,,Brazilian illigal imigrant