UPDATE: Republican Insiders Sue to Take Redistricting Back from Michigan Voters

Published: 05 Aug, 2019
3 min read

Update 8/20/19: Michigan Attorney General Dana Nesse filed a brief in federal court on Monday, August 19, asking the judge to drop a lawsuit filed by 15 Republican politicians, lobbyists, and residents over a voter-approved citizens’ redistricting commission on which they are ineligible to serve. She argued that despite plaintiffs’ claim that these restrictions on eligibility violate their First and Fourteenth Amendment rights, the rules are “no different than excluding people from jury duty who have a relationship to the parties or have a stake in the outcome of the case.”

The 2018 elections were monumental for election reform, especially independent redistricting efforts. Voters in 4 states passed amendments to end partisan gerrymandering in their state through an independent / citizens' redistricting commission.

But the fight in a couple of these states wasn't easy.

WATCH: 4 Campaigns Discuss How They Terminated Gerrymandering in 2018

In Michigan, for instance, GOP insiders and affiliated groups sued to remove the anti-gerrymandering amendment, Proposal 2, from the November ballot. Proposal 2 established a 13-member citizens’ redistricting commission to draw electoral maps. The commission will be comprised of 4 Republicans, 4 Democrats, and 5 citizens registered outside the political parties.

It was the first proposal ever to give independents more seats at the table.

The Michigan Supreme Court ruled against the lawsuit, and Proposal 2 went on to be approved by a large majority of voters. However, it looks like it will go before the courts yet again.

The Economist reports that "15 Michigan residents—shepherded by an affiliate of the National Republican Redistricting Trust, an organisation positioning the Republican Party for district-line drawing in the coming decade—are suing to stop the commission in its tracks."

The amendment created by Proposal 2 also has special rules for who can and cannot serve on this citizens' redistricting commission. It "bars anyone who has, in the last six years, sought or held elected office or served as a lobbyist or an insider for a political party. Their parents, children and spouses are barred from service," writes The Economist.

IVP Donate

Plaintiffs, all of whom are ineligible to be on the commission, say this violates the rights of free speech, association, and equal protection for many Michigan residents. Funny how equal protection in elections is only a concern when it is their members.

Plaintiffs include:

"Anthony Daunt, a Republican lobbyist who has served on the governing body of the Michigan Republican Party committee; Kathy Berden, the GOP’s national committeewoman; Patrick Meyers, a political consultant; and Mary Shinkle, once a staffer for a Republican congressman and now a county Republican Party official."

“It’s no surprise that politicians – who directly benefit from drawing their own election maps and choosing their own voters – want to undermine the voice of voters again,” said Jamie Lyons-Eddy, director of Campaigns and Programs for Voters Not Politicians, the campaign that got Proposal 2 on the 2018 ballot. “We’re confident that the proposal will survive any and all legal challenges, just as it did from many of these same politicians on the way to the ballot.”

Lyons-Eddy called the lawsuit a “last ditch” effort by politicians to hold on to power.

In this article

You Might Also Like

Woman putting ballot in ballot box.
3 Things Independent Voters Have to Be Thankful For – Reform Roundup
The number of independent voters continues to grow at a historic rate nationwide. It is becoming inc...
26 Nov, 2025
-
9 min read
Is Politico's Gerrymandering Poll and Analysis Misleading?
Is Politico's Gerrymandering Poll and Analysis Misleading?
Politico published a story last week under the headline “Poll: Americans don’t just tolerate gerrymandering — they back it.” Still, a close review of the data shows the poll does not support that conclusion. The poll shows that Americans overwhelmingly prefer either an independent redistricting process or a voter-approved process — not partisan map-drawing without voter approval. This is the exact opposite of the narrative Politico’s headline and article promoted....
25 Nov, 2025
-
5 min read
Cour blocks Texas redistricting
Did A Texas Court Just End the Gerrymandering War? (Reform Roundup)
Earlier this week, a three-judge panel blocked a mid-decade gerrymander by the Texas Legislature designed to bolster the Republican Party’s razor-thin majority in the U.S. House, setting the stage for what could become a complex legal matter....
21 Nov, 2025
-
12 min read
“Cartoon illustration of Americans facing the U.S. Capitol as light pierces through red and blue partisan cracks, representing independent voters and hope for political reform.”
New Poll: Voters Want New Leadership – and They’re Turning to Independents
A new poll from the Independent Center highlights a clear message from the public: Americans are fed up with the current political leadership, and they’re ready for change....
12 Nov, 2025
-
2 min read
Massachusetts voters.
Ranked Choice Voting Momentum Surges in Massachusetts as Cities Push for Local Control
Ranked choice voting (RCV) continues to see a surge in momentum across the U.S. However, the state that has seen the largest reform growth in the last 5 years -- Massachusetts -- has received little attention. This is because the 10 cities that have approved RCV have not been able to implement it due to state law....
14 Nov, 2025
-
5 min read
Caution tape with US Capitol building in the background.
Did the Republicans or Democrats Start the Gerrymandering Fight?
The 2026 midterm election cycle is quickly approaching. However, there is a lingering question mark over what congressional maps will look like when voters start to cast their ballots, especially as Republicans and Democrats fight to obtain any electoral advantage possible. ...
11 Nov, 2025
-
8 min read