Trump Pushes Alcatraz Revival as Calif. Audit Finds State Prisons Unprepared for Natural Disaster Evacuations

alcatraz island
Photo by Mauro Lima on Unsplash
Published: 05 May, 2025
Updated: 12 Jun, 2025
2 min read

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — As President Donald Trump calls for the reopening and expansion of Alcatraz Island to house the nation’s “most ruthless and violent offenders,” a new state audit raises alarms about California’s state prison system: most state-run facilities are not adequately prepared to evacuate during natural disasters.

The audit, released by the California Office of the Inspector General (OIG) in May 2025, found that many prisons lack clear, actionable plans for evacuating incarcerated individuals and staff beyond facility grounds, despite California’s heightened vulnerability to wildfires, floods, and earthquakes.

“Not only are some prisons overcrowded,” the report states, “but the department is unable to evacuate the incarcerated population and staff at most prisons within the first critical 72 hours of an emergency. In addition, prisons do not have specific plans to externally evacuate the incarcerated population.”

Led by Inspector General Amarik K. Singh and Chief Deputy Inspector General Shaun Spillane, the audit reviewed 2024 emergency operations plans from 30 California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) facilities. It assessed each plan for compliance with state regulations, departmental policy, and best practices.

The findings were stark: “those plans are general in nature and inadequate if large-scale external evacuations are necessary.” Although most site-specific plans included internal relocation procedures, such as moving individuals within different areas of the prison, none included detailed strategies for evacuations beyond the prison gates.

The audit also highlighted significant logistical obstacles. Site-specific audits of Valley State Prison, California Rehabilitation Center, and San Quentin Rehabilitation Center revealed concerns about the department’s aging and limited transportation fleet. One prison bus has logged nearly 533,000 miles, another over 676,000, and five buses have accumulated between 730,000 and 858,000 miles each.

“The location and high mileage of transportation buses and other fleet vehicles likely limit the department’s ability to evacuate most prisons within 72 hours,” auditors wrote. At one prison, the nearest regional hub is roughly 400 miles away.

The audit noted that if a natural disaster necessitated evacuating San Quentin Rehabilitation Center, the closest departmental fleet vehicles not permanently located at the prison or at a nearby prison would be in Galt, approximately 90 miles away. This is a striking logistical gap for a prison perched on the edge of San Francisco Bay, within view of Alcatraz Island, and vulnerable to major earthquakes.

In December 2024, a tsunami warning was issued for Northern California following a magnitude 7.0 earthquake offshore; both San Quentin and Alcatraz were located within the warning zone.

IVP Donate

Audit Report No. 24 01 is titled Audit of the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation’s Natural Disaster Emergency Preparedness and Mitigation Efforts.

Related articles

Supreme Court building.
Supreme Court Sides with Federal Corrections Officers in Lawsuit Over Prison Incident
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled June 30 that federal prison officers and officials cannot be sued by an inmate who accused them of excessive force during a 2021 incident, delivering a victory for federal corrections personnel concerned about rising legal exposure for doing their jobs....
01 Jul, 2025
-
3 min read
How It Really Works Health Care Behind Bars
Health Care Behind Bars - How It Really Works
The health care crisis behind bars affects two distinct but deeply connected groups: incarcerated individuals and correctional officers. While incarcerated people are constitutionally entitled to care, access remains inconsistent, and most enter custody with significant medical and mental health needs. They face higher rates of chronic illness, infectious disease, and psychiatric conditions than the general public....
12 Jun, 2025
-
20 min read
An angel raising a key to prison bars.
More Than a Uniform: Remembering Annie Covarrubias and the Crisis Facing Correctional Officers
Last week, California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) officials announced the sudden passing of Annie Covarrubias, a correctional officer at the Correctional Training Facility (CTF) in Soledad. She was 35 years old. In the words of her colleagues, Annie was a “dependable, professional, and kind” officer, known for her dedication to both her peers and the incarcerated individuals she worked with every day....
20 May, 2025
-
2 min read

Latest articles

Don Bacon
'Why Am I Doing This?': Don Bacon’s Retirement Reflects a Congress Driving Out Problem Solvers
U.S. Rep. Don Bacon (R-Neb.) recently announced his retirement from Congress, but the reasons he cites for his departure underscore a growing problem in Washington -- specifically, a rejection of problem solving in favor of division, partisan gamesmanship, and provocation....
09 Jul, 2025
-
4 min read
Jail cell.
Nixon Admitted Weed Wasn’t Dangerous, But Killed It to Crush Political Dissent
This seven-part series chronicles the milestones, backlash, and unintended consequences that have shaped the war on cannabis from the 1960s to the present day....
09 Jul, 2025
-
2 min read
Elon Musk in front of the US Capitol Building.
7 Things Elon Musk Needs to Do If the America Party Wants to Be More Than a Meme
The World’s Richest Man Will Have to Overcome America’s Toughest Political Obstacles — Here’s What It Will Take to Make His America Party Thrive...
08 Jul, 2025
-
4 min read