South Dakota Open Primaries Submits 47K Signatures to Get Nonpartisan Primary Reform on the Ballot

South Dakota Capitol Building
Samir Luther / Flickr
Shawn GriffithsShawn Griffiths
Published: 07 May, 2024
4 min read

Photo Credit: Samir Luther / Flickr

 

One week after the Idahoans for Open Primaries coalition submitted roughly 30,000 more signatures than they needed to get a nonpartisan top-four primary system on the ballot, South Dakota Open Primaries met the required number of signatures in their own state to put a top-two system before voters.

The campaign filed 47,000 signatures with South Dakota Secretary of State Monae Johnson Monday, nearly 12,000 more than the 35,027 signatures needed to qualify for the November ballot. Johnson's office has until August 13 to validate the amendment. 

South Dakota has a semi-closed primary system. Voters registered with a political party must vote in their respective party's primary. The parties get to decide whether or not independent voters can have an equal say in elections. 

Of the 602,000 registered voters in the state, 150,000 are registered with no party affiliation. One of the biggest changes a nonpartisan primary system would make is it would give these voters -- a quarter of the electorate -- an equal vote. 

"Our top-two primaries constitutional proposal eliminates separate ballots for each party. All registered South Dakota voters would get the same ballot," said Joe Kirby of South Dakota Open Primaries. Kirby has worked for years to reform primaries in the state.

"It would cover the three congressional offices, the governor, the legislature and county offices. It would be a South Dakota primary, not a Republican or Democrat primary."

IVP Donate

Similar primary systems are in place in California and Washington. Alaska also has a nonpartisan system, but the top-four candidates advance from the primaries instead of two.

The current system in South Dakota gives party bosses the most control over electoral outcomes. Closed primaries are designed to separate voters into two camps where those who control the parties control who advances to November and which voters matter.

And in a state like South Dakota, this gives Republican bosses -- in particular -- a lot of power. 

A state doesn't get more red than South Dakota. Only 7 seats in the state's 70-seat House of Representatives are held by Democrats -- 4 in the 35-seat Senate. Both US senators are Republican, as is its single member of the US House of Representatives.

The state is the congressional district, which has a R+16 score in the Cook Partisan Voting Index.

In most elections in South Dakota, it is not a question of will a Republican win. It is a question of which Republican will win, which turns the GOP primaries into a general election in which voters outside the party have no say.

This is why GOP leaders oppose nonpartisan primaries. South Dakota Republican Party Chair and state Sen. John Wiik was quoted by AP declaring that he sees "no good coming out of it for the Republican Party."

“I want Republicans to be able to choose the Republican candidate, and Democrats to choose the Democrat candidate,” Wiik said. “If you want to be an independent, then you’re independent of the decisions that affect your lives.”

Let Us Vote : Sign Now!

Wiik is another party leader who believes that if a voter chooses not to affiliate with the Republican or Democratic Parties then they forfeit their right to vote -- which speaks to how much control and entitlement the parties have in US elections.

It is important to note that nothing would stop the Republican Party or the Democratic Party from selecting their own nominees under a nonpartisan primary system. They can nominate candidates for the primary and endorse whoever they want.

But, the primary would not serve the private interest of selecting these nominees on the taxpayer's dime. The primary would serve the public interest of narrowing the field of candidates chosen by all voters.

Kirby has previously stated that the Republican Party has nothing to lose under nonpartisan primaries. He says a conservative party will always do well in South Dakota because it is a "conservative-thinking state."

"I just don't think we should let parties dictate how elections are run," he said, noting that these are public elections.

South Dakota Open Primaries is a group that includes many Republicans and conservative-minded independents who don't think the current primary system is fair. They are joined by Democrats and independents who think the same.

If Top Two qualifies for the ballot, it may face a tight race, especially as party leaders do everything they can to convince voters to oppose it. A January poll showed that about half of state voters support the amendment -- including 43% of Republican respondents. 

Related articles

Gerrymandering, Primaries, and Election History: How It Really Works
Gerrymandering, Primaries, and Election History: How It Really Works
The nation’s attention is currently on the ongoing redistricting fight between Republicans and Democrats. The conversation is being framed: “Donald Trump is doing this.” “Gavin Newsom is doing that.” However, what voters are missing is the context of how we got here....
08 Aug, 2025
-
1 min read
Cartoon hand placing a ballot into a box that says primary on it with a GOP elephant and Democrat donkey in the background.
Hate Gerrymandering? Let’s Start Voting in Primaries
Responding to pressure from President Trump, Texas Governor Greg Abbott and the Republican-controlled legislature are moving forward with a plan to redraw their district lines in advance of the 2026 midterms. Democrats are contemplating how to fight back and blunt any gains the GOP makes in Texas by conducting their own gerrymanders in New York, Illinois, and California.  ...
07 Aug, 2025
-
4 min read
state of Louisiana with a closed stamp over it.
Louisiana’s New Voting System: Closed, Confusing, and Costly
Louisiana is making the switch to closed partisan primaries for some elections in 2026, using a system that will no doubt confuse many of the state’s registered No Party voters, who are about to add approximately 151,000 people to their numbers. ...
30 Jul, 2025
-
6 min read

Latest articles

Person installing solar panels on roof.
How Californians Without Solar Got Stuck Paying for Those Who Do
Californians pay the ...
19 Aug, 2025
-
9 min read
Warning No Gerrymandering
CA Initiative Filed to Punish Politicians Who Undermine Redistricting Commission
State Assemblymember Carl DeMaio (R-San Diego) has added additional stakes to the redistricting drama that is unfolding in California with an initiative designed to punish any lawmaker who votes to gerrymander the state's maps....
19 Aug, 2025
-
3 min read
Redistricting fight.
The 10 Worst Gerrymandered States in the Country
Monday marked another escalation in the mid-cycle redistricting fight between Republicans in Texas and Democrats in California – with one in another special session to add 5 more GOP seats, and the other maneuvering to counter this with 5 new Democratic seats....
18 Aug, 2025
-
7 min read