Senate District 23: Can a Progressive Democrat Turn This Red Senate Seat Blue?

SD23
Created: 13 Sep, 2024
Updated: 17 Sep, 2024
4 min read

The race for California’s Senate District 23 is shaping up to be a closely watched contest. Republican Suzette Valladares is facing a strong challenge from Democrat Kip Mueller in this district that has seen significant demographic and political shifts in recent years.

The GOP is determined to hold onto this seat, currently held by incumbent Scott Wilk who is termed out. Democrats see an opportunity to flip it, capitalizing on changing voter dynamics.

Democrats outnumber Republicans in terms of voter registration, 40% to 31%. No Party Preference voters (NPPs) account for 21% of registered voters, meaning the winning candidate will likely be the one who the majority of NPPs favor.

Although Valladares finished atop the primary, she didn’t secure the majority of the vote, raising questions about her vulnerability in the general election.

Mueller, who finished second in the primary, has gained momentum, especially among younger and more diverse voters who are increasingly influential in the district.

Political analysts note that the district’s growing diversity and the rising influence of NPP voters could play a critical role in the outcome.

The race also could hinge on issues like rent control and public safety. 

While Valladares has a strong base among traditional Republicans and law enforcement, she must also appeal to moderates and independents who may be swayed by Mueller’s progressive platform.

Meanwhile, Democrats are pouring resources into the district, hoping to energize their base and flip this key seat.

More Choice for San Diego

The district includes Los Angeles and San Bernardino Counties and groups together communities with similar suburban backgrounds and commuter patterns. The region is home to clean energy and aerospace industries.

Suzette Valladares: Supported by Business and Law Enforcement

Suzette Valladares

Valladares is a non-profit executive and a well-known Republican figure in the district. She served in the California State Assembly from 2020 to 2022. 

She has built her campaign on a platform of conservative values, emphasizing public safety, economic growth, and individual freedom.

Valladares, who has deep roots in the community, has been a vocal advocate for reducing taxes and government regulation, arguing these measures are essential for economic prosperity.

Her campaign has received strong support from business groups and public safety organizations, which align with her pro-business and law-and-order stances. However, her challenge will be maintaining this support while also appealing to the district’s increasingly diverse and moderate electorate.

Public safety is a cornerstone of Valladares’ campaign. She has positioned herself as a defender of law enforcement and has received endorsements from various police associations.

She argues that a strong stance on crime is necessary to ensure the safety and well-being of all residents.

Her economic platform focuses on deregulation and tax cuts, which she believes are crucial for spurring job creation and economic growth. She has also highlighted her opposition to what she calls "heavy-handed" government interventions in the economy, arguing that such policies stifle innovation and harm small businesses.

More Choice for San Diego

Kip Mueller: Progressive, Labor, and the Democratic Party

Kipp Mueller

A former prosecutor turned workers’ rights attorney, Mueller is a first-time candidate who has gained recognition for his progressive platform focused on social justice, healthcare, and education.

With a background in education and community activism, he represents the new wave of Democratic candidates making inroads in traditionally Republican areas.

Mueller’s campaign has attracted significant support from labor unions, progressive organizations, and the California Democratic Party, which sees this race as a prime opportunity to expand their influence in the state Senate.

His platform emphasizes the need for affordable healthcare, improved public education, and addressing the housing crisis with bold, progressive policies.

Mueller has focused heavily on reaching out to underrepresented communities in the district, including younger voters, communities of color, and immigrant populations. His campaign has emphasized the importance of inclusive policies that address the needs of all residents, not just the affluent or well-connected.

On public safety, Mueller advocates for criminal justice reform, arguing that the current system disproportionately affects marginalized communities. He supports measures aimed at rehabilitation and prevention rather than punitive approaches.

Housing is a major issue in his campaign. Mueller has proposed aggressive measures to tackle the housing crisis, including rent control and increased funding for affordable housing projects. He argues that these policies are necessary to ensure that all residents have access to safe and affordable housing.

What’s at Stake?

The outcome of this race will have significant implications for both parties.

More Choice for San Diego

For Republicans, holding onto this seat is crucial for maintaining their influence in the state Senate, especially as the GOP faces increasing challenges in traditionally safe districts. For Democrats, flipping this seat would not only give them a valuable vote in the Senate, but also signal a broader shift in the political landscape of Southern California.

With the general election approaching, the race between Valladares and Mueller is expected to be fiercely contested, with both sides vying for the support of independent and swing voters who could ultimately decide the outcome.

Related articles

American flag with I Voted stickers on it.
Yes, Elections Have Consequences -- Primary Elections to Be Specific
Photo by  Can you imagine a Republican winning in an electoral district in which Democrats make up 4...
16 Nov, 2024
-
5 min read
California flag
California General Election 2024: Races Where Independent Voters Will Have Outsized Influence on Outcome
As it does each election cycle, Independent Voter News is bringing its readers extensive coverage of...
13 Sep, 2024
-
6 min read
AD36
Assembly District 36: Can a Coalition of Moderate Democrats Turn this Blue California Seat Red?
The race for California’s Assembly District 36 is shaping up to be a close contest between Republica...
13 Sep, 2024
-
3 min read

Latest articles

Man voting.
Maine Lawmakers Vote to Protect RCV Counting Process, Which Generates Results in 'One Minute'
On Monday, Maine's Veterans and Legal Affairs Committee voted 3-7 against restoring batch elimination to the ranked choice voting (RCV) system through LD 656 (HP 424), the title of which claims it will save taxpayers money, but the secretary of state says is unnecessary. ...
11 Mar, 2025
-
1 min read
Vote here signs outside a building.
To Avoid Confusion, Should RCV Just Be Called Instant Runoff Elections?
In discussions with an elderly voter in Colorado about Proposition 131, the unsuccessful 2024 ballot measure to create a nonpartisan primary with ranked choice voting (RCV), in the general election, we learned something important. This individual had voted against Proposition 131, casting his mail ballot on the day he received it. A week later, he received a campaign ad mailer that Colorado’s governor and Denver’s mayor had endorsed Proposition 131, which may have influenced his decision....
11 Mar, 2025
-
5 min read
Sky view of the US capitol building.
Democracy Expert Larry Diamond Warns of Growing Culture of SuperPAC Intimidation in Congress
In his new regular column, Diamond on Democracy, democracy scholar Larry Diamond, acknowledges that “[h]aving won the presidency fair and square, Donald Trump has earned the right to propose, and in many cases to implement, radical new policy directions.” ...
11 Mar, 2025
-
3 min read