Recess Appointments: How Do They Work and Will Trump Be Able to Make Them?

Supreme Court of the United States
Photo by Getty Images on Unsplash. Unsplash+ License obtained by author.
Published: 25 Nov, 2024
3 min read

Photo by Getty Images on Unsplash

One of the biggest legal questions going into the second term of President-Elect Donald Trump is, will he try to push through cabinet and government appointments he wants during a congressional recess? But also, can he?

The quick answer is there are constitutional provisions that say the president can (1) put Congress in recess if the House and Senate can't agree on adjournment and (2) fill vacant executive positions during a recess.

But what the president can get away with is not cut and dry, according to legal expert Sarah Isgur, who appeared on the latest episode of the Forward Podcast. Isgur served as a spokesperson for the Department of Justice during Trump's first term.

She breaks down the complexities of the legal questions at hand -- because while the constitution raises the possibility, modern attempts at recess appointments have failed in front of the Supreme Court. 

The high court, for example, unanimously struck down attempts by former President Barack Obama to fill vacant government positions during a 3-day adjournment in 2014, ruling that 3 days did not constitute an actual recess. 

Isgur explains that while the ruling was unanimous, the justices were divided on the issue of when such appointments were applicable. Some argued that if Congress was adjourned for 10 or more days, it would be different.

Notably, the conservative justices - 3 of whom are still on the bench (Thomas, Alito, Roberts) - argued that the recess power doesn't really exist. It would require a situation where Congress couldn't meet, but technology has overcome any need for recess appointments.

IVP Donate

None of the justices in the "maybe 10 days is enough" camp are on the bench going into Trump's second term. Isgur believes that because their judicial philosophy is also gone, it's more likely that the Thomas-Alito-Roberts philosophy prevails.

In other words, she believes Trump will not be allowed to get around the Senate to make appointments. "[The justices] aren't real big on presidential power right now," she says, adding that SCOTUS is tired of presidents trying to skirt Congress.

She also notes that despite fears from Democrats that SCOTUS will give Trump a free pass because it includes 3 justices he put on the bench, the high court didn't during his first term.

"Donald Trump's administration, the first time, was the least successful presidential administration at the Supreme Court in modern history," Isgur said. "Do not assume this court is all in on Donald Trump."

Whether it is Trump or Biden, SCOTUS has increasingly become the check on presidential power, especially when the president intentionally tries to get around Congress to enact policy or ignore the Senate's authority to "advise and consent."

Here is the episode's full description:

"In this episode, legal expert and political commentator Sarah Isgur dives deep into the complexities of presidential powers, the role of the Supreme Court, and the challenges of navigating a polarized Congress. From the debate over recess appointments to bold predictions about a potential shake-up in federal bureaucracy under future administrations, this conversation unpacks the legal and political dynamics shaping governance today. Discover how the Constitution, Supreme Court rulings, and populist movements influence the balance of power and what it all means for America's future."

Check out the full conversation above. 

Let Us Vote : Sign Now!

In this article

You Might Also Like

Scrabble pieces that spell out election.
After Decades of Rigged Primaries, Could 2028 Be a True Free-For-All?
Former presidential candidate and Forward Party Founder Andrew Yang published a conversation on his podcast with political commentator Ross Barkan, who along with being an author also worked with NYC mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani. In fact, Barkan literally wrote the book on one of Zohran’s opponents, Andrew Cuomo, which is slated for re-release this year....
26 May, 2025
-
3 min read
Black background with the symbols of the two major parties in the center.
Andrew Yang: Are Democrats Headed for Another Disaster in 2028?
In the latest episode of the Andrew Yang Podcast, formally known as the Forward Podcast, the former presidential candidate and co-founder of the Forward Party sits down with former ABC News White House Correspondent Tara Palmeri to talk about the Wisconsin special election, Elon Musk, and a directionless Democratic Party....
07 Apr, 2025
-
2 min read
US Capitol Building with caution tape in front.
Andrew Yang: Why Nothing Works -- And How to Fix It
In the latest episode of the Andrew Yang Podcast, Yang talks with author Marc Dunkelman about his new book, Why Nothing Works, and how distrust in government has erected barriers to get anything done....
17 Mar, 2025
-
2 min read
Ballrooms, Ballots, and a Three-Way Fight for New York
Ballrooms, Ballots, and a Three-Way Fight for New York
The latest Independent Voter Podcast episode takes listeners through the messy intersections of politics, reform, and public perception. Chad and Cara open with the irony of partisan outrage over trivial issues like a White House ballroom while overlooking the deeper dysfunctions in our democracy. From California to Maine, they unpack how the very words on a ballot can tilt entire elections and how both major parties manipulate language and process to maintain power....
30 Oct, 2025
-
1 min read
California Prop 50 gets an F
Princeton Gerrymandering Project Gives California Prop 50 an 'F'
The special election for California Prop 50 wraps up November 4 and recent polling shows the odds strongly favor its passage. The measure suspends the state’s independent congressional map for a legislative gerrymander that Princeton grades as one of the worst in the nation....
30 Oct, 2025
-
3 min read
bucking party on gerrymandering
5 Politicians Bucking Their Party on Gerrymandering
Across the country, both parties are weighing whether to redraw congressional maps ahead of the 2026 midterm elections. Texas, California, Missouri, North Carolina, Utah, Indiana, Colorado, Illinois, and Virginia are all in various stages of the action. Here are five politicians who have declined to support redistricting efforts promoted by their own parties....
31 Oct, 2025
-
4 min read