Over 23.5 Million Independent Voters Are Disenfranchised in 2024 Primaries, Study Finds

voting
Photo by Allison Saeng on Unsplash. Unsplash+ License obtained by the author.
Published: 13 Feb, 2024
2 min read

Photo Credit: Allison Saeng / Unsplash

 

As the US kicks off the 2024 presidential election cycle, more than 23.5 million registered independent voters find themselves sidelined by closed presidential primaries in 22 states, a recent report from the Unite America Institute reveals. This includes 3 million independents in Arizona, Nevada, and Pennsylvania -- crucial swing states in the race for the White House.

The report underscores a significant increase in voters who choose not to align with the Republican and Democratic Parties -- up 20% since 2010. Responding to this growing disenfranchisement, Open Primaries, in collaboration with Unite America, is launching the LetUsVote campaign. This initiative aims to mobilize independent voters in support of primary reform -- especially in states with active open or nonpartisan campaigns.

The report also highlights diversity that exists within the independent bloc. Nearly half of the "Excluded Independents" identify as "pure independents," while 27% tend to lean Democrat in elections that give them only two options and 25% lean Republican. Independent voters are disproportionately young and are more likely to be veterans.

“Both political parties are telling voters who fought for our country and voters who are the future of our country that their voices do not matter,” said Nick Troiano, Executive Director of Unite America and author of the forthcoming book The Primary Solution. “Every eligible voter should have the right to participate in every taxpayer-funded election, regardless of political affiliation.”

At the center of Unite America's report is a first-of-its-kind poll conducted by Change Research which provides insights into the diverse political perspectives and demographic composition of "Excluded Independents." It reveals that an overwhelming majority of these independents, 82%, desire a say in the 2024 presidential primary, with 74% considering their exclusion a violation of voting rights.

Despite widespread disillusionment with American politics, Excluded Independents express a desire for full participation in elections and support various election reforms. Over 80% express a desire to vote in Democratic or Republican primaries for the 2024 presidential election, while 87% support opening primaries to independent voters.

Similarly, 81% endorse nonpartisan primaries in order to facilitate a more inclusive electoral process.

IVP Donate

John Opdycke, president of Open Primaries, highlights the disparity between the numerical strength of independent voters and their limited influence in shaping the political narrative dominated by partisan politics -- and this is where initiatives like LetUsVote come into action. 

“Independent voters don’t get much respect,” said Opdycke. “We have the numbers, but not the narrative — partisan politics dominates. LetUsVote hopes to change that.”

Independent voters demand inclusion and are ready to assert their political influence in shaping the future of American democracy. By championing primary reform and advocating for a more inclusive electoral process, LetUsVote and campaigns like it aim to ensure that every eligible voter's voice is heard and valued in the democratic process.

You Might Also Like

Joe Manchin West Virginia Closed Primaries Lock Out Independent Voters
Joe Manchin is Furious as West Virginia Denies Independents a Vote — Again
The Republican Party of West Virginia has elected to keep its primary elections closed to party members only, despite these elections being paid for by taxpayers and are the most critical stage of the public elections process....
16 Jan, 2026
-
7 min read
USPS trucks parked next to each other.
2026 Will See an Increase in Rejected Mail-In Ballots -- Here's Why
While the media has kept people’s focus on the Epstein files, Venezuela, or a potential invasion of Greenland, the United States Postal Service adopted a new rule that will have a broad impact on Americans – especially in an election year in which millions of people will vote by mail....
09 Jan, 2026
-
9 min read
Missouri gerrymander
Missouri’s Gerrymander Faces a Citizen Veto, but State Officials Aren't Taking 'No' for an Answer
People Not Politicians (PNP) submitted over 305,000 signatures last week to freeze a congressional gerrymander passed by the Missouri Legislature in September. However, state officials are doing everything they can to pretend this citizen revolt isn’t happening....
19 Dec, 2025
-
12 min read
California 2026 Independent Voter Survey
NEW POLL: California Governor’s Race Sees “None of the Above” Beat the Entire Democratic Field
A new statewide poll conducted by the Independent Voter Project finds California’s independent voters overwhelmingly support the state’s nonpartisan primary system and express broad dissatisfaction with the direction of state politics....
12 Jan, 2026
-
4 min read
Disposable Vape Ban SB 762 Jacqui Irwin
This California Disposable Vape Ban Could Devastate The Legal Cannabis Industry Even Further
Good intentions often make for compelling policy. But in practice, consequences rarely fall in line as neatly as the ideas that inspired them....
12 Jan, 2026
-
6 min read
Missouri Republican Denny Hoskins Gerrymandering Manipulation
Missouri Republicans Admit They Skewed Ballot Language to Protect a Rigged Map
Missouri state officials have pulled out all the stops to prevent a veto referendum from getting on the ballot that would overturn a mid-cycle gerrymander. This includes writing a ballot summary that makes it sound like the veto referendum is trying to protect gerrymandering in the state....
13 Jan, 2026
-
4 min read