IVN Poll: Colbert, Oliver, and Ron Paul Top Choices for New Debate Moderators

Published: 17 Nov, 2015
2 min read

Ahead of last week's GOP and Democrat debates, IVN conducted an opinion poll asking readers, "If it was your choice, who would be the debate moderator?"

Respondents could choose as many news personalities they preferred as well as someone who wasn't included. This method, known as approval polling, means votes couldn't be “taken away” from any other choice because participants could select any potential moderator they preferred.

Over 400 readers responded with their top choices, a majority of whom (53 percent) wanted to see Stephen Colbert as a presidential debate moderator. John Oliver placed second with 29 percent approval and former U.S. Representative Ron Paul (R-Texas), took third with 17 percent.IVN Debate Moderator PollCreate bar charts

One of the actual moderators from last week's GOP debate, Fox News commentator Neil Cavuto, placed 7th with 8 percent. Surprisingly, although he was not named in the poll directly, Jon Stewart managed to place 10th with about 3.5 percent approval.

Perhaps the most surprising outcome was a tie for fourth between Bill O'Reilly and Cornel West - two political figures who could not be any more different. Each received about 15 percent approval among 463 respondents.

Could the Presidential Primary Debates Need More Than a New Moderator?

According to Adweek, last week's Republican and Democratic Party debates were the least successful, in terms of viewership, since the first GOP debate on August 6.

It's easy to imagine a star-studded moderator lineup would reverse the seemingly dwindling popularity of both parties' presidential debates. A Colbert-led debate moderation panel could be the cure to slumping public interest in future Democratic and Republican debates.

Similarly, one of the Republican candidates, Rand Paul (R-KY), challenged Democratic candidate Bernie Sanders (I-VT) to a one-on-one style debate just last week. Whether or not Sanders will take the challenge has yet to be seen, but a new format for the debates alongside a new moderator could be just what the doctor ordered to cure an ailing political discourse.

You Might Also Like

New IVP 2026 California Governor Poll: What the Toplines Don’t Tell You
New IVP 2026 California Governor Poll: What the Toplines Don’t Tell You
Using verified California voter file data, IVP surveyed high-propensity voters from February 13 through 20. The poll tested first-choice ballot preferences alongside issue intensity on affordability and the cost of living, immigration enforcement, more choice reform, and more....
23 Feb, 2026
-
10 min read
81% of Americans Say Money Controls Politics – Can a Constitutional Amendment Fix It?
81% of Americans Say Money Controls Politics – Can a Constitutional Amendment Fix It?
Polls consistently show that nearly all Americans across the political spectrum agree that there is too much money in politics – whether from foreign sources, corporations, or so-called “dark money” groups. ...
23 Feb, 2026
-
13 min read
10 Reasons Why the Congressional Stock Trading Ban Will Never Pass
10 Reasons Why the Congressional Stock Trading Ban Will Never Pass
The overlap between committee assignments and stock ownership is not automatically illegal. Because the current legal framework permits this proximity as long as disclosure rules are followed, lawmakers are not operating under a system that forces change....
20 Feb, 2026
-
4 min read