The Illusion of Competition in American Elections

American flag on pole.
Photo by Jonathan Simcoe on Unsplash
Created: 28 Feb, 2025
2 min read

American elections are becoming less competitive, and the consequences are eroding democracy. As The New York Times journalists Nick Corasaniti and Michael Wines report this week, most congressional and state legislative races in 2024 were effectively decided by low-turnout primaries or weren’t contested at all.

Far fewer Americans participate in primaries than in general elections. “Last year, roughly 30 million voters cast a primary ballot in a congressional election,” compared to over 156 million who voted in the general election. This means that, in most cases, the primary—not the general—determines the winner. As a result, “vanishingly few voters” actually choose the people who go on to represent them.

This dynamic is especially stark in state legislatures, where “more than three-quarters of those primary races in 2024 were uncontested,” allowing many politicians to win office without any real opposition. “Most members of both parties, liberal and conservative, they’re more worried about losing their primary than losing the general election,” former RNC chair Haley Barbour told the New York Times. That fear pushes politicians further to the extremes as they cater to the most ideologically rigid voters in their party.

Even in states with high-profile elections, competition is often an illusion. In Georgia, “10 of the state’s 14 members of the U.S. House did not face a primary challenge,” while in deep-blue New York, “21 of the state’s 26 House members ran unopposed.” And even when primaries occur, they often don’t offer a real choice—only 287 out of 4,600 state legislative primaries in 2024 were “meaningful,” according to election strategist Michael Podhorzer.

This lack of competition isn’t accidental—it’s the result of a political system designed to serve the two major parties rather than the voters. As Katherine Gehl and Michael Porter explain in their brilliant book, The Politics Industry, “The parties have become a duopoly that controls the rules of the game, suppressing competition and prioritizing self-preservation over serving the public interest.” Gerrymandering, closed primaries, and first-past-the-post voting all reinforce this system, ensuring that most elections are settled long before the general vote is cast.

For voters, this reality leads to frustration and disillusionment. “They’ve gerrymandered everything,” said Rory Duncan, a Republican voter in Maryland. “We used to have a Republican, but they’ve gerrymandered it so much that there’s no way a Republican can get elected.”

Experts warn that elections will continue to favor more extreme candidates without real competition. “It’s becoming increasingly clear that over time, more extreme candidates are winning at both state legislative and congressional levels,” said political scientist Steven Rogers.

As Corasaniti and Wines point out, American elections are increasingly a “mirage of meaningfulness.” Unless major structural reforms occur—such as ranked-choice voting, open primaries, or independent redistricting commissions—polarization will deepen, and public trust in democracy will continue to crumble.

(Based on reporting by Nick Corasaniti and Michael Wines, The New York Times, Feb. 25, 2025, and The Politics Industry by Katherine Gehl and Michael Porter.

IVP Donate

In this article

Related articles

American institutions.
Chuck Todd: When It Comes to Public Mistrust in Institutions, The Parties Just Don't Get It
Last week, the national election reform group Open Primaries held a Zoom conversation with former Me...
26 Mar, 2025
-
3 min read
New Mexico State Capitol Building
A Bill to Open Taxpayer-Funded Primaries to Over 330,000 Independents Sent to New Mexico Governor's Desk
SANTA FE, N.M. - It has been a long road for reformers in New Mexico, but the legislature has passed...
23 Mar, 2025
-
3 min read
an i voted sticker peeled up.
Louisiana Voters Are Not Happy About the State's Move to Closed Primaries
Closed primaries are coming to Louisiana in 2026, but a new poll shows that state voters across the ...
19 Mar, 2025
-
3 min read

Latest articles

Stack of mail ballots.
New Report Finds Universal Vote at Home States Nearly Doubled Turnout in 2024 Primaries
The National Vote at Home Institute (NVAHI) released a new report Monday that states with Universal Vote at Home (VAH) saw nearly double the voter turnout in the 2024 primary elections compared to states that didn't offer it....
31 Mar, 2025
-
2 min read
Chicago skyline
Mayors of America's Largest Cities Embrace Ranked Choice Voting
Mayors of big cities across the country are coming out in support of ranked choice voting (RCV). RCV is currently used in 46 U.S. cities, including the most populous cities in seven states....
31 Mar, 2025
-
3 min read
Image of Washington DC with the US Capitol in the background.
This Isn't the Political Makeover Independent Voters Hoped to Get
Both parties have undergone radical transformations, leaving many Americans feeling politically homeless and eager for a new alternative....
31 Mar, 2025
-
2 min read