'Final Four' Primary Initiative in Idaho Set for Ballot Approval

'Final Four' Primary Initiative in Idaho Set for Ballot Approval
Photo by Element5 Digital on Unsplash.
Published: 30 Apr, 2024
3 min read

Photo Credit: Element5 Digital on Unsplash

An initiative that would ensure equal voting rights for 270,000 independent voters in Idaho is all but certain to qualify for the November ballot. The Idahoans for Open Primaries coalition exceeded 90,000 signatures for its "Final Four" elections initiative days before the May 1 deadline.

The Final Four reform would transform state elections in two major ways. It would replace its closed partisan primary system that has been in place since 2011 with a nonpartisan primary in which all voters and candidates, regardless of party, participate on a single ballot. The top four vote-getters would then move on to the general election.

Then, voters would have the option to rank the top four candidates in order of preference using ranked choice voting. This would ensure that a candidate does not win an elected position with a simple plurality (less than 50% of the vote).

The initiative needs approximately 63,000 valid signatures, including 6% of registered voters from 18 of Idaho's 35 legislative districts. Supporters will end up submitting around 30,000 more than they need -- which is ample buffer in the event some signatures are determined to be invalid.

“It feels like we have built an incredible amount of momentum, and based on the conversations we have had with voters across the state it’s clear that we have a path to victory in November,” said Reclaim Idaho co-founder Luke Mayville. Reclaim Idaho is part of the Idahoans for Open Primaries coalition.

For many supporters, the most important thing the Final Four initiative would accomplish is equal voting rights for registered independent voters in the state. These voters make up nearly 30% of the voting population, and yet they are denied access to the most critical stage of the elections process.

Idaho is dominated by a single party. Both of its congressional seats are held by Republicans -- as are its US Senate seats. Republicans also hold 80% of the state's legislative seats. Thus, in most instances, the GOP primary acts as a general election.

And yet, the Republican Party of Idaho has restricted access to its primaries to party members only. This has left independent voters with no say in who represents them at the state and federal levels.

IVP Donate

“Far too many independent voters are being excluded from voting in the most…competitive primary elections and then a whole lot of voters feel like when they show up to vote they just don’t like the quality of the choices that are on their ballot,” said Mayville.

Even Republican leaders know how unfair the current system is to voters. More than 120 prominent Republicans have joined the coalition to pass Final Four, including former Gov. Butch Otter, who said every voter "should have the right to weigh in on choosing our leaders."

If the initiative is approved by voters, Idaho would join a voter revolution that includes states like Alaska, which has already adopted a Final Four system, and Nevada, where a Final Five system could be approved by voters in November. A majority of Nevada voters already voted in favor of the proposal in 2022.

The number of campaigns and groups popping up across the country to support similar reform continues to grow, from California to Arizona to Wisconsin to Florida.

You Might Also Like

How James Talarico Won Over Independents Amid Texas Primary Chaos
How James Talarico Won Over Independents Amid Texas Primary Chaos
James Talarico wins Texas’ Democratic Senate primary as campaigns point to unusually high independent participation in the state’s open primary system. Then Dallas County’s last-minute switch back to precinct-only voting sparks confusion, long lines, and a legal fight over ballots cast after 7 p.m....
05 Mar, 2026
-
3 min read
Don’t Kill Top Two. Upgrade It: A Smarter Way to Elect California’s Governor
Don’t Kill Top Two. Upgrade It: A Smarter Way to Elect California’s Governor
The answer to today’s crowded field is not retreat. It is modernization. Instead of empowering party gatekeepers, we can empower voters with more choice, less vote splitting, and majority-supported outcomes....
03 Mar, 2026
-
4 min read
No Referee in the Midterms? Trump’s FEC Nominations Come After 10 Months of Zero Federal Oversight
No Referee in the Midterms? Trump’s FEC Nominations Come After 10 Months of Zero Federal Oversight
As February wrapped up, it was reported that President Donald Trump had nominated two Republicans for the Federal Elections Commission after 10 months of the agency being unable to perform its basic functions....
02 Mar, 2026
-
9 min read
America at 250: Independent Voters Declare Independence from the Two-Party System
America at 250: Independent Voters Declare Independence from the Two-Party System
On February 27, 2026, the better elections group Open Primaries released a sweeping public statement titled Declaration of Independents, framing the exclusion of independent voters from critical taxpayer-funded elections as the unfinished business of 1776....
27 Feb, 2026
-
3 min read
ABC, State of Gold, and New York Times Turn to Independent Voter Project for Expertise
ABC, State of Gold, and New York Times Turn to Independent Voter Project for Expertise
It didn’t take long for our poll to get noticed not only in Sacramento, but all the way over on the East Coast where the New York Times featured it alongside other reputable pollsters like Emerson College and the Public Policy Institute of California. ...
26 Feb, 2026
-
4 min read
Voter ID + Proof of Citizenship: Trump Goes All-In in the SOTU - What Happens Next?
Voter ID + Proof of Citizenship: Trump Goes All-In in the SOTU - What Happens Next?
Tune in for our independent breakdown of Trump’s record-length 2026 State of the Union: voter ID + proof of citizenship, immigration rhetoric, affordability vs “winning” messaging, a rare bipartisan beat on banning stock trading, and the moment the chamber unified around a Coast Guard rescue....
26 Feb, 2026
-
2 min read