The Electoral Count Reform Act: Everything You Need to Know

DC
Photo by Andy Feliciotti on Unsplash
Published: 08 Oct, 2024
Updated: 18 Jun, 2025
4 min read

Editor's Note: The following article originally published on The Fulcrum and has been republished on IVN with permission from the publisher. Photo by Andy Feliciotti on Unsplash.

 

All of us remember when Vice President Mike Pence declared Joe Biden the winner of the presidential election at the end of a violent day at the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021. Those were trying times for our country as MAGA loyalists circulated baseless claims of fraud and Donald Trump pressured his vice president to prevent Biden’s win by not counting electoral votes from some states.

In response to these unprecedented threats, and in a rare act of bipartisanship, Congress passed the Electoral Count Reform Act in 2022, updating the Electoral Count Act of 1887. ECRA provides critical amendments to the existing law that eliminate much of the ambiguity that created the pretext for Trump’s attempted sabotage in 2020.

ECRA amended the powers of the key actors in the presidential election process.

State legislatures and slates of electors

1. ECRA prohibits legislatures from changing laws governing the selection of presidential electors after Election Day.

2. ECRA also repeals the “failed election” provision of the prior law, which could have allowed legislatures to reject the popular vote and appoint a slate of electors themselves if they thought the election was flawed.

Taken together these provisions make clear legislatures have no role in presidential elections once Election Day has come. This is important because legislatures reflect the interest of the majority party in that state, making them unlikely to be honest brokers in a disputed election. Before Election Day, legislatures decide how the state will select its electors (whether “winner take all” state-wide or by congressional district, for example), but they cannot intervene in any way after Election Day.

The vice president and the counting of the electoral votes

3. ECRA clarifies that the vice president may only hold “ministerial duties” in the electoral vote-counting process. The VP has “no power to solely determine, accept, or otherwise adjudicate or resolve disputes over the proper list of electors, the validity of electors, or the votes of electors.”

IVP Donate

Most scholars argue that even under the prior law the vice president’s role was only ministerial and non-discretionary, but Trump and his lawyers found enough ambiguity to demand that Pence reject electoral votes and unilaterally change the outcome. That dangerous idea is now unambiguously off the table.

Congress and congressional objections to electoral votes

4. ECRA strictly limits the grounds on which members of Congress can object to electoral votes to narrow procedural problems that are very unlikely to occur, such as an electoral vote for a president who is under 35 (which is prohibited by the Constitution).

5. This means Congress cannot object to a state’s certified electoral votes because of how the presidential election was conducted in the state.

6. The law requires one-fifth of each chamber of Congress to support a valid objection to electoral votes in order for a vote to be held on that objection and requires a majority vote in both chambers to sustain such an objection.

Taking these provisions together provides for only a very narrow role for Congress, so narrow that Congress should not be said to “certify” the presidential election. They observe the count, and that’s all, except for the very unlikely case of electoral votes that are flawed on narrow technical grounds.

Courts and disputed elections

7. ECRA provides for a district court of three judges to hear cases brought by a candidate regarding the issuance of the certification of results in any state.

8. ECRA states that if there is a final decision by a state or federal court that changes the election outcome in a state after that state has certified its results but before the meeting of the electors, then that result “supersedes” the previously certified results.

These elements of the law make clear that courts of law have the primary role in resolving a disputed presidential election. This is entirely appropriate, and consistent with international democratic norms. Courts are the institution best equipped to hear evidence and render judgment and are therefore most likely to resolve a disputed election fairly.

Let Us Vote : Sign Now!

Taken together, all of these changes make major improvements to shore up the presidential election process against any further rogue challenges. The Electoral College structure and voting process did hold up in 2020 — with ECRA it has been significantly reinforced.

In this article

Related articles

US map divided in blue and red with a white ballot box on top.
Could Maine Be the First State to Exit the National Popular Vote Compact?
On May 20, the Maine House of Representatives voted 76–71 to withdraw the state from the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC), reversing course just over a year after Maine became the 17th jurisdiction to join the agreement....
04 Jun, 2025
-
3 min read
An electoral map.
After 2024, Republicans Should Also Want to End the Current Electoral College System
It’s time to make nationwide popular vote an issue about not partisan advantage, but civic virtue and democratic legitimacy....
07 Jan, 2025
-
4 min read
Electoral College
An Electoral Tie: It Could Happen, But What Happens If It Does?
The 2024 presidential election is considered extremely tight and much like the 2020 election will be decided by less than 100,000 votes in a small handful of states – if polling is any indication of the state of the election....
24 Sep, 2024
-
5 min read

Latest articles

Tulsi Gabbard
Is Tulsi Gabbard Being Sidelined by Another Party?
Tulsi Gabbard can’t seem to catch a break, no matter which party or administration she joins. First, she was ostracized by the Democratic Party in 2016 when she spoke out against the party’s unfair treatment against Bernie Sanders. At the time, she was a sitting Democratic congresswoman and DNC vice chair....
26 Jun, 2025
-
4 min read
A gas station with cannabis products on the pump with the US Capitol building in the background.
Congress Moves to Ban Unregulated, Intoxicating Hemp Being Sold at Gas Stations Nationwide
In a late-session vote last week, House Republicans advanced a sweeping change to federal hemp policy that could outlaw a wide range of intoxicating hemp products, sometimes referred to as “gas station weed,” as the hemp Farm Bill loopholes become a major policy issue in many states, including California, Tennessee and Texas....
26 Jun, 2025
-
3 min read
NYC open primaries picket.
On Primary Day, NY Orgs Picket on Behalf of 3.5 Million Disenfranchised Voters
Much of the election coverage on Tuesday focused on the New York primaries, especially in NYC and the hotly contested ranked choice election for mayor. What got less attention, however, were the 3.5 million independent voters in the state locked out of elections they paid for....
25 Jun, 2025
-
4 min read