Democrat-Led Lawsuit Kills Independent Redistricting Initiatives in Nevada

two parties
Photo by Eren Yildiz on Unsplash. Unsplash+ license obtained by author.
Published: 11 May, 2024
Updated: 18 Jun, 2025
2 min read

Photo Credit: Eren Yildiz / Unsplash+

 

The Nevada Supreme Court on Friday upheld the ruling of a lower district court that two identical ballot questions that would create an independent redistricting commission were invalid because sponsors did not add a revenue source to either initiative.

Fair Maps Nevada, which spearheaded both initiatives, asserted that commissioners could act in a volunteer capacity, and that any funds needed could be taken from public funds that no longer were going toward legislative redistricting.

The court, however, said this was not enough. 

“By its terms [the Constitution] requires Fair Maps' initiatives to themselves raise the necessary revenue to create and maintain the Redistricting Commission; it is not enough to simply hope that savings elsewhere will offset the Redistricting Commission's costs,” the court's order states

The lawsuit was filed by Democratic voter Eric Jeng and supported by the Democratic majority in the legislature. The legislature drew electoral districts in 2021 to maximize the Democratic Party's advantage in the state.

Fair Maps Nevada President Sondra Cosgrove believes that anyone who seeks to challenge the legislature's redistricting power could find themselves in a no-win situation, because there are other legal roadblocks establishment forces can erect.

For example, she says that even if Fair Maps re-submitted the initiative with a funding source, like raising marijuana taxes, it could be challenged on Nevada's single-subject rule.

IVP Donate

She wrote about this legal strategy in an op-ed piece published in the Nevada Independent in March.

"Establishment forces particularly like to weaponize this legal strategy to stop ballot questions that threaten their power, using the courts to strip Nevadans of the right to even gather signatures," she wrote.

"These special interests have deep-pockets, such as the Elias Law Firm out of Washington, D.C., which often sues to stop ballot questions in Nevada."

These challenges don't stop all reform efforts. Question 3, which would implement a Final Five voting system with nonpartisan primaries and ranked ballots, was challenged on the single-subject rule.

The single-subject rule requires all aspects of a proposed ballot initiative to share a functional connection -- essentially meaning that ultimately only one question is being put before voters. The effort against Question 3 failed because the courts ruled that the single subject was election reform. 

Cosgrove asserts that it is easier to challenge independent redistricting or any effort that would require the creation of a state entity because adding a revenue source from existing taxes would create two questions:

One on the subject of the initiative and one on the appropriateness of the funding source. "This is one reason why constitutional ballot questions have not included a method of taxation up to now," Cosgrove writes. 

It is unlikely that an independent redistricting initiative will be refiled in the current election cycle. However, in an interview with the Nevada Independent, Cosgrove said she is going to focus her support on Question 3 for nonpartisan primaries and ranked choice voting.

Let Us Vote : Sign Now!

“I'm going to double down on [Question 3],” she said. “Because we need to have other mechanisms to get around gerrymandered maps.”

Related articles

Judge about to slower gavel.
Believe It or Not, There Is Still a 2024 Election That Hasn't Been Called
It may be hard to believe, but as of April 2025, there is still one election in the US from the last election cycle that has not been called: the 2024 North Carolina Supreme Court election between incumbent Democrat Justice Allison Riggs and Republican challenger Jefferson Griffin....
09 Apr, 2025
-
3 min read
businessman holding his hands to his face.
New Poll: Half of US Voters Say They Voted For 'Lesser of Two Evils' in 2024
Citizen Data polled US voters following the 2024 elections and found that nearly half (47%) said they cast their ballot, not for the candidate they supported the most, but for the candidate they determined was the 'lesser of two evils.'...
09 Dec, 2024
-
2 min read
Andrew Yang
Andrew Yang: Democrats Have Only Themselves to Blame
Former presidential candidate and Forward Party Founder Andrew Yang says that if Democratic leaders are looking for someone to blame for their 2024 loss, they need to take a hard look in the mirror....
11 Nov, 2024
-
2 min read

Latest articles

Tyson points at Trump with a marijuana leaf behind him.
Mike Tyson Calls Out Donald Trump to Make Good on Cannabis Rescheduling Promise
Mike Tyson, the former heavyweight boxing champion known as “Iron Mike,” is calling on President Donald Trump to make good on a campaign promise to reclassify cannabis under federal law....
11 Jul, 2025
-
2 min read
Football in grass.
Texas, Football, Bobcats, Pac-12, and a Corrections Officer Who Performed a Miracle
Houston Chronicle and Hearst Newspapers Spotlight Kelly Damphousse, a Former Correctional Officer Who Transformed a University....
10 Jul, 2025
-
4 min read
Lorena Gonzalez with teamsters
Lorena Gonzalez, California’s Top Labor Leader, Blasts ‘Anti-Labor Left’ Over Abundance Movement
Lorena Gonzalez, one of California’s most influential labor leaders, entered the fray this week in a growing Democratic debate over the so-called “abundance” movement. ...
09 Jul, 2025
-
2 min read