logo

Fair Elections, Better Representation: The US Can Learn a Lot from Scottish Elections

image
Author: Fair Vote
Created: 22 June, 2017
Updated: 17 October, 2022
2 min read

On May 4, Scotland held its elections for local councils using a Multi-Winner Ranked Choice Voting System (RVC). Once again, Scottish election results have demonstrated how their system gives voters fair elections, greater choice, and a stronger voice. Local councils are the form of municipal government used in the region.

The distribution of votes between parties was relatively even, with the three largest parties winning just 79% of council seats.

The Scottish National Party remained the most popular party for local governance, receiving the most votes and the most council seats in Scotland.

The Conservative Party made massive gains, pulling ahead of Labour for the first time in recent history.

Labour suffered heavy losses in terms of seats, and no longer controls any councils by a majority. The Liberal Democrats, Scottish Greens, and Independents split the remaining 21% of the seats.

Since 2007, Scotland has used multi-winner districts and ranked choice voting to elect local councilors. This model is the same one proposed by FairVote for US congressional districts in The Fair Representation Act.

One impact of RCV in Scotland is that a range of political parties and perspectives are consistently elected to office. The Scotland election was primarily a contest between the three major parties but Independents, Liberal Democrats, and Scottish Greens all received influential quantities of council seats.

RCV makes third party candidacies viable by eliminating the potential for a spoiler effect. As a result of third party and independent success, no party in Scotland has more than a plurality in any of the regions 32 councils. This is a victory against polarization. By forcing the larger parties to build coalitions to achieve their agendas, independent parties have guaranteed that moderation and compromise will define council governance in Scotland.

The Scottish election was a victory for Fair Representation Voting. Fair Representation requires that a legislature should reflect all of the voters who elect them.

IVP Existence Banner

In Scotland, this was demonstrated by the proximity of the percentage of votes acquired by each party to the percentage of seats obtained. In the table below, you can see that the difference between votes and seats in the 2017 election is less than 3% for every party.

For a race with five parties, this is considered a fair and relatively proportional result.

The successes of Scotland’s electoral system is strengthening a range of diverse political voices, mitigating polarization and guaranteeing fair representation. All of which, provides a strong model for the United States to look towards.

In this country, our broken electoral system results in extreme political polarization, and produces unfair unrepresentative results. By implementing RCV, the United States could combat polarization by allowing a range of political voices to be heard, and guarantee fair and proportional results.

Editor's note: This article, written by Jesse Doctor, originally published on FairVote's blog on June 21, 2017, and has been modified slightly for publication on IVN.

Photo Credit: andriano.cz / shutterstock.com

Latest articles

Glenn Youngkin
The Irony of Gov. Glenn Youngkin Vetoing a Ranked Choice Voting Bill
Virginia Governor Glenn Youngkin has said no to a bill that would clarify how ranked choice voting (RCV) is supposed to work in local elections -- which is odd considering the only reason Youngkin is governor is because of a RCV nomination process at the 2021 Virginia GOP convention. ...
12 April, 2024
-
3 min read
Trump and Biden Debate
If Trump or Biden Don't Want to Debate, Give The Stage to Someone Else
Major national news outlets reportedly are drafting an open letter to President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump's campaigns urging them to debate this fall. Biden has threatened not to debate at all, and Trump doesn't have a solid track record committing to debates....
10 April, 2024
-
3 min read
Electoral College
The Electoral College Reform the Nation Needs is Not What Either Party Wants
Nebraska is one of only two states that has a system that awards its Electoral College votes based on the popular vote in each of its congressional districts. However, there is a contingent of state lawmakers who want to change this with the support of former President Donald Trump....
08 April, 2024
-
11 min read