Supreme Court To Consider Hearing Bipartisan Lawsuits Challenging Open Primaries

Published: 07 Feb, 2017
3 min read

Legal efforts to shut out voters from publicly-funded primary elections in Hawaii and Montana may be heard by the Supreme Court next week.

The lawsuits challenging open primaries were brought by Republicans and Democrats alike. On February 17, the court will decide whether to reconsider the findings of lower courts in the cases of Ravalli County Republican Party v McCulloch and Democratic Party of Hawaii v Nago.

Previous decisions have upheld Montana and Hawaii’s open primaries as constitutional. However, the major parties remain undeterred and aim to take their case to the nation's highest court.

What's at stake?

In both suits, the plaintiffs' arguments relied on precedent that recognized the political parties' First Amendment right to not associate with voters who are not members of their party. This precedent was established in 2000 in the case of Democratic Party v Jones, which concerned California's old blanket primary system where all party primaries were listed on the same ballot and voters could choose to participate in different party primaries for each office on the ballot. Now, the political parties are trying to extend that holding to all open primaries.

Advocates of inclusive primaries argue that the primary election is an integral part of the publicly-funded election process, and as such, no part of that public process should exclude any voters. Another argument can be made that forcing any voter to join a political party as a condition of participating at any stage of the public election process is also unconstitutional.

Several organizations -- including the Independent Voter Project, FairVote, Open Primaries, and the Center for Election Science -- have proposed alternate systems that respect the parties' rights as well as the rights of individual voters.

Chad Peace, attorney for the Independent Voter Project, explains what's at stake:

To date, our court system has recognized the right of association as it applies to private political parties. Hopefully, in the near future the court will recognize the suffocating effect of closed primaries on the fundamental right to vote and recognize that every person has that same fundamental right to not associate.”

Montana

In the case of Republican Party v McCulloch, the Republican Party of Montana and local Republican committees attempted to close the state’s primary elections ahead of the 2016 Republican Presidential Primary. Despite emergency appeals, a federal court upheld an earlier decision and Montana’s 2016 primary continued as it had since 1912 - open to all voters.

IVP Donate

The court declined to hear the case in March 2016. Now, the Supreme Court will consider whether or not to take up the case once again. After plaintiffs request was denied last year, the Montana Republican Party left the suit, but local county central committees remained.

Hawaii

Democratic Party of Hawaii v Nago originated in 2013 when the Democratic Party sued the state’s chief election officer, Scott Nago. The suit attempted to invalidate Hawaii’s open primary system, which was adopted in 1978.

In 2016, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld Hawaii’s open primary as constitutional, following an appeal from a lower court. The Ninth Circuit held that the Democratic Party of Hawaii did not produce enough evidence to show that the state’s open primary system violates the party’s First Amendment right to association.

Related: Lawsuit Challenges Constitutionality of New Jersey Primary

Related: How Primary Elections Work: An Overview and Legal Analysis

WATCH: How Political Parties Rig Elections

In this article

You Might Also Like

Isn't It Weird That Congress Feels No Urgency to Re-Open the Government?
Isn't It Weird That Congress Feels No Urgency to Re-Open the Government?
The U.S. has entered Day 22 of the latest government shutdown with no end in sight. As pundits expect it to surpass the 35-day record set during Trump’s first term, a new Gallup poll shows voters’ approval of Congress has plummeted in the last month. Yet, for congressional leaders, there isn’t any urgency to re-open the government. House Speaker Mike Johnson and Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries trade jabs back and forth in the media, but the blame game continues to be prioritized over solutions....
22 Oct, 2025
-
5 min read
Partisan chess game.
The Gerrymandering Fight is About Democracy -- But Not for the Reasons You Think
The Texas GOP made two significant moves in the last few months to enhance their chances in the 2026 midterms. The first made national headlines and provoked a Democratic Party response. The second has flown under the radar....
20 Oct, 2025
-
4 min read
Joe Manchin
Joe Manchin on Taxpayer-Funded Primaries: 'They're Locking Us Out!'
While appearing on CNN host Michael Smerconish’s show, former Democratic U.S. Senator Joe Manchin, now a registered independent, told Smerconish that “we have to have open primaries” in order to get candidates who prioritize representation to run and have a chance to win....
17 Oct, 2025
-
2 min read
Partisan chess game.
The Gerrymandering Fight is About Democracy -- But Not for the Reasons You Think
The Texas GOP made two significant moves in the last few months to enhance their chances in the 2026 midterms. The first made national headlines and provoked a Democratic Party response. The second has flown under the radar....
20 Oct, 2025
-
4 min read
Isn't It Weird That Congress Feels No Urgency to Re-Open the Government?
Isn't It Weird That Congress Feels No Urgency to Re-Open the Government?
The U.S. has entered Day 22 of the latest government shutdown with no end in sight. As pundits expect it to surpass the 35-day record set during Trump’s first term, a new Gallup poll shows voters’ approval of Congress has plummeted in the last month. Yet, for congressional leaders, there isn’t any urgency to re-open the government. House Speaker Mike Johnson and Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries trade jabs back and forth in the media, but the blame game continues to be prioritized over solutions....
22 Oct, 2025
-
5 min read
Proposition 50 voter guide
California Prop 50: Partisan Power Play or Necessary Counterpunch?
November 4 marks a special election for what has become the most controversial ballot measure in California in recent memory: Proposition 50, which would circumvent congressional districts drawn by the state’s independent redistricting commission for a legislative-drawn map....
01 Oct, 2025
-
9 min read