Why You Really Don't Want A Political Outsider as President -- Even If You Think You Do

image
Author: Jack Scherer
Published: 15 Jul, 2015
Updated: 16 Oct, 2022
3 min read

For those of you who have been under a rock for the last week or two, Donald Trump has set the 2016 presidential field on fire. In his very first speech announcing his candidacy, Trump managed to stir up a wave of controversy that has only propelled him to the top of the Republican field.

But while Democrats quickly denounced his statements and many Republicans sought to distance themselves, Trump continues to poll well. It is doubtful Trump will be able to sustain this early lead and even more unlikely that he will win the nomination, but there is an appeal to his type.

Americans love to flirt with the idea of a nonpartisan candidate, a political outsider with a proven career outside of government who will miraculously come to power and “clean up” Washington. Political experience is seen as a problem rather than an asset. They say what they mean, not what their party dictates, no matter how seemingly crazy or unpopular it is.

A business man, independently wealthy with seemingly nothing to gain is often seen as that savior. Trump is the latest incarnation of this common theme, just as Michael Bloomberg was courted in the last election, and Ross Perot was in the 1990s.

Although America has flirted with the idea, they have never taken the relationship to the next level, nor should they.

While the idea of a political novice at first blush seems appealing, Americans need to remember that the modern presidency is the most political office in the world that does not lend itself to on-the-job experience. Presidents need to know how the current system works even if they want to change it. Our government requires coalition building and working relationships to move forward both within our government and with leaders around the world.

All of the presidents who changed the system were political insiders. Whether it was the Founding Fathers, Abraham Lincoln, Theodore Roosevelt, Franklin Roosevelt, Lyndon Johnson, or even Ronald Reagan, all of them had years of political experience under their belts and knew what was needed to move the levers of power. They knew the relationships and how to do battle politically when needed.

A candidate lacking such relationships and such political skills will likely struggle to gain support for any major initiative. Furthermore, such candidate will likely alienate both sides, making governing even more difficult. We have already seen this on Trump’s campaign as the left denounces his racially-charged comments, and many on the right distance themselves from him.

It is easy to see that Trump has few friends, other than the public, when it comes to the campaign trail. Imagine how those differences would intensify with him in office.

So there are two scenarios that could occur if such a candidate won. Either they would develop the political skills necessary for the most political job in the world and thereby become the very thing so hated by the public, a politician. Or, lacking the skills, or refusing to develop them, they will have few friends in politics, will not move any major legislation, and will be viewed as incompetent political hacks.

IVP Donate

Latest articles

Marijuana plant.
Why the War on Cannabis Refuses to Die: How Boomers and the Yippies Made Weed Political
For much of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, American physicians freely prescribed cannabis to treat a wide range of ailments. But by the mid-twentieth century, federal officials were laying the groundwork for a sweeping criminal crackdown. Cannabis would ultimately be classified as a Schedule I substance, placed alongside heroin and LSD, and transformed into a political weapon that shaped American policy for the next six decades....
30 Jun, 2025
-
2 min read
Donald Trump standing behind presidential podium and in front of two American flags.
Has Trump Made His Case for the Nobel Peace Prize?
A news item in recent days that was overshadowed in the media by SCOTUS and the One Big Beautiful Budget Bill was a US-brokered peace agreement that was signed between Rwanda and the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) – which if it holds will end a conflict between the two countries that has killed thousands and displaced hundreds of thousands of people....
30 Jun, 2025
-
7 min read
Picture of skyscraper in New York behind a bridge.
Knives Come Out Against Reform at NYC CRC Hearing as Independents Rise
Last week in Staten Island, the NYC Charter Revision Commission held its next-to-last public hearing. As Commissioner Diane Savino commented, addressing NYC's closed primary system “is the single biggest issue we’ve heard this year.”...
30 Jun, 2025
-
3 min read