Political Ideology A Polarizing Factor in Media Trust, Social Interaction

image
Author: Steve Baker
Created: 27 Oct, 2014
Updated: 15 Oct, 2022
3 min read

"Political Polarization & Media Habits" is the the latest report in an ongoing Pew Research project tracking partisan trends among Americans. The report found:

"When it comes to getting news about politics and government, liberals and conservatives inhabit different worlds. There is little overlap in the news sources they turn to and trust."

The project, funded by the Hewlett Foundation and MacArthur Foundation, consisted of responses from 10,013 adults divided into 5 categories -- consistently liberal or conservative, mostly liberal or conservative, and mixed (acting as the middle ground) -- in order to understand how political ideology influences the medium an individual chooses when getting their news and how they interact on social media sites.

Political Affiliation A Factor in Media Trust

Trust in media sources by those surveyed, called panelists, indicates that the largest schism is fueled by ideological differences. Fox News and NPR were the most polarized sources in terms of trust between consistent conservatives and liberals.

Consistent conservatives overwhelmingly trust Fox News (88%) while only 6 percent of consistent liberals reported trusting the network. NPR is the most trusted news source for consistent liberals, according to the survey, at 72 percent. About 3 percent of consistent conservatives said they trust NPR.

Panelists with 'mixed' political views are broadly skeptical of both news sources and reported trusting CNN the most (61%). While conservatives are more likely to agree on a main source for news, respondents with mixed political views and liberal views are more divided on what sources they prefer.

main source of government and political news

Partisanship on Social Media

Facebook and other social media sites were not only identified as sources of political news but information provided by panelists gave additional insight as to how and with whom they share political ideas. Partisan groupthink -- a psychological phenomenon associated with insulated cohesive group decisions -- carries over in terms of whom panelists associate with on social media.

Of those surveyed, 48 percent treat Facebook as a source of political news compared to other social media sites like Twitter, YouTube, Google+, and LinkedIn.

According to Pew, conservatives are more likely to follow posts on political parties, candidates, and officials than liberals who focus more on issue-based groups. On average, more than 32 percent of consistent conservatives and liberals view posts consistent with their political outlook and pay more attention to political posts than other ideological groups.

IVP Donate

Discussions by both polar groups tend to be within their own political affiliation or party. Half of consistent conservatives talk primarily with like-minded conservatives -- 43 percent of the panelists within this group discuss politics with only Republicans.

Many consistent liberals also primarily engage with other liberals (31%) and with Democrats (39%). Panelists with mixed political views said they were more likely to talk politics with conservatives and Republicans than liberals and Democrats.

Negative aspects attributed to the polarization of the country can be showcased by social trends. Of all panelists, 25 percent have responded negatively to social media content and 10 percent have dropped a friend on social media because of political differences. Thirty-two percent of consistent conservatives and 44 percent of consistent liberals have blocked, unfriended, or stopped following someone because of content.

An old adage on consumption reads, "you are what you eat," but in an era of increased partisanship and hyper-socialization, individual consumption can be best described as, "you are what you watch."

 

Image: GU Progressive

Latest articles

Cory Booker
Cory Booker Just Delivered the Longest Senate Speech in U.S. History
Senator Cory Booker of New Jersey made history with a marathon speech on the Senate floor, surpassing 24 hours in a sweeping protest against the policies of former President Donald Trump....
01 Apr, 2025
-
2 min read
Hand in cannabis leaves.
Cannabis Rescheduling Remains Paused Despite Trump Support
A popular and game-changing rescheduling proposal backed by Donald J. Trump to reclassify cannabis from Schedule I to Schedule III under the federal Controlled Substances Act (CSA) remains formally active but administratively paused by a DEA judge....
01 Apr, 2025
-
5 min read
Stack of mail ballots.
New Report Finds Universal Vote at Home States Nearly Double Turnout in 2024 Primaries
The National Vote at Home Institute (NVAHI) released a new report Monday that states with Universal Vote at Home (VAH) saw nearly double the voter turnout in the 2024 primary elections compared to states that didn't offer it....
31 Mar, 2025
-
2 min read