Clinton vs. Paul: Who Would Win over More Independents?

image
Published: 19 Jun, 2014
3 min read

Hillary Clinton and Rand Paul are both likely candidates for the 2016 presidential race. Both parties know they'll win the hardline voters who stay loyal to their party. However, who will have more success with independent voters?

If this race actually comes to fruition, it may turn out to be a race truly decided by Independents.

The hard part, however, is figuring out how many independents will vote. According to a recent Huffington Post article, Hillary wins by a landslide in political standards (52.5% to 41.8%). However, the Huffington Post only cites mainstream polls from sources like MSNBC and Fox. That is hardly an accurate gauge of independent voters.

The most recent polling numbers show that 42 percent of all registered voters in America self-identify as independent. While some analysts and commentators have classified some of these voters as "closet partisans," many are true independents that actually show no allegiance to one party or the other and swing from one party or the other every election. This is telling because it leads us to believe that the issues control their votes and not the party platforms.

So let us consider the issues:

Hillary is associated with several political controversies during her tenure as secretary of state, U.S. senator (NY), First Lady and even before her time on the national stage. Let's not forget the Whitewater scandal. Then we have the most immediate one: Benghazi.

What about her voting record? She did cast an

affirmative vote for the Iraq War in 2002. This may cause many independents who are war-weary to vote for the Libertarian-leaning Rand Paul. However, Hillary could argue that Rand wasn't around for that vote and so his stance against the war isn't valid.

Rand Paul on the other hand, has had a pretty controversy-free career. However, some voters may view his position on limited government as a bit extreme.

According to an ABC News article, Rand Paul would eliminate four federal departments: HUD, Energy, Commerce, and Education. I would be willing to bet that eliminating the Department of Education is going to lose Rand some votes.

IVP Donate

Although public schools are largely funded by state and municipal taxes, voters would likely perceive abolishing the Department of Education as an end to public schools. According to the latest Dept. of Education statistics, over 49.5 million kids are enrolled in American K-12 public schools.

Although there is not any reputable data out there that shows how many independents support public schools, I think it would scare a considerable number of parents who are uninformed about the funding structure of public schools. If they feared that a Rand Paul presidency would harm public schools, they might support Hillary.

What Rand has going for him is his consistent anti-war rhetoric. The American public is war weary and Hillary doesn't have a good track record in regards to the war or armed conflict; not as a U.S. senator or secretary of state.

So in the end, it would be a tough race with no clear overwhelming support from independents. Will we see a more Libertarian-leaning independent voter show up in the 2016 election, or will we see a more Progressive independent voter? I think the performance of the Obama administration over the next two and a half years will decide that.

You Might Also Like

Ballrooms, Ballots, and a Three-Way Fight for New York
Ballrooms, Ballots, and a Three-Way Fight for New York
The latest Independent Voter Podcast episode takes listeners through the messy intersections of politics, reform, and public perception. Chad and Cara open with the irony of partisan outrage over trivial issues like a White House ballroom while overlooking the deeper dysfunctions in our democracy. From California to Maine, they unpack how the very words on a ballot can tilt entire elections and how both major parties manipulate language and process to maintain power....
30 Oct, 2025
-
1 min read
California Prop 50 gets an F
Princeton Gerrymandering Project Gives California Prop 50 an 'F'
The special election for California Prop 50 wraps up November 4 and recent polling shows the odds strongly favor its passage. The measure suspends the state’s independent congressional map for a legislative gerrymander that Princeton grades as one of the worst in the nation....
30 Oct, 2025
-
3 min read
bucking party on gerrymandering
5 Politicians Bucking Their Party on Gerrymandering
Across the country, both parties are weighing whether to redraw congressional maps ahead of the 2026 midterm elections. Texas, California, Missouri, North Carolina, Utah, Indiana, Colorado, Illinois, and Virginia are all in various stages of the action. Here are five politicians who have declined to support redistricting efforts promoted by their own parties....
31 Oct, 2025
-
4 min read