Republican Candidates in CA-4 Must Look Outside Party to Win

image
Published: 18 Jun, 2014
2 min read

California’s primary system was initiated to curb the well-established partisanship in state politics. Following the 2012 elections, the first under the new primary, the state’s strong Democratic lean resulted in a super majority in the state Legislature for Democrats.

Consequently, Republicans will need to rethink how to be competitive in a state with a voting population that is 45 percent Democratic and 20 percent No Party Preference. Yet, the current civil war plaguing the party may significantly lower chances of a successful Republican rebirth.

So, where does this leave voters?

In California's 4th Congressional District, voters are faced with such an intra-party showdown. Incumbent Tom McClintock (R) will take on Art Moore (R) in November's general election. While McClintock remains a tea party favorite, his challenger has portrayed himself as a moderate alternative for voters.

Although McClintock earned more than half of the primary votes, Moore, a military veteran, remains hopeful since he appeals to voters outside of his own political party.

Voters in District 4 are faced with a unique opportunity this fall. Unlike in 2012 election, the primarily Republican district will not have a landslide victory in favor of the incumbent simply because of the R next to his name.

Instead, voters are now able to distinguish between degrees of conservatism in addition to truly focusing on each candidate's merits.

In the new California primary system, the top two candidates advance to the general election regardless of partisanship, and thus calls for moderate candidates or candidates who appeal to a larger variety of voters. Thus, with Jeffrey Gerlach (NPP) pushed out of the general election, almost 21.6 percent of voters are left to choose between the more ideologically-focused McClintock or the more moderate Moore.

This could force McClintock to change his strategy in reaching voters on a wider level.

IVP Donate

Although McClintock's campaign is skeptical of a real challenge to the seat, they have gone on record, commenting on Moore's advance into the general election with, "Moore is Less." Moore's campaign remains hopeful as many of these Northern California voters express their discontent with McClintock's track record.

You Might Also Like

California 2026 Independent Voter Survey
NEW POLL: California Governor’s Race Sees “None of the Above” Beat the Entire Democratic Field
A new statewide poll conducted by the Independent Voter Project finds California’s independent voters overwhelmingly support the state’s nonpartisan primary system and express broad dissatisfaction with the direction of state politics....
12 Jan, 2026
-
4 min read
Disposable Vape Ban SB 762 Jacqui Irwin
This California Disposable Vape Ban Could Devastate The Legal Cannabis Industry Even Further
Good intentions often make for compelling policy. But in practice, consequences rarely fall in line as neatly as the ideas that inspired them....
12 Jan, 2026
-
6 min read
Missouri Republican Denny Hoskins Gerrymandering Manipulation
Missouri Republicans Admit They Skewed Ballot Language to Protect a Rigged Map
Missouri state officials have pulled out all the stops to prevent a veto referendum from getting on the ballot that would overturn a mid-cycle gerrymander. This includes writing a ballot summary that makes it sound like the veto referendum is trying to protect gerrymandering in the state....
13 Jan, 2026
-
4 min read