Frustration over Immigration Reform Builds as Congress, States Fail to Act

Created: 17 April, 2014
Updated: 14 October, 2022
2 min read

As immigration reform stalls in the U.S. Congress with little hope of any movement in the 2014 election year, immigration reform advocates have shifted tactics to both state-level legislation and broad grassroots activism to stop the narrow goal of deportation.

New York once appeared to be a national leader in immigration reform. Legislatures began to debate a Dream Act for the state as early as 2011. The same year, Governor Andrew Cuomo suspended his state’s participation in a federal deportation program.

However, both these measures have languished in recent years, frustrating advocates in New York who hoped for more humane immigration policies at a state-level to counter the federal floundering.

First, the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) decided that states could not opt into the deportation program; they were required to allow federal agents to operate within state borders. New York has also struggled to get the Dream Act passed by the Senate.

The proposed bill would open state tuition programs to undocumented immigrants at both public and private colleges. Many of these children were brought into the country illegally by their parents, but have lived most of their lives in the U.S.; however, they were unable to access the state’s tuition benefits. This bill proposed to change this.

For the past two years, the bill has come before legislatures only to get stuck down in committees and political wrangling over the issue. This year brought a new hope to the bill as Cuomo endorsed it with strong support from NYC Mayor Bill de Blasio as well.

The bill passed the State Assembly in February and headed to the Senate for a vote.

Once again, though, immigration reform advocates had their hopes dashed as the New York State Senate rejected the bill by a mere two voters.

Activists, who had hoped the bill would finally get the votes, were stunned. A spontaneous

protest took to the streets in New York City by disappointed advocates for the bill. These groups promised that in spite of the defeat, they would continue to work for immigration reform.

It is no wonder, though, that advocates, frustrated with both the U.S. Congress and slow rate of state-level reforms are resorting to other tactics. Just this month, a #not1moredeportation campaign was launched which included protests across 40 U.S. cities asking Obama to suspend deportation.

IVP Existence Banner

These groups rallied in front of the White House, advocated to shut down Broadview Detention Center in Chicago, and marched to City Hall in Los Angeles to call on ICE to change its policies. Activists also took to social media, calling on Obama to be on the right side of history and support a "pro-human rights stance" on immigration reform.

Tweets about "#not1moredeportation"

Latest articles

Funding Problems Plague Oakland's New 'Democracy Dollars' Program
Nearly three-quarters of Oakland voters (74%) approved an initiative in 2022 that took a comprehensive approach to campaign finance solutions in the city. However, one of its historic changes is in need of funding if it is going to be implemented by 2026; namely, its "democracy dollars" public finance system....
17 May, 2024
3 min read
Trump-Biden Debate
Did the Major Party Campaigns Just End the Commission on Presidential Debates?
President Joe Biden’s campaign issued a challenge to former President Donald Trump Wednesday to two debates: One in June and one in September. The debates have to be hosted by a news outlet and will not be conducted in front of a crowd....
15 May, 2024
6 min read
Oregon Capitol Building
Only 7% of Voters Have Returned Ballots in Oregon's Closed Primaries
Imagine being part of the largest segment of the registered voting population and being denied the right to an equal vote in elections. Well, millions of voters across the US don't have to imagine this because it is a reality for them in every election cycle. ...
14 May, 2024
3 min read